It’s definitely a toad. As weird as it may sound, when I was a kid, I wanted to be a herpatologist when I grew up. From age 4 or so to about age 11 or 12. I knows me my toads, and that there is one of ‘em. Pretty little gal, too. I’d be willing to bet she made some very lucky male rainbow toad a wonderful wife.
Sure it’s a toad. So why is it listed on a list of the ten most looked for frogs?