Posted on 05/18/2021 8:42:42 AM PDT by SJackson
In a world in which massive violations of human rights have, tragically, become the norm, why has the hard left focused on one of the least compelling of those causes — namely, the Palestinians? Where is the concern for the Kurds, the Chechens, the Uyghurs, the Tibetans? There are no campus demonstrations on their behalf, no expressions of concern by “the Squad” in Congress, no United Nations resolutions, no recurring op-eds in The New York Times, and no claims that the nations that oppress these groups have no right to exist.
On the merits and demerits of their claims, the Palestinians have the weakest case. They have been offered statehood and independence on numerous occasions: in 1938, 1948, 1967, 2000-2001 and 2008. Israel ended its occupation of the Gaza Strip in 2005. Yet, even now, Palestinian leaders refuse to sit down and negotiate a reasonable two-state solution. As the late Israeli diplomat Abba Eban once aptly put it, the Palestinian leadership never misses an opportunity to miss an opportunity.
Nor are history and morality on their side. The Palestinian leadership allied itself with Nazism and Hitler in the 1940s, with Egyptian tyranny and antisemitism in the 1950s, and with international terrorism from the 1960s forward.
In 1947, the United Nations divided the land that the Romans called Palestine and the Jews called Yisrael into two areas. It provided a sliver of land along the Mediterranean and a non-arable desert called the Negev to the Jews, who were a majority in that area, and a much larger arable area to the Arabs. The Jews declared statehood on their land. Instead of declaring statehood on their land, the Palestinians and surrounding Arab nations declared war. The Arabs lost and the Jews captured more land. As a result of the war, there occurred an exchange of populations: Hundreds of thousands of Arabs left or were forced out of Israel, and hundreds of thousands of Jews left or were forced out of Arab countries and Arab Palestine.
Again, in 1967, the surrounding Arab nations threatened to destroy Israel, which preemptively attacked and occupied the West Bank and Gaza, which it immediately offered to return — with some territorial adjustments necessary for security — in exchange for peace and recognition. The U.N. Security Council issued Resolution 242, which called for a return of captured territories in exchange for peace. Israel accepted. The Arab nations and the Palestinians, however, issued their three infamous “no’s” — no peace, no recognition, no negotiation.
The Kurds have never been offered independence or statehood, despite treaties that promised it. Nor have the Tibetans, the Uyghurs or the Chechens. But the Palestinians have, on multiple occasions since 1938, when their leader told the Peale Commission that the Palestinians don’t want a state — they just want there not to be a Jewish state.
The Palestinian people have suffered more from the ill-advised decisions of their leaders than from the actions of Israel.
Back to the present: Hamas commits a double war crime every time it fires a lethal rocket at Israeli civilians from areas populated by its civilians, who they use as human shields. Israel responds proportionally in self-defense, as President Biden has emphasized. The Israel Defense Forces go to extraordinary lengths to try to minimize civilian casualties among Palestinians, despite Hamas’ policy of using civilian buildings — hospitals, schools, mosques, and high-rise buildings — to store, fire and plan their unlawful rockets and incendiary devices. Yet the hard left blames Israel alone, and many on the center-left create a moral equivalence between democratic Israel and terrorist Hamas.
Why? The answer is clear and can be summarized in one word: Jews.
The enemy of the Kurds, the Tibetans, the Uyghurs and the Chechens are not — unfortunately for them — the Jews. Hence, there is little concern for their plight. If the perceived enemy of the Palestinians were not the Jews, there would be little concern for their plight as well. This was proved by the relative silence that greeted the massacre of Palestinians by Jordan during “Black September” in 1970, or the killings of Palestinian Authority leaders in Gaza during the Hamas takeover in 2007. There has been relative silence, too, about the more than 4,000 Palestinians — mostly civilians— killed by Syria during that country’s current civil war. It is only when Jews or their nation are perceived to be oppressing Palestinians that the left seems to care about them.
