Good points.....valid points. This murdering trash was far from a trained paramilitary unit. They were a gang of idiots in a sheep pen as ya suggest !
Here is a PDF version of the Grossman Book excerpt that I have “among others” for free download on my FR homepage.
http://www.commonfolkusingcommonsense.com/files/sheepwolvessheepdogs.pdf
I am not saying that ethics and morals are not definitive, but just you have to stand back, like a surgeon,and separate your self from the thickets of subjective bagage, look at the events coldly.
On, their plus side, they did quite a lot.
Physically, economically, they did nothing.
I don't think they scared the Indian population. If, anything, they have unified the Indians. So, other that the press, they have lost in every measure.
Other than back at home cave, or where ever they came from, the action was a loser.