Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

If You’re Not Grateful To The United States, Why Are You Here?
The Federalist ^ | 08/14/2019 | Casey Chalk

Posted on 08/14/2019 7:57:58 AM PDT by SeekAndFind

Earlier this month, the Washington Post featured an op-ed entitled “I am an uppity immigrant. Don’t expect me to be ‘grateful,’” by New York University professor Suketu Mehta, an author who recently published a book arguing that “immigration is a form of reparations” for past American crimes.

In the article, Mehta accuses America of stealing “the futures of the people who are now arriving at its borders,” of causing many immigrants “to move in the first place,” and of “despoil[ing] their homelands and mak[ing] them unsafe and unlivable.” He censures the West for “despoil[ing] country after country through colonialism, illegal wars, rapacious corporations and unchecked carbon emissions.”

Mehta asserts, for such reasons, that he’s “entitled” to live in the United States. Yet a few brief historical reflections will demonstrate that immigration as reparations is a bit more complicated than Mehta lets on. Moreover, no one, whether first-generation immigrants or direct descendants of voyagers on the Mayflower, deserves to be here. Being American is a gift for which every citizen should be inordinately grateful.

No Country Is Free of Guilt for Horrible Crimes

First, Mehta’s conception of American history, identity, and foreign policy is quite skewed. He’s indeed right to criticize the United States’ many disastrous and damaging blunders around the world, from the Horn of Africa to the Levant to Latin America. Yet it’s ludicrous to claim that all the problems of these nations and peoples lie at the United States’ feet, or that the United States’ egregious errors somehow necessitate reparations via immigration. As Jeremy Black in “Imperial Legacies” astutely argues, the countries that have suffered at the hands of American foreign policy had plenty of problems before a single American boot or dollar ever crossed their border.

Somalia, the original homeland of Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., was impoverished and violent long before the United States got involved there during the Cold War. European colonialists caused many of Somalia’s problems, as they did for many other African nations. But other problems, such as female circumcision, slavery, and war, long predate the arrival of Europeans.

Likewise, long before the U.S. government and American companies sought to manipulate the banana republics of Latin America, the region was a mess following centuries of rapacious Spanish and Portuguese imperialism. Brazil was the last country to allow slavery, in 1888 — 20 years after America’s Emancipation Proclamation.

Again, prior to the Spanish and Portuguese, Latin America could be just as cruel. Ask the many conquered peoples who served as a centuries-long source of victims for Aztec human sacrifice.

Every nation’s hands are bloody in world history and geopolitics. Certainly, America shares in the blame. Yet it is hardly the only culprit. Moreover, those who attack the legacy of imperialism hardly have a word of criticism for their own cultures’ misdeeds, be it the violent repression of ethnic minorities, conquering of other peoples, or theft of resources.

The Problems With Reparations

Consider Mehta, an Indian American. Why, exactly, would he qualify for “reparations”? America never ruled India nor had any significant foreign intervention there. Moreover, Mehta is notably silent on the many evils Indian society and its caste system have caused for its own people — 200 million Indians are Dalits, or “untouchables,” who are ruthlessly discriminated against.

India is itself an imperial power, from its treatment of its Muslim minority to its violent repression of Sikh sovereignty movements. Anyone who studies Indian history, whether modern or pre-colonial, knows the subcontinent has always been a brutal place to live.

The idea that groups should pay reparations for ancestral misdeeds raises the question of how far back we must go to seek reparations for ancient offenses by one group against another. Should Japan pay for its use of “comfort women”? Should Muslim North African nations pay reparations to European countries for the Barbary slave trade of the 16th to 17th centuries, which enslaved more than 1 million Europeans?

The fact of the matter is that Mehta can only make such an argument within a construct such as America, where many citizens have a conscience and think maybe they should do something to atone for past misdeeds. I don’t see Turkey exhibiting much interest in reparations for its genocidal murder of Armenians and other ethnic Christian minorities, nor Japan for its rape and pillaging across the Pacific.

Indeed, both countries, and others, aggressively try to ignore or rewrite these narratives precisely to shift blame elsewhere. America may not be perfect, but we are far more honest about our mistakes and willing to make amends than most of the world is.

