In any event. Hillary would destroy Giuliani. Just as she would have stomped him like a stinkbug had he not pulled out of the Senate race due to ethical issues and prostate cancer.
I wholeheartedly disagree about the NY Senate race in 2000. Rudy would have mopped the floor with Hillary. He would have eaten into her base in the city and cleaned her clock upstate.
Lazio ran about the worst campaign I've ever seen and still kept it relatively close until the end.