While the United States provides financial support for Israel, we also provide massive support for Jordan and Egypt. Even if the United States were to end support for Israel, the demonization of Israel by the hard left would not end.
The left singles out the Palestinians not because of the merits of their case but, rather, because of the alleged demerits of Israel and the double standard universally applied to Jews. That is the sad reality.
Former CIA director John Brennan as much as admitted this double standard when he complained in a tweet about the alleged lack of empathy by Jews: “I always found it difficult to fathom how a nation of people deeply scared by a history replete with prejudice, religious persecution, & unspeakable violence perpetrated against them would not be the empathetic champions of those whose rights & freedoms are still abridged.”
As Seth Frantzman, a writer for the Jerusalem Post, aptly put it: “In his telling of it, he implied that Jews must have special empathy for others while non-Jews have no special need to be empathetic. Brennan has not … held other countries to a higher standard based on the ethnic and religious origins of their citizens … In short, because Jews endured genocide, they have to live according to a higher standard than those who perpetrated genocide.”
This “benevolent” double standard may sound kinder than the malevolent double standard imposed by members of “the Squad” and others, but it has the same effect: it demands that Israel do less to protect its citizens from rockets and terrorism than is demanded from other countries. The same standard must be demanded of Israel as is demanded of other countries defending their citizens. In particular, the same standard must be demanded of Palestinians and their leaders as is demanded of other groups seeking the moral support of good people.
Palestinians go on strike amid airstrikes, rocket fire The Memo: Biden faces choppier waters As of now, the Palestinians have failed to meet that standard.
I support the legitimate rights of Palestinians to a peaceful state, not so much because their history and actions merit it more than others, but because it would be good for peace in the region and for Israel. But I refuse to prioritize it over other more, or equally, compelling claims just because Jews are on the other side.
Because they believe, ironically that Christians, in general, are the biggest supporters of Israel. Even many Jews resent that fact.
Yup. They are biblical deniers.
Just another bunch of oppressed peepL apparently. NOT! 💣🚀🔪
The Left has had a love affair with islam since 9-11-2001 and just like the terrorists, they believe America deserved that tragedy.
The marxists hate the Jews and always have. Therefore anyone else who also hates the Jews can count on the marxists to help them with their cause.
Period.. End of story.
Simple: the left glorifies the creeps to piss off the Jews and Christians.
Yeah, I've always thought it odd that so many of the Hollywood elite Jews never stand up for Israel. Perhaps because the citizens of Israel are generally conservative.
Because the Left hates Jews.
The left hates God. Israel is the chosen land for his chosen people. If Israel exists, God exists. The left cannot allow that concept to exist.
I believe the same is true for radical islam. How could Allah be so powerful but he can’t rid the little country of Israel that is located right in the middle of their territory. That has to drive the radicals completely insane.
If Hamas sneaked some rockets into Hawaii and set them next to a school and launched them at Zuckerberg you would see TheHill’s feedback change it’s tune instanter.
As it is The Hill is still the home of anti-semitic reprobates and child diddlers.
“Why does the hard left glorify the Palestinians?”
There are a lot more Muslims than Jews in the world.
There very well might be US Muslim voters than US Jewish voters in the not so distant future.
Political power matters!
The hard left are anti-Christian and so are the Palestinians.
The Palestinian leadership has not even made a statement that it:
1. desires peace,
2. respects the right of Israel to exist,
3. recognizes that terrorism is a crime against humanity and Islam,
4. has stopped the production of offensive weapons such as rockets,
5. will dismantle all remaining rockets if a cease fire is reached.
Why does the hard left glorify the Palestinians?Like minded dimwits...not a question
Haters of God.
That is why.
Ever couple of years the Palestinians get mad about something and then you have a few months of trading rockets and artillery shells, Israel sends in the troops, the Gaza Strip gets trashed even more, and then it all dies down again until the next time. It’s been that way for decades and it’s never going to change.
Because Israel is the only western style govt in the Middle East and many Israelis are ex-Americans. Israel makes the countries around them look pitiful, the rest are 100 years behind.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.