Posted on 03/06/2009 6:37:28 AM PST by marktwain
Some say we live in a “free society.” Others say we are marching toward communism. How free are you really? In a study from the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, political science professors William P. Ruger and Jason Sorens decided to find out.
“Freedom In The 50 States: An Index of Personal and Economic Freedom” measures a number of variables beyond the usual economic measures, including, “measures of social and personal freedoms such as peaceable citizens’ rights to educate their own children, own and carry firearms, and be free from unreasonable search and seizure.” And why did the authors decide to study personal freedom?
“In our view, individuals should be allowed to dispose of their lives, liberties, and property as they see fit, so long as they do not infringe on the rights of others.” Ruger and Sorens do acknowledge that different people see freedom differently, and publish raw data with an invitation for readers to construct their own personal freedom rankings by going to: www.statepolicyindex.com
“We would also argue that freedom … can be threatened as much by the weakness of the state as by overbearing state intervention. Individuals are less free the more they have reason to fear private assaults and depredations, and a useful government punishes private aggression vigorously. However, we focus on threats to individual liberty originating in the state. Therefore, we do not code the effectiveness of state governments in punishing rights violations. For instance, we do not include measures of the efficacy of state police and courts or of violent and property crime rates. Thus, our “freedom index” does not capture all aspects of freedom.”
WHAT THE AUTHORS MEASURED
States are ranked for Economic Freedom, Personal Freedom and Overall Freedom. Beyond the usual economic measures, Ruger and Sorens looked at “paternalism,” including variables from legalized prostitution to seat belt laws and campaign finance restrictions.
Gun laws were among the most heavily weighted variables, second only to freedom of education. Gun laws measured included “concealed- and open-carry regulations to assault weapons bans, waiting periods, gun show and private sale regulations, licensing of gun owners, registration of firearms, trigger locks, and more.”
HOW DID YOUR STATE FARE? (The drum roll, please…)
Least free: If you live in one of the People’s Republics of New York, New Jersey, Rhode Island, California or Maryland, you’re pretty much screwed, but you probably know that already. New York led the “least free” pack by a considerable margin, with the others following in the order listed. (Now I remember why I refer to myself as a “refugee from New York”).
Most free: In combined personal and economic freedom, New Hampshire, Colorado and South Dakota scored a virtual tie for first place.
Personal freedom: In personal freedom alone, Alaska was a “clear winner,” and Maryland was dead last.
Beyond rankings in economic, personal and overall freedom, Ruger and Sorens do an excellent state-by-state analysis of individual measures. Now if we could get a researcher to correlate personal freedom and crime, I’d lay money they have a perfect inverse relationship …
For previous columns by Paul Valone, go to: www.fpaulvalone.com For legislative information, go to: www.GRNC.org
Michigan more free than Alaska?
Who would have thunk.
#37 in Wisconsin. It would be better, but we still have no CC law and a gun-grabbing ‘Rat Governor.
Sweeeet.
Most of Michigan is very nice. Grand Rapids is a wonderful town. Detroit is a disaster along with Flint and a few others.
Virginia is #9. With Tim Kaine as our gov that’s sure to change.
The money quote?
“Now if we could get a researcher to correlate personal freedom and crime, I’d lay money they have a perfect inverse relationship …”
Gets my vote.
Illinois is #42!! Awesome!
Maybe next year we can get down to at least #46!
Illinois is #42!! Awesome!
Maybe next year we can get down to at least #46!
Woohoooo!!!
Texas came in fifth! WooHOO!
My adopted home, Indiana, at #13
My born home, Michigan, at #14
Not too shabby.
“Texas (#7 economic, #5 personal, #5 overall) has one of the smallest state governments in the country. Nevertheless, as one of us who lives in Texas can testify, there are plenty of areas where improvement is needed. As a percentage of corrected GSP, Texashas the second lowest tax burden in the country and the third lowest grants-adjusted government
spending. However, government employment is a standard deviation higher than the national average.
Gun control is better than average, but the state falls short on open-carry laws, stricter-than-federal minimum age for purchase rules, and dealer licensing.
Alcohol is less regulated than in most other states, and taxes are low. Low-level marijuana cultivation is a misdemeanor, but otherwise marijuana laws are very harsh. Texas does not authorize sobriety checkpoints. Private and home schools are almost completely unregulated. Labor laws are generally good, except for a prevailing wage law. Texas is the only state not to require employers to contribute to
workers’ compensation coverage. While Texas has only light community rating, it has imposed mandated coverages on health insurance increasing the cost of premiums by more than 63%.45 Texas is one of the leaders in telecom and cable “deregulation.” Unfortunately, eminent domain has not been extensively reformed. The state’s liability system is much worse than average; ending the election of judges may help here. There are no smoking bans on private property.”
#5 Texas (where i’m from)
#9 Virginia (where I am)
Not great, but at least I’m not in #50 NY.
Thank God for small favors.
All the worst states voted for The Messiah.
We're #1!! For now, anyway.
Thank you for posting the listing.
Hey Diana! Surprising we were not even worse than #37. Doyle will keep trying to make us #50.
My state qualifies for a large “LOL.”
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.