I agree with your comments on David A. and Syesha. I’m not as in line with your thoughts on David C.
I really liked his first song, but his second and third didn’t quite do it for me. His second was just okay. His third was a little better.
He should still make it through with the judges shining his boots during their comments tonight. We agree that his ability to turn songs to his own likes, is excellent. That’s why I still back him. I still didn’t come away from tonight thinking he had peformed up to par on two of the songs.
OK, I have to be honest about David Cook’s performances last night. When I heard Simon’s choice for him, I was really worried. Then he started singing, and he really did an amazing job and I had a tear in my eye! The 2nd song, I had never heard of. The beginning wasn’t great and then he picked it up. His voice was off key in places and he was shouting. The 3rd song was better than the 2nd but not as good as the first. I have to say, I was disappointed and didn’t want to be. With that being said, I had to vote for him because he has done very well and been consistent all along. He is my kind of music. I don’t know if I am imagining, but after each performance, David lets out a big sigh of relief. I could be wrong but I think his brother’s cancer and whatever else is going on, has taken a big toll on David.
Yes, his ability to turn songs into his own is excellent. If I had just tuned into this 1 week, I would find it hard to decide a winner. Since he really nailed the first song and made it his own, that was enough to override the other OK performances.
I did vote for Syesha, because I want her to stay in and because she has been slighted by the judges and everyone else. Why can’t the girl get the credit she is due? You aren’t alone in that thinking.