Posted on 11/12/2014 8:04:14 AM PST by FlJoePa
Court documents filed in Pennsylvania show that the NCAA and investigators from a firm hired by Penn State University to conduct a wholly independent investigation of the university's handling of the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse scandal worked closely in the investigation.
The firm, led by former FBI chief Louis B. Freeh, published damning conclusions about Penn State's "lack of institutional control" that were used by the NCAA as the basis for its sweeping sanctions against Penn State in July 2012.
The court documents filed Tuesday but released publicly Wednesday, obtained by "Outside the Lines," strongly suggest the NCAA provided an investigative blueprint to Freeh. Correspondence between Freeh and the NCAA began less than two weeks after Freeh's firm was hired by Penn State, with a Nov. 30, 2011, request from NCAA president Mark Emmert to speak by phone with Freeh.
From then on, correspondence and meetings between the groups continued, the documents show:
• On Dec. 7, 2011, Freeh and his top deputies met with the NCAA's general counsel, Donald Remy, Julie Roe Lach, then vice president of enforcement for the NCAA, Jonathan Barrett, outside counsel for the Big Ten, and other officials for three hours at the Nittany Lion Inn on the university's State College campus.
• On Dec. 19, 2011, Remy solicited input from a Freeh partner about the text of a letter the NCAA was intending to send to Penn State.
• Less than two weeks later, on Jan. 7, 2012, NCAA lawyers and enforcement officials hosted a two-hour video-conference call for 15 to 17 of Freeh's investigators, described by one of them in email as an "education session." In all, there were 13 conference calls with the NCAA during the course of Freeh's investigation.
(Excerpt) Read more at espn.go.com ...
This is the tip of the iceberg. Much more damning information will be released in the coming days - as well as emmert's deposition.
Say goodbye to the ncaa and freeh as you know them. "Independent investigation" my ass. This was scripted from the start. Great day to be a Penn Stater.
In before the “Joe Paterno didn’t do enough” crowd.
Yeah, Penn State should be really proud. They should put their Sandusky statue back up.
So, a political solution to make the perception go away—no better than the process used by the PSU Board of Trustees. All about PR.
Let the facts continue to come out, and restore the win-loss records to the student athletes who earned them on the field. When are those trials of the admins going to happen?
Jesse Jackson would be proud of the “shakedown” of $60,000,000.00 the NCAA and Freeh engineered against Penn State.
“Former FBI Director Louis Freeh is now working as legal council to Saudi Arabia’s Prince Bandar, defending him in a corruption investigation launched by the U.S. Department of Justice that accuses a British defense contractor of funneling billions of dollars in payments and gifts to Bandar so that he could buy himself an airplane (which he had painted in Dallas Cowboy colors) and refurbish his royal palaces.”
Emmert will be fired and Freeh’s reputation ruined in the eyes of most people. Personally, I never did trust him.
The NCAA is going to lose, and lose BIG. They had no right, nor authority to get involved in this case since there was no clear violation of an NCAA rule. It was/is a criminal case against the perps and those involved in the cover-up.
Paterno knew or should have known what Sandusky was doing. Nothing will ever chnge that fact.
Thanks for posting this.
“Thanks for posting this.”
yes!
and truth will prevail where pain is taken to bring it to light
For those still clinging (bitterly) to theories of a coverup and that “Joe knew”...your days of clinging are coming to an end.
This is the tip of the iceberg.
As I’ve said all along, anyone placing faith in the integrity of louis freeh over Joe Paterno is making a grave mistake.
Freeh is going to be burnt toast when his report is exposed for what it is - a fabrication done at the behest of the 11-9-11 PSU b.o.t. in an effort to justify their firing of JVP.
But cling on!
Another reminder - These emails in Corman’s filing are the ones the ncaa CHOSE to make public! There are 477 emails that Judge Covey is privately reviewing, and she will decide which of those (or all of them) will be made public.
Sheesh, I wonder what’s in them.
