Posted on 07/28/2010 9:25:06 AM PDT by atomic conspiracy
Japan hanged two death row inmates Wednesday in the first executions under the Democratic Party of Japan-led government launched last September, Justice Minister Keiko Chiba said.
In an unusual move, Chiba herself attended the executions of Kazuo Shinozawa, 59, and Hidenori Ogata, 33, at the Tokyo Detention House, saying at a press conference, ''I attended the executions today as I believe it is my duty to see (the process) through as the person who orders it.''
Despite criticism from various quarters about Chiba's order, Prime Minister Naoto Kan said he believes Chiba made the right decision on the executions of two death row inmates.
''I believe she has made appropriate judgments in line with the law as a justice minister,'' Kan told reporters in the evening, when asked about the first executions.
Chiba, who was a former member of the Japan Parliamentary League against the Death Penalty until she became the justice minister, had held a cautious stance on executions.
When she assumed the ministerial post last September, she told a press conference, ''The death penalty involves a person's life, so I will cautiously handle (the cases) based on the duties of the justice minister.''
While declining to comment on her personal views over executions, on the latest executions, Chiba said, ''I closely examined (the cases) and ordered it...I have felt anew the need to fundamentally discuss the issue of capital punishment.''
Japan is one of the few advanced countries that still have the death penalty. According to Amnesty, 139 countries, or more than two-thirds of them, have abolished the death penalty in law or in practice so far.
The minister attended the executions of Shinozawa, who was convicted of murder for setting fire to a jewelry store in 2000, in Utsunomiya, Tochigi Prefecture, in which six female clerks were burned to death, as well as Ogata, who killed a man and woman and seriously injuring two others in Saitama Prefecture in 2003.
It is believed to be the first time a justice minister has attended an execution, according to the Justice Ministry.
In a bid to stir public debate over the death penalty, Justice Minister Chiba also said she has instructed the detention facility in Tokyo to allow the news media to visit the death chamber, while ordering the Justice Ministry to establish a panel to study capital punishment.
Death chambers in Japan have been closed to the media, as well as to the public so far. However, Chiba said media coverage ''will contribute to public debate over the death penalty.''
Chiba also said that while the panel, to be set up under the justice minister, will consist of ministry officials, who will discuss the system involving the death penalty, including whether it should be maintained or abolished, she hopes to ''hear what outside experts have to say in open discussions.''
The content of the debate will be open to the public in order to enable people to discuss the issue more deeply, as private citizens have become involved in criminal court proceedings under the lay judge system, she added.
The last time the government executed death row inmates was July 28 last year, when the Liberal Democratic Party was in power and hanged three inmates. The latest executions bring the total number of death row inmates to 107 in Japan.
Chiba may be replaced soon, as she lost her parliamentary seat in the House of Councillors election earlier this month.
Some lawmakers from the opposition as well as the ruling bloc have expressed criticism over the execution order issued by a civilian justice minister, but Chiba said she had considered it before the upper house election and ordered the hanging of the two inmates ''as a result of it.''
Meanwhile, DPJ Secretary General Yukio Edano told reporters he has heard that Chiba signed the execution order Saturday, one day before her term as an upper house member expired on Sunday.
Amnesty International Japan issued a statement condemning the executions, which noted, ''The information disclosure over the death penalty and public debate on whether to maintain or abolish it should be implemented with executions suspended.''
''It is contradictory to execute someone while proposing public debate on it,'' the human rights group said in the statement.
In October 2008, the Geneva-based Human Rights Committee urged Japan to consider termination of the death penalty regardless of domestic public opinion that favors its maintenance, saying in a report, ''Regardless of opinion polls, the state party (Japan) should favorably consider abolishing the death penalty and inform the public, as necessary, about the desirability of abolition.''
However, a Japanese government survey showed in February that a record 85.6 percent of respondents said that continuing capital punishment is ''unavoidable.'' ==Kyodo
Too bad the Japanese don’t use the ancient methods the Samuri prefered.
It is nice to see Japan is still a civilized nation.
Not really.
They have an interesting way of handling it. They wake you up that morning and say “Today's the day.”
Much better than giving notice, a countdown, and then galvanizing the anti-death penalty activists.
“It may come as a surprise to many that Japan even has the death penalty.”
Not me. I would actually be surprised if Japan or any other Eastern nation didn’t have the death penalty.
WEll, if nothing else, now Shinozawa and Ogata will never get paroled or escape and kill anyone else.
Beheading was the method used in Japan until quite recently, but hanging is far less messy and just as effective.
So, you don’t think this would surprise a lot of people? On what grounds?
Ask any number of media conformists and other libs if the US is only “advanced” country with the death penalty. It’s an article of faith among them that it is.
Too bad the Japanese don’t use the ancient methods the Samuri prefered.
***********
Seppeku was a privilege, and considered an atonement for lost honor or failure. It was considered an honorable closure for an untenable situation. Hanging and crucifiction on the other hand were shameful.
This woman has more balls than most men. This is a good idea. If you sign a death warrant, you should be willing to witness it being carried out.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.