That must not be true for every troop - unless things changed in the 2000's. In the troop my sons belonged to, up to around 4 years ago, their summer camp had archery and rifle ranges. They were encouraged to have pocketknives. (One of my sons brought home a large folding knife from camp once.) And we mothers (mostly) weren't allowed to be as involved as the fathers.
What more of a vote of confidence does one need?
Rank | Merit Badge | 2017 earned |
1 | First Aid | 69,563 |
2 | Swimming | 62,057 |
3 | Citizenship in the World | 55,917 |
4 | Environmental Science | 55,703 |
5 | Citizenship in the Nation | 52,949 |
6 | Cooking | 51,004 |
7 | Camping | 50,871 |
8 | Communication | 50,503 |
9 | Personal Fitness | 50,428 |
10 | Personal Management | 49,287 |
11 | Family Life | 48,774 |
12 | Citizenship in the Community | 48,736 |
13 | Emergency Preparedness | 43,351 |
14 | Fingerprinting | 38,989 |
15 | Rifle Shooting | 37,796 |
16 | Leatherwork | 35,490 |
17 | Archery | 35,301 |
18 | Wood Carving | 32,943 |
19 | Wilderness Survival | 30,814 |
20 | Kayaking | 30,466 |
21 | Chess | 26,919 |
22 | Canoeing | 26,052 |
23 | Fishing | 24,343 |
24 | Art | 21,567 |
25 | Lifesaving | 20,748 |
26 | Shotgun Shooting | 19,703 |
27 | Space Exploration | 18,994 |
28 | Mammal Study | 18,715 |
29 | Geology | 18,674 |
30 | Climbing | 18,356 |
31 | Indian Lore | 17,003 |
32 | Astronomy | 15,702 |
33 | Basketry | 15,406 |
34 | Robotics | 15,031 |
35 | Aviation | 14,347 |
36 | Small Boat Sailing | 14,182 |
37 | Pioneering | 13,870 |
38 | Game Design | 13,810 |
39 | Photography | 13,550 |
40 | Metalwork | 12,990 |
41 | Weather | 12,690 |
42 | Geocaching | 12,604 |
43 | Engineering | 11,773 |
44 | Fire Safety | 11,746 |
45 | Orienteering | 11,742 |
46 | Fish & Wildlife Management | 11,615 |
47 | Nature | 11,586 |
48 | Forestry | 11,456 |
49 | Welding | 10,656 |
50 | Music | 10,592 |
51 | Chemistry | 10,248 |
52 | Automotive Maintenance | 10,205 |
53 | Search and Rescue | 10,107 |
54 | Motor Boating | 9,517 |
55 | Soil and Water Conservation | 9,484 |
56 | Moviemaking | 9,262 |
57 | Electricity | 9,245 |
58 | Digital Technology | 8,768 |
59 | Sculpture | 8,715 |
60 | Horsemanship | 8,641 |
61 | Rowing | 8,239 |
62 | Pottery | 7,940 |
63 | Oceanography | 7,763 |
64 | Electronics | 7,524 |
65 | Signs, Signals and Codes | 7,364 |
66 | Sustainability | 7,295 |
67 | Snow Sports | 7,267 |
68 | Hiking | 7,084 |
69 | Public Speaking | 7,035 |
70 | Pulp and Paper | 6,879 |
71 | Archaeology | 6,876 |
72 | Crime Prevention | 6,721 |
73 | Nuclear Science | 6,702 |
74 | Railroading | 6,663 |
75 | Sports | 6,556 |
76 | Reptile and Amphibian Study | 6,053 |
77 | Scouting Heritage | 5,916 |
78 | Salesmanship | 5,908 |
79 | Radio | 5,840 |
80 | Cycling | 5,742 |
81 | Traffic Safety | 5,689 |
82 | American Heritage | 5,496 |
83 | Animation | 5,462 |
84 | Law | 5,402 |
85 | Disabilities Awareness | 5,239 |
86 | Genealogy | 5,213 |
87 | Woodwork | 5,212 |
88 | Bird Study | 4,965 |
89 | Mining in Society | 4,673 |
90 | Fly Fishing | 4,597 |
91 | Plumbing | 4,398 |
92 | Pets | 4,289 |
93 | Scholarship | 4,171 |
94 | Collections | 4,140 |
95 | Programming | 4,138 |
96 | Coin Collecting | 3,930 |
97 | Animal Science | 3,848 |
98 | Architecture | 3,654 |
99 | Medicine | 3,561 |
100 | Reading | 3,524 |
101 | Backpacking | 3,498 |
102 | Entrepreneurship | 3,473 |
103 | Home Repairs | 3,432 |
104 | Inventing | 3,296 |
105 | Safety | 3,280 |
106 | Golf | 3,248 |
107 | Painting | 3,222 |
108 | Dentistry | 3,135 |
109 | Graphic Arts | 3,066 |
110 | Water Sports | 2,966 |
111 | Whitewater | 2,832 |
112 | Athletics | 2,754 |
113 | Energy | 2,749 |
114 | Dog Care | 2,661 |
115 | Insect Study | 2,644 |
116 | Model Design and Building | 2,564 |
117 | Truck Transportation | 2,466 |
118 | Veterinary Medicine | 2,451 |
119 | Theater | 2,332 |
120 | Farm Mechanics | 2,307 |
121 | American Cultures | 2,298 |
122 | Textile | 2,205 |
123 | Plant Science | 2,107 |
124 | Exploration | 2,090 |
125 | Scuba Diving | 1,842 |
126 | Public Health | 1,798 |
127 | Skating | 1,785 |
128 | Landscape Architecture | 1,483 |
129 | Gardening | 1,450 |
130 | Composite Materials | 1,407 |
131 | Journalism | 1,127 |
132 | Drafting | 1,119 |
133 | Stamp Collecting | 954 |
134 | American Labor | 901 |
135 | Surveying | 863 |
136 | American Business | 613 |
137 | Bugling | 454 |
138 | Cinematography | 231 |
139 | Computers | 207 |