Posted on 11/30/2007 8:06:34 PM PST by Coleus
As the movie studios gear up for a big Christmas movie season, one trailer that looks like a blockbuster is "The Golden Compass," which must be trying to cash in on the "Narnia" movies. It has flashy special-effect polar bears in armor and a young heroic damsel in distress facing off against evil forces. The casting is top-notch, led by Nicole Kidman and Daniel Craig, the current star spy in the James Bond movies. But buyer beware: Narnia it's not. It's the anti-Narnia. Instead of a Christian allegory, it's an anti-Christian allegory. The author of "The Golden Compass," Philip Pullman, is an atheist who despises C. S. Lewis and his much-beloved Narnia series. "I thought they were loathsome," he said of those books, "full of bullying and sneering, propaganda, basically, on behalf of a religion whose main creed seemed to be to despise and hate people unlike yourself."
This book and movie is only the first in his trilogy, titled "His Dark Materials," that gets more and more anti-religious in each book. Pullman hates orthodox religion and "those who pervert and misuse religion, or any other kind of doctrine with a holy book and a priesthood and an apparatus of power that wields unchallengeable authority, in order to dominate and suppress human freedoms." If you hear the ring of anti-Catholicism, you're right. The evil empire in this movie for children is called the "Magisterium," which is exactly the word Catholics use to describe the teaching authority of the Pope and his bishops. The books are more explicit, in which the evil institution is also called "The Church" and the higher-ups are the "Vatican Council."
British columnist Peter Hitchens has explained how our secular thought-shapers would love for Pullman to undercut Narnia's influence on children: "The cultural elite would like to wipe out this pocket of resistance. They have successfully expelled God from the schools, from the broadcast media and, for the most part, from the Church itself." He writes that while Lewis mocked atheists as joyless, Pullman depicts priests as evil and murderous, drunk and probably perverted, and the Church as "a conspiracy against happiness and kindness."
Isn't it a bit perverse to head into the Christmas holiday season hyping an atheist fantasy movie for kids? No doubt sensing this, Pullman and the moviemakers have ventured on a dishonest but energetic public-relations campaign to convince the public that this film isn't really anti-Christian. It's a plea for open-mindedness and spiritual dialogue. The Church is just a metaphor, see. The movie's director, Chris Weitz, spins it this way: "In the books, the Magisterium is a version of the Catholic Church gone wildly astray from its roots. If that's what you want in the film, you'll be disappointed." Weitz says they merely "expanded the range of meanings" for the Magisterium, that it's merely a metaphor for tyranny of any stripe: "Philip Pullman is against any kind of organized dogma whether it is Church hierarchy or, say, a Soviet hierarchy." That would be more believable if Hollywood had a track record of casting a Soviet hierarchy as evil -- and if Hollywood didn't have its own organized dogma of secular fundamentalism.
Nicole Kidman spins it her way: "I was raised Catholic, the Catholic Church is part of my essence. I wouldn't be able to do this film if I thought it were at all anti-Catholic." The media have played happily along in disguising Pullman's religion-bashing. On NBC's "Today," weatherman Al Roker delighted in making "The Golden Compass" the fall book selection of "Al's Book Club for Kids." Pullman appeared on NBC to deny that he was really promoting atheism. He touted letting the reader decide what the author intended, in a "democracy of reading." The closest he came to atheism was saying the book championed "open-minded intellectual curiosity." If that sounds like a transparent dodge, it certainly was. He told the students asking questions to think of the Taliban in Afghanistan. But the menace in Pullman's trilogy isn't called the Caliphate, and its hideous monsters aren't mullahs. They are cardinals and priests, and the heroes are an atheist former nun and two rebellious gay male angels.
The atheists may be angry that the movie waters down Pullman's anti-religious message, but they can take comfort in the fact that many parents (and grandparents and even godparents) will, sadly, buy the hype over this movie and buy this trilogy of vicious anti-religious books for the young readers in their lives. To the Christian book buyer, beware: Instead of celebrating God's son born in the flesh, you'll be celebrating God being killed so that man can advance to true consciousness. For those anticipating the wonder of Narnia, you'll have to wait until next May, when "Prince Caspian," the second installment, returns magic to the screen.
Yes, figures someone beat me to that 'good' idea. I can see this becoming the next Potter series. Ugh. Courageous of that parent to complain. I guess it should be 'coming soon to a public grade school near you'.
ping
Last movie we went to see was Narnia. We’ll see Prince Caspian when it comes out. I guess that gets us about every 2-3 years also.
No one needs to go supporting garbage like this. With the *how do you know if you don’t try it* mentality, all that ends up happening is the everyone either has to read the book or watch the movie and they end up supporting the very thing that’s condemning them.
No thanks. I can trust some other people’s judgment and do not feel inclined to waste my money on trash like that. If you do, fine by me. Just don’t expect me to behave a certain way because you think it’s right.
You must be pretty old, then. How many centuries ago were you born?
That little girl in the picture looks like the Witch they cast in Chronicles of Narnia.
I actually had a long-time customer ask about “The Golden Compass” tonight and that’s what I told him: “This is my opinion alone, but the Golden Compass is a razor blade hidden in cotton candy.” He agreed.
I’m not the chief of sinners, but I am proof that God’s Will will be done, whether or not I agree with Him!
He only has to teach me a lesson, what, 77 times before I get it!
It looked very intriguing, like a Harry Potter movie, or Narnia. Millions of kids are going to see this, and the ones with Godless, bitter parents will take one more step in that direction, going to reach for that cotton candy with the razor blade in it.
Sad.
Thanks for the post and ping.
My grands told me about this movie.
They were warned about it in school.
I haven’t read the entire thread, so I don’t know if this has been mentioned.
They said much of the offensive stuff wasn’t in the movie.
However, the goal is to entice the young ‘uns to become more interested in his books.
I’ve seen the previews, and am disturbed that kids will be drawn to it.
I hope parents will research this before allowing their kids to see it.
As for myself, I hope it bombs.
At least you can still count your lessons, FRiend. ;~)
Oh boy! Bump...for movie backgrounder
Thanks for the heads up! I really thought this was a C. S. Lewis-like story. The ads for it running here make it sound like it was the Narnia book I never knew about.
Pullman, hear this: I DONT HAVE TO DESTROY WHAT SHAMES ME IN ORDER TO LIVE WITH MYSELF. Thats why Atheists have as much freedom in America as I do.
Be reasonable. It is was well known at the time that “Last Temptation” portrayed Christ as homosexual, or at least as having homosexual tendencies. If I know that, am I allowed to call it “vile garbage” without having seen the film? Considering that Christ says homosexuality is an “abomination”, I think that’s pretty much on the mark.
How about if I call a child pornograher who rapes children a “pervert”? Do I have to watch him do it to decide?
I figure you are going to flame me for posting and running, but I do have to go to lunch. Flame away if you like, but I’ve said all I want to say on this. Have a nice week.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.