I don't know how this guy became your hero, but to me he looks like a poster child for The Peter Principle. He did fine till he got to this level, and then broke down.
Ive seen it happen a couple of times.
Full blown stressed out melt down. Career ending stuff.
The key is the manic five page letter. At that level, equal to a corporate VP....they dont communicate like that.
As you all know by now, the Navy secretary has apologized for his remarks. For calling Captain Crozier naïve and stupid.
I also saw where President Trump is likely to weigh in on this situation.
I understand the mindset of obeying orders without question. I understand your disgust for the captain. But as Ive always said this situation was not what it appeared to be. This is a fluid situation I think then and I think now the captain was right.