Posted on 10/03/2008 8:51:01 AM PDT by bonnieblue4me
1. What is his original citizenship.
2. When he moved to Indonesia did he give up that citizenship?
First question needs to be answered first, because you can not answer the second question without knowing original citizenship. Very simply if he doesn't have the citizenship he can not give up something he never had.
obumpa
In your snottiest possible voice you asked what proof do we have that McCain would release is birth certificate.
I showed you a copy of his unquestionably valid birth certificate that he has already released.
Most people can put those two together in their minds.
“But the AP photo of the school record from Jakarta clearly says he was born in Honolulu.”
Honolulu is where Barry Obama’s birth was REGISTERED in the United States. Kenya was where he was born.
I'm sorry, but I said no such thing.
What was being discussed was the State Department, and their refusing Berg's subpoena.
Kevmo said that if the tables were turned, they, i.e. the State Department, would have sent the information requested without delay.
I asked what proof he had of that. Not what proof he had that McCain would release his birth certificate.
But the Jakarta school record says that's where he was born. Not where his birth was registered.
1. What is his original citizenship.
2. When he moved to Indonesia did he give up that citizenship?
First question needs to be answered first, because you can not answer the second question without knowing original citizenship.
But Berg claims as a statement of fact that Obama has or had Indonesian citizenship, which makes 1 and 2 moot.
The paperwork you are given when you register a birth is official and I’m sure the school where he was enrolled in jakarta “thought” it was a “regular” birth certificate.
Think about it. That school had no idea what an American birth certificate would look like.
Besides, the officials at the school in Jarkarta may never even have asked to see Obama’s birth certificate. They may have only asked his mother where Obama was born and then wrote that done.
“What proof do you have of this”
OK it is called character and honesty that’s the difference in the TWO BTW where EXACTLY are Ole Hussein’s LSAT and this vaunted collage work located ?
Why wouldn't it have been a "regular" birth certificate?
Think about it. That school had no idea what an American birth certificate would look like.
I'm not sure what you're saying here. Are you saying that she provided a forged birth certificate?
Besides, the officials at the school in Jarkarta may never even have asked to see Obama’s birth certificate. They may have only asked his mother where Obama was born and then wrote that done.
But if he were born in Kenya, rather than Hawaii, and she was asked where he was born, why wouldn't she have said Kenya?
why is that a problem?
It wasn't Obama and McCain who were being discussed in that exchange. What was being discussed was the State Department. Specifically the State Department's refusal of Berg's subpoena, which was the topic of this article.
Kevmo claimed that if the tables were turned, the State Department would have handed over the information without delay.
It was this statement that I asked what proof he had of it
It doesn't make any sense to me. The State Department is part of the executive branch, and is headed up by Condoleezza Rice, who was appointed by Bush.
So why would the State Department balk at providing information about Obama, but provide information about McCain without delay? Is the Bush administration trying to protect Obama? That doesn't seem likely.
Again, Kevmo's claim doesn't make any sense to me. Which is why I asked what proof he had to back it up.
When you stated the following “What proof do you have of this?” It Begged to open SO many LOCKED doors That this ACORN Nitwit has presented us with!
BTW just so we understand each other IT IS MY BUSINESS as an American this Leftist is running for president not dogcatcher!
HIPAA (not HIPPA) stands for Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act. It was not intended to be a privacy law, although that is how it has morphed. In fact if you ask the majority of people they will tell you that the “P” stand for privacy. Two years ago, I had to print out a copy and show a hospital administrator in order to get access to my wife’s medical records because she didn’t understand what she had wrong with her and they wouldn’t talk to me.
How the “Minions of O” has used this to further their cause is appalling.
Huh?
Did you mean to say "Those are Obama's statements of facts, not Berg's"?
If so, when did Obama make any statement of fact that he is or was an Indonesian citizen? I can't recall seeing any such statement of fact from Obama.
However Berg clearly makes it a statement of fact when he says in his response to the motion to dismiss:
Even if Obama was, in fact, born in Hawaii, he lost his U.S. citizenship when his mother re-married and moved to Indonesia with her Indonesian husband.
Now that has to be done in court.
why is that a problem?
I don't recall saying it was a problem.
I've only said that Berg's claim that Obama is or was an Indonesian citizen makes the birth certificate moot. Because it wouldn't have mattered if he were born in Hawaii or Kenya. Even Berg says this himself.
When I stated "What proof do you have of this," it concerned the State Department. Not Obama.
BTW just so we understand each other IT IS MY BUSINESS as an American this Leftist is running for president not dogcatcher!
I never said it wasn't.
It looks likely that Wash. knows exactly what the truth is and is willing to throw us under the bus.(Like, ‘’ we know he wasn’t born here, but we ain’t gonna tell you.)
Well all you have to do is provide some proof of this and we can all go home. Whaddya got?
So are you saying that the US State Department is among the "Minions of O"?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.