Tell me which state that went Bush in 2000 and 2004 would go Hillary if Rudy was the nominee, but would be RED if Rudy wasnt the nominee.......OH might go DEM but will do so anyway...
I cannot see Pennsylvania or Michigan going for Guliani on your list. There is too much fraud. Throw in that in the next election the Ds are in a better position to steal Florida and Ohio, and thinks look worrisome for whichever candidate wins the primary.
I think Hillary would win Arkansas, Missouri and possibly Montana, Colorado and Florida against Rudy. Montana and Florida are certainly wacko predictions that violate the CW, but I have my suspicions.