Be Grateful, not ‘Uppity’

This brings us to the second part of the response to Mehta, the “uppity immigrant.” Thankfully, many immigrants and descendants of immigrants in the United States do not harbor the grudges Mehta holds against his adopted homeland, nor believe America “owes” them anything. Nor do they think they must grovel at some person or groups who supposedly have more reason to call themselves American.

Every person born in America, or who obtains citizenship, is indeed a citizen with certain unalienable rights. But that doesn’t mean we should vainly claim to be “entitled” to them, especially when much of the globe mocks the rights our First Amendment guarantees, not to mention the rest of the Bill of Rights.

As the saying goes, “Freedom isn’t free.” That we were born here or became citizens is a gift, a result of a combination of circumstances largely out of our control. Mehta’s family, as with mine, might just as easily have been denied entry when it approached American shores.

My ancestors emigrated from Ireland and Poland, nations that also saw their fair share of brutal oppression, violence, and intolerance. They didn’t perceive their new status as citizens of this glorious country as something to which they were entitled. They were simply glad to be welcomed in.

And they were grateful. Profoundly grateful. They instilled that sense of gratefulness in me. Unlike Mehta, I would never say I deserve to live in a country as wonderful as the United States. It is a gift, bequeathed to me by my family, by those earlier inhabitants who welcomed my ancestors here, and by God.

Old and New Americans Should Unify

Ultimately, a proper give-and-take should exist between those who have been in America for several generations and those who more recently became citizens. Of course, those with deep American roots should not antagonize newer Americans with threats to “go home,” if by this they mean certain people legally allowed entry into the United States don’t belong. This, as I’ve argued above, reflects an ignorance of the fact that all Americans should be humbled and grateful to live here.

“Older Americans,” however, should expect “newer Americans” to learn, appreciate, and honor the culture and mores of our land. American identity is indeed unique. Certainly, it shifts with each generation, but it also has remained quite stable in its beliefs and customs over the last few centuries. As Thomas Sowell argues, “older Americans” should also recognize and appreciate the talents and customs of “newer Americans” who make our land better, smarter, and more interesting.

I have met many recent immigrants as classmates, as coworkers, and as business owners, who recognize the blessings and opportunities of our country. They bear no shame for their inherited nation, despite its many imperfections. Many promote sports teams with supposedly “racist” names, gladly honor “old white men” of American history on their walls, and have even embraced the alleged “oppressor religion” of Christianity. I know many who harbor no ill will toward America for its role in their own countries’ problems. Indeed, in many respects, it was America that saved them from oppressive, violent regimes.

Rather than ridicule America’s past, as if the travesties of U.S. history nullify its soaring glories, these new citizens have gladly and willingly embraced a part of its cultural inheritance in their chosen profession. For America to persevere, we’ll need a lot less of Mehta’s immigrant “uppityness” and a lot more humble appreciation for America and its political and cultural traditions.


Casey Chalk is a graduate student at the Notre Dame Graduate School of Theology at Christendom College.


TOPICS: Constitution/Conservatism; Culture/Society; Philosophy
KEYWORDS: gratitude; immigration; usa
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-29 next last

1 posted on 08/14/2019 7:57:58 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Free stuff?


2 posted on 08/14/2019 7:58:45 AM PDT by SkyDancer ( ~ Just Consider Me A Random Fact Generator ~ Eat Sleep Fly Repeat ~)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Because they want America’s wealth and power—but not its ideals.


3 posted on 08/14/2019 8:03:21 AM PDT by Savage Beast (When the Light of Truth threatens to expose corruption, it's the corrupt who try to extinguish it.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

At our county fair here in very liberal Sonoma County there were T-shirts aplenty for sale, and being worn(!) that said “If you’re ashamed of this flag, I’ll help you pack”.


4 posted on 08/14/2019 8:06:36 AM PDT by RedStateRocker (We had entirely enough government in 1789.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

To destroy.


5 posted on 08/14/2019 8:06:58 AM PDT by null and void (Heaven has an impenetrable wall, and a welcoming gate for those qualified, Hell is wide open.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Send him back.

No liars, that is not “racist”. I couldn’t give less of a crap what he looks like. It’s all about his behavior. This is not someone who makes the country a better place. As such and since he is not a citizen, has had no right to be here. I’d say the same if it were a blue eyed blonde haired Scandinavian. Just try me if you doubt it.


