A needle a day. Inserting needles into certain acupuncture points, shown here as labeled dots, seems to spur tissue to release a pain-killing chemical.
Credit: Takahiro Takano
Posted on 06/09/2010 2:01:50 AM PDT by neverdem
Millions of people worldwide use acupuncture to ease a variety of painful conditions, but it's still not clear how the ancient treatment works. Now a new study of mice shows that insertion of an acupuncture needle activates nearby pain-suppressing receptors. What's more, a compound that boosts the response of those receptors increases pain relief—a finding that could one day lead to drugs that enhance the effectiveness of acupuncture in people.
Researchers have developed two hypotheses for how acupuncture relieves pain. One holds that the needle stimulates pain-sensing nerves, which trigger the brain to release opiumlike compounds called endorphins that circulate in the body. The other holds that acupuncture works through a placebo effect, in which the patient's thinking releases endorphins. Neuroscientist Maiken Nedergaard of the University of Rochester Medical Center in New York state was skeptical about both hypotheses because acupuncture doesn't hurt and often works only when needles are inserted near the sore site. Nedergaard instead suspected that when acupuncturists insert and rotate needles, they cause minor damage to the tissue, which releases a compound called adenosine that acts as a local pain reliever.
Nedergaard first assigned the study as a summer project to her then-16-year-old daughter, Nanna Goldman. Goldman and other researchers in Nedergaard's lab lightly anesthetized mice to get them to hold still, inserted a needle into an acupuncture point on the lower leg, and sampled the fluid around the needle. They found a 24-fold rise in adenosine, which seemed promising.
Next, they tested whether boosting the action of adenosine helped alleviate two types of chronic foot pain—pain from inflammation, which underlies conditions such as arthritis; and pain from nerve damage, which occurs in conditions such as spinal cord injuries or complications of diabetes. By performing neurosurgery or by injecting a substance that promoted inflammation, the team created mice that had one of these conditions in their feet. Both types of chronic pain make mice recoil from mild stimuli that wouldn't bother comfortable animals. Then the researchers tested each mouse's sensitivity to two types of stimuli: touch, which they measured by how quickly the mouse pulled its sore foot off a metal filament; and heat, which they measured by shining a classroom laser pointer on the animal's sore foot and measuring how quickly it pulled that foot away.
Inserting an acupuncture needle or locally injecting a drug that boosted adenosine's action made the mice far less sensitive to pain. But neither treatment eased pain in mice that lacked a cell-surface receptor through which adenosine exerts its effects. These results demonstrate that adenosine acts as a biochemical messenger that helped soothe pain during acupuncture, says Nedergaard. The researchers obtained further confirmation by showing that both treatments lowered the activity in a pain-sensing area of the brain known as the anterior cingulate cortex.
To determine whether they could boost the pain-relieving effects of acupuncture, the researchers gave the injured mice a drug that leads tissue to accumulate more adenosine. The drug made adenosine stick around three times longer—and it tripled the period of pain relief from 1 hour to 3, the researchers report online today in Nature Neuroscience. Although the drug they used, an anticancer drug called deoxycoformycin, is too toxic to use routinely in the clinic, Nedergaard calls the finding a "proof of principle that you can improve the effect of acupuncture."
The work is "a landmark study" that was "very meticulously done, with a very clear hypothesis that was attacked on many different levels," says Vitaly Napadow, a neuroscientist at Harvard Medical School in Charlestown, Massachusetts. More research is needed to test whether the pain-relieving pathway works not only in anesthetized mice but also in awake humans. "Whether this really flies in humans, I have no idea," he says. "But I think it is a very important first step."
Good job of applying sound science to get a definitive answer.
I've just had a terrible two months of low back pain and sciatica and was thinking of giving it a try since muscle relaxants and naproxen just arent' doing the job any more. How many treatments and how often did it take for your back?
It works, no question about it. But,,, I got better results with the treatments from a Chinese Herbal Doctor. 5 years ago, I had to walk with a cane. Bad knee. Two weeks of herbal treatment, and,,, I don’t even know where my cane is.
To each his own.
Leni
Thanks! I’m also a big believer in western medicine, but the last bout convinced me that I need to focus more on flexibility and core strengthening. I’ve been treated for years with each blowout - usually it occurs about once a year and sidelines me for about a month. Having just passed 40, I need to get serious about building things up before age wears them down.
Your post reads as almost identical to one I gave on a similar thread some months ago. The only thing I might add is; try to find Chinese practitioners from the mainland.
So if you take someone and put them up on a table and have an ‘expert’ poke them with needles anywhere they feel like; and take someone else and put them up on a table and have an ‘expert’ poke them with needles where ‘ancient Chinese secret’ says to: Both patients report the same level of ‘relief’.
Can you say “placebo effect”? I knew you could.
Psychologist Says Antidepressants Are Just Fancy Placebos
New autism susceptibility genes identified
Polyphenols in red wine and green tea halt prostate cancer growth
FReepmail me if you want on or off my health and science ping list.
I've just had a terrible two months of low back pain and sciatica and was thinking of giving it a try since muscle relaxants and naproxen just arent' doing the job any more.
('scuse me for buttin' in)
It sounds like you have two seperate issues. And *may* or *may not* be related. (I'm putting on my white Dr's Coat now)...
If you don't address this, it will only get worse and the day will come that you can't even bend up from your waist, AND, you'll be eating Vicodin ES like M&M's but they won't help one bit. However, there is ONE thing you could try first before surgery (any option beats 'the knife'). It's a long shot but hey, what the heck? Ask your Dr for an Rx for Neurontin (generic is Gabapentin). It was initially developed for the treatment of Epileptic Seizures but it was found that it works for stopping 'Nerve Pain'. It's powerful stuff (not an opiate and non addictive) and you HAVE to start slow, with a low dosage and work UP. But the stuff is magic.
No I'm not a MD, I'm an expert on 'Back Pain', Disc Problems, and 'Sciatica'. As I've suffered since 1980 with all the above. I now have Spinal Stenosis. That REALLY sucks big time and how I found out about ALL the above, and the Neurontin for nerve pain. I eat so many pills per day I lose count, its somewhere near a dozen.
ps: Avoid 'Spinal Fusion' at all costs. That's Stone Age Back surgery.
How many treatments? I have horrible low back and leg pain. My doctor wants to operate. I can't take the 3 to 6 months off work to recover but it is getting near impossible to go up steps some days and frequently I am in tears by the end of the day.
Research Vit C for pain and castor oil packs. Works miracles.
No kidding, rub castor oil on where it hurts and research castor oil packs.
I even used it today for a headache.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.