Also, look for new CEO’s at both BNY Mellon (Peetz) and Merck (Frazier). They (PSU b.o.t. members) are in this up to their eyeballs. Surma (former ceo US Steel) has already resigned his b.o.t. position and was canned from US Steel (to the delight of stockholders).
Corman was just elected majority leader in the PA house today. Good conservative guy that should keep Wolf in check.
Penn State fired their woman’s basketball coach for not allowing gays on her team.
It was Rene Portland, a good lady.
Not sure what that has to do with this, but ok...Rene also didn’t win enough ncaa tournament games imo.
“The firm, led by former FBI chief Louis B. Freeh”
Ah Louis, the Butcher of Waco.
From the Daily Collegian:
NCAA emails show communication with Freeh, community reacts
Share on facebook Share on twitter Share on pinterest_share More Sharing Services 3
By Erin McCarthy and Morganne Mallon | Collegian Staff Writers | Posted 10 hours ago
UPDATE: 6:40 p.m.
Alumni-elected trustees Al Lord and Bob Jubelirer were both frustrated by Penn State’s public response to the newly released NCAA emails.
In two separate interviews, Lord and Jubelirer both used the same word — “embarrassment” — to describe the university’s statement, which asserted it was public knowledge that the NCAA monitored the progress of Freeh’s investigation.
“It flies in the face of what Barron said last week” — in response to other NCAA emails indicating the NCAA tried to bluff Penn State — Lord said.
Lord was talking about the statement in which university president Eric Barron and Board of Trustees Chairman Keith Masser said they “find it deeply disturbing that NCAA officials in leadership positions would consider bluffing one of their member institutions.”
Jubelirer voiced similar frustrations — with the university’s Wednesday statement, and with the board members who did not vote in favor of Lord’s proposal to reexamine the Freeh Report last month.
And he called for action against Freeh.
“One of the things we should do is sue Louis Freeh,” Jubelirer said. “That report was totally flawed.”
In light of Wednesday’s NCAA emails — and more that will likely be unsealed in lawsuits — Lord said he is confident all the sanctions will be rescinded, including the wins vacated from late head football coach Joe Paterno.
Jublierer said he also wants the NCAA to give back the fines the uiniversity paid it.
“This is a national story and one that is far from over,” Jubelirer said. “If you tried to write a movie about this, I’m not sure people would believe this.”
UPDATE: 5:00 p.m.
State College criminal defense attorney Matt McClenahen said he believes there is a possibility the NCAA could be charged for theft by extortion in relation to its handling of Penn State following the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse case.
If it is determined the NCAA had no right to impose the sanctions yet threatened Penn State with the death penalty unless the terms of the sanctions were complied with, “that sounds like theft by extortion,” McClenahen said.
The emails released today make it appear Freeh was working under the guidance of the NCAA, who were trying to dictate what Freeh’s report would include, he said.
“The irony of the situation is, if they didn’t challenge the Endowment Act, none of this would be happening now,” McClenahen said. “There’s a saying that ‘pigs get fat, hogs get slaughtered.’ Not only did they engage in egregious, outrageous conduct, they set themselves up to be found out after the fact when they could have swept it under the rug.”
If the Attorney General makes the decision to go forth with extortion charges, the decision would not be made until after the NCAA, Corman and McCord’s case goes to trial in January, he said.
UPDATE: 3:34 p.m.
Penn Staters for Responsible Stewardship, an alumni group who has been critical of the board’s decisions in the aftermath of the Sandusky case, said the newly released emails confirm the public was misled.
“The Penn State community and the wider general public were led to believe that Louis Freeh was hired to provide an objective, independent assessment of how a pedophile could have gone undetected so long; and to learn how to prevent it from ever happening again,” Elizabeth Morgan, co-founder of PS4RS, said in an emailed statement through spokeswoman Maribeth Roman Schmidt.
“Sadly, with today’s news, we have learned that the real objective was to place the blame on Penn State football so that the NCAA could hand down harsh sanctions and thereby prop up its faltering image.”
