Skip to comments.Is the American Labor Movement Dying? All Signs Point to Yes.
Posted on 02/09/2022 5:04:16 AM PST by Kaslin
Washington, DC. – Joe Biden likes to talk about how “unions built this country.” And, up to a point, he’s right. From FDR to Nixon, the American labor movement held considerable sway over the nation’s economic destiny.
Since the 70s, a decade marked by economic extremes Biden’s policies are causing us to revisit, unions have been in decline. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports participation in the labor movement to be down across the board. Unionized private sector workers represent just 6.1 percent of the labor force, an all-time low, while the total number of those in unions dropped last year by almost a quarter of a million.
The labor movement has lost a lot of its clout. What remains comes because the rank and file are held captive by the union bosses who extract political contributions from them to what remains of its political influence. To put it another way, it’s the number of dollars they provide to the politicians, not the number of members who can vote that account for what influence remains.
The union bosses would have you believe membership is down because it’s too hard to organize. They want the politicians who are still in their hip pockets to let them boost their numbers by resetting the clock to the days when people had to join a union as a condition of their employment whether they wanted to or not.
It’s an interesting theory but it doesn’t fit the facts. America’s workers no longer need union representation as they once did. Employers in the post-industrial era are smarter, offer better pay and benefits, greater flexibility on the job site, and more input into operations than many union shops allow.
The unions, of course, would argue against this. But what do they have to show in the way of success? The high-profile 2021 effort to organize workers at an Amazon warehouse in Alabama failed when then voted against 2 to 1.
The federal government gave the unions a do-over on that vote, but we’ll see if it changes the outcome. It’s not likely. The continuing decline is evident. Even strikes are becoming problematic as in Colorado, where members of a United Food and Commercial Workers local found themselves betrayed by their president, Kim Cordova, and Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders.
Throughout the month of January, negotiations over a new contract between the King Soopers supermarket chain and UFCW Local 7 became tense amid a strike that restricted access to food and dealt a devastating blow to area residents. All this on top of a Biden economy that has inflation is eating away at rising wages like it hasn’t in decades.
Hours before the strike began, the union rejected an offer by King Soopers to bring the minimum starting wage up to $16 per hour and pay increases of up to $4.50 per hour for its members. For ten days, members of the union sat at home or marched on a picket line while Local 7 President Kim Cordova continued to collect her $200,000+ annual salary while promising she would get a better deal.
The offer eventually a majority of Local 7 members accepted appears to include many of the same proposals Cordova called “concessionary” days earlier according to theWorld Socialist Web Site. That same week, Senator Bernie Sanders hosted a virtual panel that amounted to little more than “damage control for the union” and praised Cordova’s efforts to get a deal that probably could have been had before the strike. If this doesn’t seem fair, it isn’t. Yet it’s happening repeatedly as union bosses like Cordova choose what’s good for the union and its officials over what’s good for the rank-and-file.
We’ve seen this before. In the 1960s, the New York City newspaper unions let several prominent but marginally profitable dailies shut down rather than make concessions that would have kept them open and their members on the job. During the Obama-led reorganization of General Motors, the unions killed an effort by a private sector entrepreneur who wanted to run the Saturn brand as an independent, non-union company. The union survived. The workers didn’t.
Politicians like Biden and Sanders who say the labor movement is dying need to face up to the fact union leaders like Cordova are killing it. It’s not murder. It’s suicide.
I’ve noticed how strongly the Teamsters are in solidarity with their “brothers and sisters” in Canada. Telling, as if we needed more confirmation of what they are.
The labor movement is in very sad state.
The biggest problem is the conflict of interests between union bosses and union members.
Bosses want their plushy jobs, and often disregard rank and file real interests.
By now, the members figured it out, so they are dropping out of unions.
Labor is dead in this country. The Unions are in government.
Didn’t read the article yet, but if it does not include the absolute CORRUPTION of the Teachers’ Unions...then it is meaningless.
It’s a little more general that that. When the article zeros in, it doesn’t on teacher unions and the myriad problems they cause. It’s more focused on the private sector.
If so, it’s a self-inflicted death.
For all practical purposes, Labor is in fact already dead.
Presently unions exist in the main at large corporations where the unions provide a structure upon which a wage and benefits programs can be developed in an orderly manner.
At GM, the UAW is actually in control, but the corporation is dying
Then, that’s a shame.
There is much damage in America from those who “teach.”
Thanks for that information.
Unions are almost extinct in the private sector. They remain popular in the government sector where not working hard is still a key perk.
Since 94% of the workforce is non union there is no real reason why the USA ( like the rest of the world ) put up real protectionist import tariffs. This would promote NON union employment! A win - win.
I didn’t read your post yet, but if it doesn’t include something specific that I want to make a point about...then it is meaningless.
The GOP needs to come into the 21st century and stop viewing workers as the enemy. There are WAY more in the working class then there there are of the globalist GOP Free Traitors...
To some degree it is. Mechanization and importing
manual labor from abroad has change things for sure.
“Labor is dead in this country. The Unions are in government.”
They’re only dead when they are OUTLAWED. If we don’t kill them off, they will rise up again, once the they get the legal protection to start destroying companies, yet again.
America’s workers no longer need union representation as they once did. Employers in the post-industrial era are smarter
What most folks need these days, and have, is a good employment lawyer and the FLSA. Anything and everything an employee could want is contained in that act.
As for the unions, it’s too easy to see how they’ve been bought off.
Paul Hílal, Mantle Ridge and Hunter Harrison went about destroying CSX Transportation over the course of 3-4 years, just like they did the railroad companies in Canada. The RR unions neither said nothing nor did anything.
And I’m thinking the people aren’t as socialist and communist as Sanders and AOC want to pretend they are. Folks don’t have as much in common with the union agendas like they used to as the agendas have gotten more and more radical.
The unions won and are no longer necessary. The predatory excesses of the past have been made illegal.
At least with private sector unions I have the option of taking my business elsewhere.
Which robber barons are the public sector unions protecting the worker from now, we the taxpayer?
Public sector unions are parasitic organisms that continue to bleed us and make our tax burdens absurdly high. They are also funding the communist Democrat Party with your tax dollars, talk about insult to injury! And you don’t think about not paying, wage garnishment and property liens are the penalty you will pay for resisting.
it doesn’t on teacher unions and the myriad problems they cause.
I don’t disagree but union sectors across the board are being
reduced via mechanization, computers, etc. Teachers will be
one seeing reductions as changes develop in the learning sector.
Oh contaire. Many workers need a union. Look at IT workers. With out a STEM union corporation imported replacement workers with H-1B visa scabs and now look, a woke leftists running the on-line world. A STEM union would have put a halt to that.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.