Posted on 05/03/2009 7:52:50 AM PDT by HangnJudge
An April 26 article in the New York Times reported:
The need for more doctors comes up at almost every congressional hearing and White House forum on health care. “We’re not producing enough primary-care physicians,”Obama said at one forum. “The costs of medical education are so high that people feel that they’ve got to specialize.”
This quote demonstrates precisely the stilted logic based on flimsy assumptions that characterizes the intellect of our statist new presidential administration. That primary care physicians are in short supply is not in dispute, but the shortage certainly doesn’t stem from the cost of medical education, according to a November 2008 consumeraffairs.com report:
Thus, your new national health care coverage will be administered by physicians trained more frugally than those now practicing. Perhaps these newbies can be rushed through a community college-type program in a couple of years to meet the demand for “doctors.” One can imagine the high quality sawbones that would be turned out by our nation’s rumpled bureaucracy.
The simple alternative — simplifying the procedures for physician access to Medicare and Medicaid funds combined with tort reform to enable doctors to keep more of their hard-earned cash — is surely anathema to Obama and his regulators. Unfortunately the president’s approach meets the medical standard for Gresham’s Law, as demonstrated in nationalized health care systems in Europe and Canada: Bad doctors drive out good doctors
(Excerpt) Read more at pajamasmedia.com ...
The objective is TO GET CONTROL over people’s lives by using socialized medicine. The goal is CERTAINLY not improving health care. He cannot do that and really does not care to.
It is all about control by socialists. Has nothing to do with your health or mine....at all.
Ok, either I haven't had enough coffee yet, or that sentence makes absolutely no sense.
Does he think an ENT or a pediatrician or a cardiac specialist attends LESS school? WTH is he talking about?
IMHO
When Obama Care kicks in
~30% of physicians will just quit
The job is just too destructive to self
and to primary relationships
The personal costs too high to sustain
with a ever increasingly intrusive government presence
Specialist have higher average incomes than generalists
They can support higher “startup” costs than
Pediatricians, FP’s, General surgeons
Ok, so it was my lack of caffeine. Nevermind....
Actually the biggest reason there are too few doctors is that medicine is hard. There’s a very limited pool of people who are smart enough and have the desire to do the grueling 12 years (or more depending on the specialization) of study.
That’s why it seems like every other person you meet is studying to be a nurse practitioner or physician’s assistant or aroma therapist or some such thing. They get to help people in a shorter time period and with a much lower likelihood of failure.
I’ve already heard from surgeons that say they will just quit. No sense in working to not get paid .
While the problems of the uninsured should be addressed, is socialized medicine really the answer?
And considering that many nations in Europe, Canada, etc. have had socialized medicine for many years, we have seen both some good points and some big problems with those systems.
We have seen what the problems are in the real world, not as part of some abstract theory, but what has happened in these systems. Yet the Obamabots talk about this issue as if it is an abstract theory that has never been tried before.
Right. And a specialist in private practice even earns more and better control over his practice than being a ward of a large HMO or Government. Government control over health care will destroy good medical care by destroying private practice. Wait and see!!!!!
And these other people have much less likelihood of getting sued also. Tort reform is badly needed.
I’ve heard that about 2/3 of all OB/GYN doctors get sued for malpractice sometimes in their career. And that yearly malpractice insurance premiums can run into six figures for these doctors. You think doctors make a lot of money, because they have six figure incomes, but they also have some huge expenses that you and I don’t have.
But I’m sure Obama has figured out what to do about malpractice and other issues in medicine.
In my case, 13...
4 years Undergraduate School
1 year Graduate school
4 Years Medical School
1 Year Internship
3 Years Residency
Lifetime of Continuing Education
Medical Boards
2 Specialty Boards
And I still feel insufficient
Specialists have higher income NOW.
They won’t under BO med-no-care. That’s one of the gripes not mentioned in the article. If all doctors are paid the same, you won’t get specialists. Why study 4 or 5 more years to get the same pay as the just-graduated resident?
Yep, he'll make it illegal to sue your BO med-no-care doctor. That way they can slap a bandaid on your spurting artery and not worry about getting sued.
Yup
Back to the classic General Practitioner
4 Years Medical School
1 Year Internship
Or even skipping Internship and
going straight into practice
Shiver
Makes a whole lotta damns sense to me.
India, Thailand and Singapore will just build more for profit hospitals to service those with money from the West.
They will attract US trained Dr. who will make a lot of money inspite of lower rates. Very little insurance, lower operating costs, more cash payment with less paper work and accounts receivable.
Our out is Singapore. We would go there if treatment was unavailable in the US.
One of our friends is preparing for a kidney transplant. Under the UK or Canadian system she would not qualify..too old.
I wish her well.
One half of USA doctor visits result in NO quantifiable improvement in the patient’s condition.
Despite spending trillions for research and treatment, modern medicine has few answers to the physical destruction of old age.
In 2009, the greatest enemy of good health is your BIRTHDAY.
Medical research will slowly extend the human life span and quality of life.
Increasing the number of clinical doctors will make only a minor contribution to public health in the coming decades.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.