Posted on 02/22/2021 4:54:58 AM PST by Kaslin
The U.S. House of Representatives has taken up H.R. 40 - Commission to Study and Develop Reparation Proposals for African Americans Act which begs some hard questions three generations after slavery was abolished.
Slavery is not the only springboard for the debate. The history of the Democrat Party, their role in slavery and how they hold a great deal of responsibility for the plight of the African slave during and after slavery cannot be overstated as they now lead Commission discussions with unclean hands, the political descendants of slavery itself.
For the record, the sin of slavery in the U.S. was an industry of the South led by Southern Democrats. The Union Army (from the North) beat the Confederacy in the Civil War giving way to the Emancipation Proclamation and Reconstruction. Democrat President Andrew Johnson refused to comply with the planned reparations in which Union General Sherman’s Special Fields Order 15 (“forty acres and a mule”) provided 400,000 acres to the emancipated slaves, and Southern Democrats imposed a literal hell on the freed African slaves through Black Codes and Jim Crow laws. Let the record reflect these truths.
Further, the Democrats bargained with Republicans over the presidency in 1877 which could not be decided by the Electoral College. Democrats bargained to keep their foot on the necks of the freed slaves who thrived after slavery until the end of Reconstruction in 1877. They bargained to remove federal troops from their states (which included the polling stations) and ended any political representation the freed slaves had garnered during Reconstruction. The Southern Democrats robbed the freed slaves of restorative justice after slavery and to the freedom Abraham Lincoln and the Republican Party birthed.
Slavery was not a part of the founding principles of our nation. Before the Civil War, there were 19 free states and 15 slave states. At the hands of Republicans, slavery was abolished by the Thirteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and was ratified in 1865.
This truth of the U.S. Constitution as it relates to slavery is important to appreciate because those who seek to denigrate the United States as a racist country use the Three-Fifths Clause of the U.S. Constitution to impugn her.
Notwithstanding that some Founding Fathers owned slaves, the Three-Fifths Clause (1787) is the by-product of abolitionists fighting against slave owners who wanted to have a majority representation in Congress by counting the slaves. Rejecting that approach, the bargain was to count each slave as three-fifths thus holding the South at bay from having majority control in the House. The lie that the slave was not considered human can only be attributed to those who dared traffic in slavery and not to the whole of the nation.
If “reparations” is a check, which is the historic application, there are hard questions for those who support reparations for black Americans:
The Democrats were the ones who enslaved Africans. It was not a national policy. Why should anyone other than the descendants of slave-owning Democrats pay reparations? Is this an invoice best sent to the Democrat National Committee?
Blacks owned slaves too. Black plantation owners like Cecile Richards and Antoine Dubuclet of Louisiana to name a few. Surely, they have descendants too. Why should the descendants of blacks who owned slaves get reparations, or are they excluded?
The “Five Civilized Tribes” owned African slaves. These tribes included the Cherokee, Chickasaw. Choctaw, Creek, and Seminole. The Thirteenth Amendment did not free their slaves, only the Treaties of 1866 did so after the war. How do we handle this hidden history?
White Union soldiers fought to end slavery. Should their descendants be required to pay the price for something they died to abolish?
If elected officials would stop doling out “feel-good” checks and start holding all Americans accountable to accessing the American Dream, the years of debate on reparations would have no place. Opportunity is priceless and is the best form of reparation. Opportunity can start afresh in America with enacting School Choice and ensuring equal access to capital for all Americans. If you want to make a difference, these are better starting points. Call them reparations if you like.
bflr
These folks are over thinking this. We had a civil war to solve the problem.
We dont need a commission.
I am not sure extending a cash payment to people based on race is a good idea. We would have to start slicing genetics and categorizing people. That’s been tried before. Not sure it’s a good idea.
“...Commission to Study and Develop Reparation Proposals for African Americans Act which begs some hard questions three generations after slavery was abolished....”
********************************
Three generations? Slavery was abolished in 1865. That’s 155 years ago according to my old school math where you get the right answers.
Since a generation is considered to be 20 - 30 years, that’s significantly more than 3 generations ago.
Both Obama and Harris are proven descendants of slave owners. They should be the first to pay!
A generation is usually understood to be twenty years. It has been 155 years. I would say more like 5 generations.
So grant all certified AfricanAmericans who can prove descent through at least one line from a slave on $100,000 per annum incomes for life. A very few who are not already prosperous will prosper. The rest will participate in an explosion of drug commerce and mayhem. Most will also be scammed out of the money and left as large debtors.
This reparations drumbeat is so transparent......nothing but a shakedown.
People WHO HAVE NEVER BEEN slaves are shaking down people WHO HAVE NEVER owned slaves.
I learned yesterday that I have a direct ancestor who came from England was granted land in Virginia and left a slave, George to his daughter and soninlaw.
The Virginia family I knew barely owned one horse which is why they all enlisted in the VA cavalry.
How about we just stop with all this race crap?
Reparation or whatever will never be enough and all this race BS will never stop. The road we are currently going down is seriously dangerous.
Just give every black a democrat politician as an indentured servant.....
Blacks get something for nothing, which is what reparations is all about.
And democrats get to pay for the sins of their racist leaders, past and present.
PROBLEM SOLVED!
Slavery was a terrible institution and I believe it actually handicapped the development of the United States in some ways. That having been said, anyone who is descended from slaves, owes their very existence to slavery.
If not for slavery, their ancestors would almost certainly have never met and reproduced. The descendants of these slaves would never have been born.
Like my plan:
1. Pay reparations to those blacks who can prove they are descendants of slaves
2. Make the descendants of the owners of slaves foot the bill for this...like Kamala Harris
Why don’t descendants of slaves pay reparations to the descendants of union veterans who were killed or maimed during the war that set them free?
cash out of my pocket no,,
state & fed tax breaks, maybe ..
Quiet them with reparations from the stock market.
Not redeemable until age 25.
Make them partners in MAGA!
See above. Sorry for the misspelling...
Wrong.
The whole nation was heavily involved from its inception.
All part of their new push for wealth redistribution and their socialist dreams. It hasn't gone unnoticed that all Whites are now White Supremacists.
Shouldn’t reparations come solely from Democrats? After all, they were the slave owners and secessionists?
Don’t Democrats owe Republicans reparations for starting the Civil War?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.