Posted on 07/05/2007 11:34:16 AM PDT by Bronco_Buster_FweetHyagh
The mother of a San Luis Obispo man who died after an attempted organ donation at Sierra Vista Regional Medical Center last year claims she never gave hospital officials consent to take her son off life-support and was misinformed when agreeing to the organ harvest, according to a wrongful death lawsuit.
Rosa Navarro also alleges in her June 29 civil lawsuit that a transplant surgeon misrepresented himself as her son’s doctor, an allegation the surgeon’s attorney strongly denies. She also said she agreed to the organ donation only because she believed her son had no chance of survival.
Defendants in the lawsuit — the San Luis Obispo hospital; its parent company, Dallas-based Tenet Corp.; the California Transplant Donor Network; transplant physicians Hootan Roozrokh and Arturo Martinez; and their employer, The Permanente Medical Group Inc.—are accused of assault, battery, fraud, civil conspiracy, negligence, medical malpractice and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Sierra Vista hospital on Tuesday denied any wrongdoing in the Feb. 4, 2006, death of 25-year-old Ruben Navarro.
Rosa Navarro, 54, is asking for unlimited compensation in the death of her son.
Ruben Navarro, who was dying of a rare metabolic disorder, had been on life support for four days and was expected to die. His mother agreed to donate his organs, and the California Transplant Donor Network dispatched its transplant team to Sierra Vista.
Rosa Navarro said during an interview from her Oxnard home Tuesday that when she arrived at the hospital she asked about her son’s condition. She said a hospital nurse told her to speak with the doctor.
“He came over and approached me and said I’m in charge of Ruben,” Navarro said of Roozrokh, who was part of the surgical team from San Francisco dispatched by Oakland-based Organ Transplant Donor Network.
“I asked him, ‘Doctor could you do anything for my boy?’ and he said, ‘Oh, no. Oh no… There’s nothing I can do for a patient like him.’ ”
Navarro said through sobs that Roozrokh asked her if she planned to watch him disconnect her son from life-support.
“He didn’t even ask me, ‘What do you want me to do Ms. Navarro? Do you want me to keep him on the machine or whatever?’ ” Navarro said.
Roozrokh’s attorney, M. Gerry Schwartzbach, told The Tribune on Tuesday that his client never spoke with Rosa Navarro and was not in charge of her son’s medical care.
“He did not have any conversation with her with regard to taking Ruben off the respirator. … Dr. Roozrokh was in the Bay Area,” Schwartzbach said. “I feel very bad for Ms. Navarro because she’s going through a great deal, but unfortunately someone misled her because she never met (Roozrokh) and she never spoke to him. That is absolutely clear.”
Schwartzbach said a local physician made the decision to remove Ruben Navarro from life support.
Ruben Navarro was brought into the operating room at 11 p.m. Feb. 3, 2006, and his breathing tube was removed. But he did not die within 30 minutes—the window during which organs could be harvested. He died nine hours later, according to the lawsuit.
An operating-room nurse reported that standard medical procedures weren’t followed when Navarro was taken off life support.
The lawsuit alleges Roozrokh ordered Ruben Navarro be given lethal doses of morphine and Ativan, an accusation also reported as a finding in a federal investigation by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
The report showed an intensive care nurse gave Ruben Navarro 220 milligrams of morphine and 80 milligrams of Ativan.
Sierra Vista spokesman Ron Yukelson did not respond to specific allegations against the hospital.
He did say a surgeon contracted with the donor network assumed responsibility for Navarro in violation of hospital policy, which requires a doctor to be credentialed by the hospital to treat a living patient.
District attorney’s investigators have been reviewing the case since March, but have made no decision about filing criminal charges.
“It’s a very unique case. No one’s prosecuted a case like this anywhere,” Assistant District Attorney Dan Hilford said Tuesday. “The case is very complex and deals with issues that require a great deal of research and study.”
State Medical Board spokeswoman Candis Cohen said the agency is investigating Roozrokh.
Martinez, the other doctor on the transplant team, could not be reached for comment.
I doubt most people have any problem in this area, although the Schiavo case has probably inspired people to be more detailed in expressing these wishes to their families.
I worry that after reading threads like this that people will go into situations like this assuming the worst about the doctors and disbelieving of anything they hear from them.
I’m sure corruption can and does exist at times, but I do not believe it is the norm.
After meeting other donor families, and receiving information from doctors involved in the process - we have only met very caring, ethical, and intelligent people.
H--- No, everybody has to die sometime, and I have no intentions of someone like bill clintoon being saved by my parts. When donations get to where you and are your family have control and some shyster doctor isn't being made wealthier, ping me.
which shyster doctor are you talking about?
The doctors who harvest, and who reimplant the organs are compensated for the procedure, just like they would be compensated for performing other types of surgery.
They are not being compensated for the organ.
How are you and your family going to manage to find a suitable match for the organ before it degrades to the point of being useless?
are you going to make your decision based on need? Or are you going to auction off to the highest bidder?
Whatever. You’re a fine one to talk - your posts strike me as quite disingenous. I could say more but don’t wish to be insulting, so I’ll leave it at that.
People like that are dangerous psychopaths who should be put away.
Ah crap! I had written something similar to this in a story I am working on. I have never seen the movie you mention. Proof that there are no original ideas in the world.
The Island is an awesome movie!
Gruesome, but with a message I was very surprised to see coming from Hollywood.
I felt the same way after seeing Children of Men
“”””I could say more but don’t wish to be insulting..”””
Too late...but there is time to give your condecension organ to someone.
This is an interesting site for determining how organ, blood and tissue donation is viewed from a religious perspective. Perhaps it will save insults and hurt feelings on this thread.
http://www.dcids.org/dci_religion.html
http://terrisfight.org/
No my post is not filled with inaccuracies as it relates to my experiences. You have found one story that is a glaring exception and chosen to smear the entire organ donor program with it. That is not how it is done, and it is most certainly not murder or suicide.
>>>>Must be big money in them soup-monkeys!
Do an FR keyword search on body brokers.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1534241/posts
>>>”The donor, whose name has not been released, was said to have been of a similar age and from the same area as Ms Dinoire. She had hanged herself. Permission for the transplant was given by her family after she was declared brain dead.”<<<
You first. Yours is obviously hyper-active, Mr. Condescending.
OMG - a thread from 2006 - That is frightening.
Introduced to a VIP physician from the Robt.Woods Johnson Foundation. Liberal think tank as I recall. Didn’t like him one bit. He was overly enthusiastic about Universal Health Care.
Maybe you should’ve told that doctor about what such a system would do to his paycheck.
ps, if I seem condescending it’s because I find it hard to take the paranoid ramblings of idiots seriously.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.