Posted on 06/14/2007 7:42:49 PM PDT by Moseley
Which, according to the logic of some people here, would make him a phony conservative. After all, he has consistently criticized Republican Presidents, including the one that was in office then. He even ran for Presidnetr himself once, outside the GOP.
Obviously a fake conservative.
No, I meant the “independence movement”.
Intellectual: Anyone who espouses irrational hate against democratic societies to suit the interests of China and the Islamic world.
Look at what TBP is upto again. This time, he is supporting muslim terrorists AKA “Kashmiri militants” and calling the terrorist scum a “legitimate independence movement.”
” I hope that their effort to take over a legitimate independence movement is defeated.”
Whose side are you on? India’s or Al Qaeda’s?
Kashmirwatch is a Paki news paper, whatever they spew about India is pure BS.
Neither. Both are anti-American.
This thread should be pulled.
Of course not; that's moonbat nonsense. But the fact is that they are trying to take over an indigenous independence movement.
Well, they can't argue with him about limited government, so they pick on his one weak spot and try to make his remarks out to mean something other than what tehy mean. I don't entirely agree with Paul about Mideast policy; I don't think that our leaving the area will suddenly turn these fanatical, terrorist Islamonazis into a bnch of nice guys. But that is a legitimate position and a far cry from what is being alleged here.
And the people who are trying to tie Paul to it know that.
The Al Qaeda are indigenous independence movement? You supporting the Al Qaeda ?
“Neither. Both are anti-American.”
Ok. Whose side are you on America’s or Kashmiri Jihad’s?
Unlike you, I’m on America’s side always.
Now, come on , Gengis. I know you're not that dumb. Go back and re-read what I said, honestly and openly. The Kashmiri freedom movement is a sui generis, indigenous independence movement, which Al Qaeda has tried to take over (with a degree of success, unfortunately.) They must be stopped from doing so.
The future of Kashmir has been bandied back and forth among numerous countries and organizations. But it is not India's to decide, nor Pakistan's, nor Al Qaeda's, nor the UN's, but the people of Kashmir's to decide. And they hvae been denied the right to decide their own fate ever since independence while otehrs have negotiated over them.
It's time to let the people there make that decision for tehmselves.
If you are on America’s side as you claim, how is it you support Kashmiri Jihad?
It’s time to let the people there make that decision for tehmselves.”
They have already decided in India’s favour long back. The part occupied by Pakistan is where the right have been denied for the last 50 years. That part much merge back to India in accordance. BTW people inside the rest of Pakistan should also be allowed to decide for themselves if they should remain with Pak or have their independence. Balochistan, Sindhudesh and Pakhtunkhwa should have a referendum/ or plebiscite for people to decide if they should remain within Pakistan. Recent events within Pakistan have indicated they are not happy being inside Pakistan.
“The Kashmiri freedom movement is a sui generis, indigenous independence movement, “
So all those Kashmiri groups like Hizbul Mujahideen, Jaish e mohammad, LET, harkat ul mujahideen and Harkat al ansar are sui generis and so you support their movement?
“Unlike you, I’m on America’s side always.”
You surprised I am on India’s side ...always?
False statement. The maharajah, who was Hindu, decided FOR a predominantly Muslim population. (BTW, in Hyderabad, where the situation was reveresed -- a Muslim maharajah and a predominantly Hindu population -- the Indian army marched in and prevented the maharajah from deciding this.) The vote that the people were promised in Kashmir 60 years ago has never occurred. They should be given the right to vote and decide for themselves, the democratic way.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.