At a special Penn State Board of Trustees meeting last month, alumni-elected trustee Al Lord — who is backed by PS4RS — discussed his proposal to reexamine Freeh’s Report.
The proposal was rejected after receiving only nine votes, all of which came from alumni-elected trustees.
Wednesday, PS4RS had harsh words for Freeh.
“Louis Freeh obscured the lessons that should have been learned from this tragedy,” Morgan said, “and did a terrible disservice to children everywhere.”
UPDATE: 2:20 p.m.
Communication between the NCAA and Freeh group began as early of November of 2011 and continued after Freeh’s report was released, according to court documents.
In documents received by the court on Tuesday, Sen. Jake Corman and state Treasurer Rob McCord responded to the NCAA cross motion in which the NCAA asked the court to prevent an inquiry into their contacts with the Freeh Group, according to court documents.
The NCAA asked the court to prevent the release of the contacts, which Corman and McCord called “extensive and substantive,” because the Freeh investigation was “entirely independent from the NCAA,” according to court documents.
However, Corman and McCord provided the court with a 104 page document detailing the communication between the NCAA and the Freeh Group and advised the court that the NCAA’s claim of only having periodic contact with the Freeh Group “should bear no weight,” according to court documents.
In a statement to ESPN, Donald Remy, the Chief Legal Officer of the NCAA, said Corman’s statements are a “mischaracterization of the evidence and “are inconsistent with the facts,” and that he believes the communication between the Freeh Group and the NCAA was consistent with the NCAA’s “commitment to monitor the progress of [the] investigation.”
Corman and McCord said as early as Nov. 30, 2011, Remy reached out to Omar McNeill of the Freeh Group to arrange a phone call between NCAA President Mark Emmert and Louis Freeh. In the following month the NCAA arranged to meet with members of the Freeh Group in State College, according to court documents.
In a Dec. 5, 2011 email, it was stated the NCAA was looking into “collaborating with the Freeh Group’s investigation,” according to court documents.
Later, the Freeh Group sent McNeill a list of questions for use in the Penn State investigation and McNeill solicited from the NCAA a list of potential witnesses and database search terms for the investigation, according to court documents.
In December of 2011, the NCAA, the Freeh Group and the Big Ten began “scheduling and having a series of weekly conference calls to discuss Penn State” that continued regularly during the time Freeh’s report was released on July 12, 2012 and even beyond, according to court documents.
Original story: 11:26 a.m.
The NCAA and those hired by Penn State to independently investigate the university’s handling of the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse case worked together, according to court documents obtained by ESPN’s “Outside the Lines.”
The emails show former FBI director Louis Freeh’s investigators corresponded and met with NCAA officials throughout the investigation. In July 2012, the NCAA levied sanctions on Penn State, based on the findings of Freeh’s Report.
The documents were released publicly Wednesday as part of the discovery phase in state Sen. Jake Corman’s lawsuit against the NCAA.
“It has been public knowledge for almost three years that the University had agreed that the NCAA and the Big Ten Conference would monitor the progress of the Freeh investigation,” the university said in an emailed statement through spokeswoman Lisa Powers. “While the NCAA may have made suggestions to the Freeh Group with respect to its investigation, the scope of the Freeh investigation was established by the Penn State Board of Trustees, as set forth in the Freeh engagement letter, not by the NCAA. “
“The University’s preliminary review of the NCAA’s proposed questions suggests that there are many proposed questions that are not addressed in the final July 12, 2012 report.”
Check back with The Daily Collegian for updates.
To email reporter: ekm5162@psu.edu. Follow her on Twitter at @ErinMcPSU
It’s called a “point”. Try to have one next time.
Thanks.
I guess the point is that louis freeh is about the most despicable liar for hire the world has produced. I just presented you with yet another example of why he is rightfully placed in that category.
Yep. He belongs in the same category as JoePa does A despicable liar who covers up for heinous criminals. Two sides of the same coin. One covered up for a guy who buggered children and the other covered up for one who burned them alive.
L
Nice try. Enjoy your last few days of your unwarranted assassination of JVP’s character.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.