Skip to comments.The War Over America’s Past
Posted on 05/25/2010 8:00:35 PM PDT by grand wazoo
Who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past.
That was the slogan of the Ministry of Truth in George Orwells 1984, where Winston Smith worked ceaselessly revising the past to conform to the latest party line of Big Brother.
And so we come to the battle over history books in the schools of Texas. Liberals are enraged that a Republican-dominated Board of Education is rewriting the texts. But is the rewrite being done to falsify history, or to undo a liberal bias embedded for decades?
Consider a few of the issues.
The new texts will emphasize that the separation of church and state was never written into the Constitution.
Is that not right? The First Amendment prohibits Congress from establishing a national religion. But, in 1776, nine of the 13 colonies had state religions established in their constitutions.
Thomas Jeffersons words about a separation of church and state were not written until 1802, when he responded to a letter from the Danbury Baptist Association. Not until after World War II did the Supreme Court begin the systematic purge of Christianity from American public life.
Barack Obama may have declared, We do not consider ourselves a Christian nation. But Woodrow Wilson said, America was born a Christian nation, and Harry Truman wrote Pius XII to affirm, This is a Christian nation.
The Texas school board wants the U.S. economic system called free enterprise rather than the term Karl Marx used, capitalism.
Anything wrong with that?
The Christian Science Monitor cites one professor Phillip VanFossen as appalled the new history texts will put a more positive spin on Sen. Joe McCarthys communist witch hunt.
The FDR and Truman administrations were shot through with treason. Alger Hiss, who was with FDR at Yalta and Truman in San Francisco when the U.N. was founded, was a Stalinist spy, exposed by Whittaker Chambers and Rep. Richard Nixon.
Harry Dexter White, Treasurys No. 2, who pushed the infamous Morgenthau Plan to turn Germany into a pastureland, was a Soviet agent, as was White House aide Laughlin Currie and States Laurence Duggan, whose treason was confirmed by the VENONA decrypts of Soviet cables in 1995.
William Remington at Commerce was convicted of perjury for denying his ties to a spy ring. Julius and Ethel Rosenberg were executed for their role in betraying the secrets of the atom bomb.
The VENONA transcripts contained the names of scores of U.S. citizens assisting known Soviet agents during and after World War II.
By 1952, Truman, having been repudiated by his own party in New Hampshire, was down to 23 percent, and was the most unpopular president ever to leave office.
But Joe McCarthys approval, four years into this crusade in January 1954, stood at 50 percent, with only 29 percent disapproving.
And was that really a time of anti-communist hysteria?
Why, then, does not a single Gallup poll from 1950 to 1954 show even 1 percent of Americans giving anti-communist extremism or witch hunts or Joe McCarthy as an issue of concern?
Not only did Joe Kennedy Sr. admire and support Joe McCarthy, Jack Kennedy befriended him, Bobby worked for him, Teddy played touch football with him at Hyannis Port and the Kennedy girls dated him.
When, at a Harvard reunion, Jack heard a speaker say he was proud the college never produced an Alger Hiss or Joe McCarthy, JFK roared, How dare you couple the name of a great patriot with that of a traitor? and stormed out.
That 1954 was a year of disaster for Joe, with the Army-McCarthy hearings and censure by the Senate, is undeniable. But Joe is hated today not for what he got wrong, but for what he got right.
What is the purpose of teaching Americas children the history of their country? Few said it better than Ronald Reagan in his farewell address: An informed patriotism is what we want. . . .
So, weve got to teach history based not on whats in fashion but whats important. . . . You know, four years ago, on the 40th anniversary of D-Day, I read a letter from a young woman writing of her late father, whod fought on Omaha Beach. Her name was Lisa Zanatta Henn, and she said, We will always remember, we will never forget what the boys of Normandy did. Well, lets help her keep her word.
If we forget what we did, we wont know who we are. Im warning of an eradication of the American memory that could result, ultimately, in an erosion of the American spirit.
Teaching American history to Americas children is done so that they will come to know and love their country. And while all nations have sins of scarlet, none has a greater, more glorious past than ours.
And if teaching that is what the Texas Board of Education is all about, ensuring that the children of Texas know both sides of every great American quarrel and come away loving their country all the more, then God bless em.
This Freeper just finished a college level American History class. There is a tremendous amount of liberal bias in the course. Go Texas!
I have heard that what is disturbing people is that the revised Texas texts will be used nationwide for the next ten year. I don’t understand how that works, but I am not sure that people in other parts of the country would necessarily want their textbooks to reflect a Texas bias even if they are in general political agreement
Did you stand out like a sore thumb or stay off the radar screen?
exposed by Whittaker Chambers and Rep. Richard Nixon.
Yep. That's the real reason the left hated Nixon. He outed their traitor hero, Hiss. After that they wanted his scalp.
There are newspaper archives online going back to the 1840s. If you want to actually learn about the Civil War, then pick one Southern paper and one Norhern paper and read the account of each engagement in both. You can then filter out the bias and actually learn some history. The most interesting period is the 25 or 30 years after the Civil War. Al awful lot of revisionist stuff is stuffed in there.
i would love to have attended that class...
and the liberals in the class would have hated me.
there’s nothing better than whipping a liberal with logic, facts, history and sarcasm. drives them crazy.
Yes, the bigger states have text books written according to their own specs. Then, rather than having new books written, smaller states will just adopt those same texts as their own. The people who are upset are liberals. And it’s not a Texas bias that upsets them; it’s a conservative bias, or more accurately a non-liberal bias. Liberals feel entitled to a monopoly on what gets shoveled into students’ minds via textbooks, and they get testy their monopoly is challenged.
Hiss and Dexter White are shown within to be the utterly Communist a-holes that they in fact were. Whittaker Chambers' Witness, although thoroughly self-serving, adds even more weight here.
This little work demonstrates with hard fact that McCarthy was 98+% correct. Speaking historically, it's just too bad he couldn't keep his hands off the bourbon bottle. Sad indeed.
Thanks for reminding me about that one. I just bought a copy. They have the hardcover new for 7 bucks at Amazon. Can’t beat that.
Yes, indeed! Very good read...and (how odd!) quite objective, too. What ever happened to historians citing hard facts, eh?
Evans' book is a gem.
Texas pays most (if not all) the fees for having the textbooks published.
Instead of paying for having their own textbooks published, the other States just have the Texas ones reprinted.....it's much cheaper that way.
but I am not sure that people in other parts of the country would necessarily want their textbooks to reflect a Texas bias even if they are in general political agreement
There isn't any 'bias'. All Texas did was to present both sides of historical issues and took out the liberalistic slant.
it’s not the texas bias i opposed, it’s that dang accent i have to put up with whenever i read it.
The name of the game is keeping quiet about one’s political views in the classroom. Teachers can and do hand out failing grades for those who disagree with their views. Bad news in the last semester of a four year degree.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.