[Ratman83]

You are a "newbie".

Wow, so mature.

As far as your ascertain that he violated her rights show me where he did this, he was not charged with it nor has he been sued over it. Once again you are blowing smoke.

He was moving out.

Key word in that sentence “was”, not had.

[muawiyah]

His stuff was in his truck in front of the apartment building. Guy was GONE ~ new residence elsewhere.

Minute he stepped out of there to load his vehicle she was the sole resident (although a landlord might have made a claim on him for damages and such, but you could do that to any casual visitor as well).

The real dispute here was domestic in nature ~ but she called the cops ~ as was her right, and he decided he had to interfere in the process.

[muawiyah]

BTW, your argument is right out of Sharia Law ~ I'm pointing to the notion you have that if someone hasn't been sued he didn't cause damage or violate rights.

Does not compute in American law.