Posted on 09/26/2009 2:45:33 PM PDT by HokieMom
“he was born in America”
Even better, Kentucky.
Boy, you were one step behind...:)
I wonder if Thomas got into Lincoln getting back into politics largely as a response to the Dred Scott decision, the original activist Supreme Court decision.
Just like Roe v. Wade, it took a political disagreement and in attempting to put it outside the realm of politics made political adjustment of the issue impossible. In the Scott case this led directly to the greatest war in American history.
I take great pleasure in contemplating Chief Justice Taney’s reaction to Justice Thomas’ presence on the Court.
Is he calling for starting the lightly-entertained idea of another civil war?
Speaking of myths that surround Lincoln's persona....
As if a common race means anything.
"You guys have been practicing discrimination for years. Now it is our turn." - Thurgood Marshall
That must be what made his hair stand on end.
Wow, never heard that one before. Did a Google search and it only came up on a couple of hundred web pages (out of what, a trillion?) that aren't FR pages. Imagine Dubya or Cheney or Rush Limbaugh saying anything half as outrageous; it'd probably be on a billion webpages. And we're not talking about the MSM; we're talking about the world-wide web for crying out loud.
If Obama did that Mr. Thomas, you might be in jail as another SCOTUS judge was.
Who was that?
If the Northern states relied on slavery for their economy, I imagined abolition wouldn’t have been a priority.
See post 27, another Freeper knew what I was talking about.
http://www.lewrockwell.com/orig2/adams3.html
Just finished listening to the whole speech. Justice Thomas will never win a prize for best public speaker.
However, he did indeed tackle the issue I mentioned. Dred Scott was one of the very first attempts to allow the judiciary to rule by fiat. It was overturned only by the Civil War.
Yet as Clarence points out, judges learned nothing by this. They still think they have the wisdom to rule by just stating that their policy preferences are part of the Constitution and thus above political give and take.
As bad an idea as in the 1850s, and at least as prone to lead to tyranny, even if it is a tyranny of good intentions.
A warrant for the arrest of Taney may have been issued, but he was not actually arrested or jailed.
No, I think he means start a civil war. He was using some of those conservative code words you hear so much about.
Thank you for your comments. I appreciate your remarks.
Checking in.
Lincoln *is* the Republican Party — the GOP was created by the religious right for the purpose of abolishing slavery. Lincoln was definitely pro-war— he put down the great Democrat rebellion, even threw many Democrats in jail and shutting down their newspapers. And the icing on the cake— Lincoln was pro-business, passing bills like the Homestead Act and the Pacific Railway Act.
Lincoln is the best American president ever, easily.
I am sure he would have let the South go if he only knew that 140 later, the North would slowly bring creeping Marxism. Yes, socialism/Marxism is coming North to South. No question a free Independent South would be watching our ex -Northern countrymen drinking the collective kool-aid, glad to have been freed from this abysmal Union. But alas no, because of the Illinois Butcher we have to go down with the ship. What a hero.
FYI To Clarence, he was a racist of the worst sort.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.