6 posted on 08/14/2019 8:07:01 AM PDT by FLT-bird
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

It's all about the Benjamins.
7 posted on 08/14/2019 8:12:48 AM PDT by conservative98
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SkyDancer
When you have people like this in the University System
New York University professor Suketu Mehta this sort of tripe will continue. I am not sure from the article if this professor and I use that term loosely is an immigrant or not but my guess he was and I see the same sort of “uppity” mentality is common with the Indians I work around here in the Seattle area and in tech. My family has been here since 1690 and I am sorry if this offends but I agree with the post sentiment if you are not grateful to be in this country why are you here? The mentality of people coming here is nauseating and offensive to me at times and to be honest I don't see a change coming anytime soon.
8 posted on 08/14/2019 8:13:03 AM PDT by Nuke From Orbit
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

If You’re Not Grateful To The United States, Why Are You Here?
____________________________________________________

To take over, using our laws, universities, media, etc.


9 posted on 08/14/2019 8:14:43 AM PDT by choctaw man (Good ole Andrew Jackson, or You're the Reason God Made Oklahoma...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Trying to use logic and common sense to get a point across to the anti-America, hate-whitey crowd is a losing proposition.

They cannot be appeased.


10 posted on 08/14/2019 8:16:28 AM PDT by MichaelCorleone (Jesus Christ is not a religion. He's the Truth.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

We need to start rejecting immigrants who hate America and Americans.

NO foreigner is ENTITLED to come here.


11 posted on 08/14/2019 8:19:53 AM PDT by Lurkinanloomin (Natural Born Citizen Means Born Here Of Citizen Parents_Know Islam, No Peace-No Islam, Know Peace)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

They are here to take advantage of us. It is that simple. Many people hate us and what we stand for but they still come here legally and illegally to take advantage of what we have.

In the 70s I went to college with a fair number of Iranian students. I was shocked to find out they hated the United States with a passion. They openly said we were stupid and lazy, and were very opposed to females like me working and attending college. They were here to get an education, and that was it. They never missed a chance to tell us how they felt about our country, our way of life- not bashful at all about being hateful and rude.

This was before the Iranian hostage crisis, I actually went to college thinking Iran was our friend thanks to the media and politicians of the time. I have to say when the shah was thrown out and later they took our people hostage I was not at all surprised.

Many of the new legal immigrants and illegal aliens coming here are the same; they hate us and our way of life. They are here to take advantage, they have no intention of assimilating or contributing to this country. We have socialists welcoming them with open arms, who don’t seem to have a clue what they are welcoming.


12 posted on 08/14/2019 8:19:59 AM PDT by Tammy8
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

What he is saying, “Give me free stuff because I am non-white and therefore I deserve anything I want to take from the whites that BUILT this country.


13 posted on 08/14/2019 8:21:05 AM PDT by Agatsu77
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

These are not immigrants, the proper term is locust


14 posted on 08/14/2019 8:22:27 AM PDT by dsrtsage (For Leftists, World History starts every day at breakfast)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

New York University should have to change their name to “New York School of Snowflake production, reparations and liberal indoctrination.


15 posted on 08/14/2019 8:23:10 AM PDT by Agatsu77
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

The wars in Central America ended instantly when the Iron Curtain collapsed and the Soviet Union imploded.


16 posted on 08/14/2019 8:24:49 AM PDT by marron
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

To destroy us.


17 posted on 08/14/2019 8:31:36 AM PDT by exnavy (american by birth and choice, I love this country!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind
Hey, Mehta:

As an immigrant you are not entitled to anything -- certainly no reparations for your perceived injustices and your "right" to be "uppity" -- nothing other than the opportunity to live in freedom in our great Republic. I don't care where you came from or what you think about America's history -- in fact, based on what you have written I don't care what you think about anything.

What I do care about is your mental instability brought about -- at least in part -- by your hatred of Americans and by your ingratitude -- the ugliest of human emotions -- toward America. My recommendation is that you go back to wherever you came from, curl up into a little ball and cry your ungrateful eyes out feeling sorry for pitiful existence.

18 posted on 08/14/2019 8:34:03 AM PDT by glennaro
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Bump


19 posted on 08/14/2019 8:34:19 AM PDT by foreverfree
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Antiamerican seditionists are neither due sanctuary refuge or citizenship.


20 posted on 08/14/2019 8:35:30 AM PDT by a fool in paradise (Denounce DUAC - The Democrats Un-American Activists Commitee)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-29 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson