"No one has consulted with me on this matter yet..."
Posted on 01/18/2008 3:47:41 PM PST by SubGeniusX
Barring a miracle, South Carolina will bury the last libertarian-leaning candidate of '08
COLUMBIA, SC—One by one, the great libertarian hopes of the 2008 presidential cycle have been dashed.
New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson was touted—some might say over-hyped—as an example of a Western "libertarian Democrat" for his friendliness to gun rights, for signing a medical marijuana law, and for a tax-cutting record that earned him a B on the Cato Institute's Fiscal Policy Report Card. He dropped out of the race after failing to break the six percent mark in Iowa or New Hampshire. At his final debate appearance in New Hampshire, the Clinton-Obama-Edwards triumvirate hardly seemed to notice him.
While few thought Congressman Ron Paul, the one-time Libertarian Party candidate and anti-war Republican, would be a viable contender for the presidency, lots of people thought that he might at least raise the profile of libertarian ideas. Now his history of associating with the uglier side of the paleolibertarian movement has come back to haunt him, and many once-sympathetic observers are wondering if his campaign might actually be bad for libertarianism.
That leaves former Tennessee Senator Fred Thompson. For a while, during his endless flirtation with the GOP race, Thompson looked to some people like the Great Libertarian Hope. The Cato Institute's Michael Tanner praised Thompson last May for "a solid record as a fiscal conservative," adding that in the Senate he was "a consistent supporter of entitlement reform" and a reliable vote for free trade. "On federalism," Tanner wrote, "there may be no better candidate."
Indeed, Thompson is the only major candidate who talks about the importance of federalism, which has helped earn him endorsements from an impressive roster of libertarian-leaning law professors, including Volokh Conspiracy blogger-profs Eugene Volokh, Jonathan Adler, Todd Zywicki, and Orin Kerr.
On the stump, Thompson likes to say that "a government big enough and powerful enough to give you anything is big enough and powerful enough to take anything away from you." He waxes on about how the principles this country was founded on include "respect for a market economy, and what can be done in a free country with free people doing free things in healthy competition with one another and trading with their neighbors."
Alas, Thompson has hardly taken the race by storm. Glenn Reynolds wrote last month that he might have joined Volokh et al. in endorsing Thompson if he hadn't observed how poorly Thompson's campaign is run behind the scenes. That poorly run campaign has yielded poor results. Thompson's low-key affect and introverted personality made him ill-suited to the hands-on retail politicking that Iowans expect, and he edged out John McCain for third place in the Iowa caucuses by just three tenths of a percentage point despite spending much more time than McCain stumping in the Hawkeye State (McCain focused on New Hampshire, where he won). He made almost no effort in the New Hampshire and Michigan primaries, where he got less than 2 percent and less than 4 percent of the vote, respectively.
Now Thompson is putting all of his hopes on a strong finish in South Carolina. "We have to be very successful [here]," Thompson spokesman Jeff Sadosky told me Wednesday. "He would say he has drawn his line in the sand in South Carolina. We've been down here for the last couple of weeks while everybody else was up in Michigan. We're campaigning heavily throughout the state. It's his neck of the woods." Does he have to finish second or better? "I'm not going to get into that," says Sadosky. "We're working hard, we're going to be successful. I'll let the pundits figure out where we need to be."
Very well, then: Thompson needs to finish second or better in South Carolina, or his campaign is over. There are signs that he's gaining steam; polls show a small uptick in support for Thompson over the past week, coming at Mike Huckabee's expense. But it's not at all clear that it'll be enough. In Orangeburg on Wednesday, at 6:30 in the evening, Thompson attracted a good-sized crowd. At 12:45 the next day, Mike Huckabee attracted an even bigger crowd in Florence.
Huckabee's mixture of nanny-statism, populist economic rhetoric, and social conservatism makes him a libertarian's nightmare, and anything that trips him up is to be welcomed. But if Thompson really is dragging down Huckabee, the biggest beneficiary is McCain, who is either leading or tied with Huckabee in every poll this week. A libertarian journalist could fill a book with things that are troubling about John McCain, and reason editor Matt Welch has done so.
Perhaps something will change the dynamics of the race in the remaining hours before South Carolina Republicans go to the polls tomorrow, and Thompson will catch a break. But at the moment, his prospects don't appear to give fans of smaller government any reason to abandon the pessimism that has by now become all too familiar.
John Tabin is a writer and blogger for The American Spectator.
By golly, I think you have nailed it. Think that over. Fred is EVERYBODYS second choice in a race that so far has Rudy McRombee in first. Fred can ride that all the way to a brokered convention, cause Rudy McRombee is destroying it's own various "personalities".
Excellent.
The only thing I don’t like about Fred, um,ah,um, is um, he is um, a crappy public speaker. He comes across as old and um, senile......
I don’t get the poorly run campaign thing. Here in my county in Iowa Huck and McCain’s people were nonexistent. Almost everything they got was media generated. Romney was the only one who organized.
Fred actually did pretty good organization wise. It seems he’s improved in SC.
Thompson was never a serious candidate. These folks are recognizing something that was an attribute of why he was in the race in the first place. His flirtation with federalism and libertarianism was intended to siphon support from Ron Paul (and to a lesser extent, Duncan Hunter). He has always been in this race as a spoiler. I suspect he has been offered a top slot in McCain’s short list for VP.
No one in their right mind thought Ron Paul ever had a shot at the nomination, but he’s not out of it just yet. He has spent too much time on the war and is not getting enough of classical small government libertarianism into the dialog. I hope he and his handlers will realize that being anti-war will get him exactly the same number of liberal votes as being pro-illegal-alien will get the other pubbies from Latinos. We know he’s opposed to the war and a lot of us support him in that, but he needs to stop injecting that into every issue. We need the dialog to be about the fact that the government is too big, has too much power, costs too much, and is too intrusive.
Reason and CATO is beltway libertarianism.
I sure hope you are right. As a friend said (cleaned up a bit for FR) “without Fred, the best hope for conservatives is either McCain, an ex-governor of Massachusetts or a guy from Hope Arkansas? How mucked up is THAT?”
Thompson is, has been and will SOON BE REVEALED as McCain’s Stalking Horse. Less than 48 hours remain until the proof is know to all.
Fred will....
Oh, good grief. No person in his right mind [and Fred is most certainly is] would go through this thankless punishment for anyone. What an insult this is to a decent man and good conservative.
Funny, you said the same thing before the Iowa caucus. You were absolutely sure he would be out shortly after the caucus. You were wrong then and you will be wrong this time. You have NO evidence to support your allegation, NONE, ZERO, NADA, yet you spew this garbage, even after repeated denials by the Thompson Campaign, anyway. Give it up already. Your credibility ain't worth a pile of dog poop.
You are wrong, Fred has the money to continue past SC and into Super Tuesday.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1956009/posts
Neither Richardson or Paul were ever considered serious contenders.
senile.....to you.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.