alternate response:
Posted on 01/29/2007 6:54:51 AM PST by presidio9
Egypt is scoffing at a global contest to name the new seven wonders of the world, saying it is a disgrace that the ancient Pyramids of Giza — the only surviving structure from the traditional list of architectural marvels — must compete for a spot.
ADVERTISEMENT
Top Egyptian officials have criticized the popular contest that urges people around the world to vote for their top sites from a list of 21 finalists that lumps the pyramids with upstart wonders like the Statue of Liberty, the Eiffel Tower and Peru's Machu Picchu.
The pyramids are "living in the hearts of people around the globe, and don't need a vote to be among the world wonders," said the head of Egypt's Supreme Council of Antiquities, Zahi Hawass, according to the state-run Middle East News Agency.
Egyptian officials refused to meet with the organizer of the "New 7 Wonders of the World" contest, the Swiss adventurer Bernard Weber, when he visited Egypt earlier this month, said the contest's spokeswoman Tia B. Viering. When Weber tried to hold a press conference near the pyramids, she said, police shut it down.
Organizers say the hostility is unwarranted, claiming the competition is supposed to renew international interest in culture and history, not strip the pyramids of their ancient status.
"The contest is not about taking something away, it's about moving something into modern times," Viering said.
The Egyptian pyramids are the only surviving structures from the traditional list of seven wonders of the ancient world, derived by later authors from various lists of marvels cited by ancient Greek and Roman writers.
Besides the pyramids, according to the Encyclopedia Britannica, the best known list includes the Hanging Gardens of Babylon, the Colossus of Rhodes, the ancient lighthouse that once stood on the island of Pharos in Alexandria, Egypt, and three other long-vanished edifices.
Choosing a new roster of world wonders has attracted ongoing interest over the years: The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, UNESCO, list of World Heritage Sites includes 830 selections.
Weber started his project in 1999, collecting nearly 200 nominations. That list was eventually narrowed to 21 by a panel of architectural experts, chaired by former UNESCO chief Federico Mayor.
But Weber wanted the masses to pick the top seven. People can vote on the Internet, by phone or by sending a cell phone text message until July 6. The seven winners will be announced on the symbolic date of July 7.
Half of the revenues raised by the campaign will go toward restoring historic sites, including the Bamiyan Buddha statue in Afghanistan, which was destroyed by the Taliban regime.
As part of the campaign, Weber is visiting each of the 21 sites, which also include the Great Wall of China, the Sydney Opera House, Stonehenge and the Acropolis in Athens.
Almost everywhere Weber has gone, he has been welcomed, but not in Egypt.
"We think it's about ego, and we don't know why the hostility is there," Viering said in a telephone interview from Belgium this weekend.
Egypt's Culture Minister Farouk Hosni, according to the Middle East News Agency, called the contest "nonsense" and "an attempt to seek celebrity and their efforts to meet Egyptian officials to give the contest significance won't take place. They have to understand the archaeological and the historical stature of the pyramids."
Egypt's ire may not hurt the pyramid's chances of making it on the new list. With more than 24 million votes so far, Viering said tombs — which are more than 4,000 years old — are in the top seven.
"We know that people all around the world want the pyramids as part of this as do people in Egypt," Viering said.
___
Bummer. I can cover it with my hand.
(Alternate response: That's some monitor you have.)
It is: it's part of the Acropolis.
feinted=fainted.
sigh.
Agreed, one of the few things muslims have done right was perserve their heritage, even of objects created before islam. Egyptians should be and rightfully proud of their ancient culture. With the exception of the Taliban, most muslim cultures were better keepers of the past them christian cultures (at least until the enlightenment).
This is simple, have both ancient and modern wonders of the world.
I agree. I certainly like the Statue of Liberty, but to say that it's more wonderful than say, the Sistine Chapel, to me is just absurd on its face.
The Sistine Chapel is two wonderous paintings. It is not a particularly impressive building.
The colossus of Rhodes fell during an Earthquake in 224 B.C. The locals were afraid to restore it as they feared offending the god Helios. There were no Moslems around then.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colossus_of_Rhodes
alternate response:
Herein lies the conundrum - we're limited to seven picks.
And the main reason I picked the Acropolis is the methods used in its construction. The Greeks took perspective into account - a true 'wonder' at the time. The columns for instance get slightly larger in diameter as they go up the top, so when you look up the width (diameter) appears to be consistent to the eye. And IIRC they did it with the exterior walls too - they're not right angles, again taking perspective into account. So considering that it is a 'Wonder'.
Sadly, no. The hanging gardens and colossus were destroyed by weather.
The statue of Zeus was dismantled by a Christian Roman emperor who was worried about the worship of the statue. I don't recall the rest.
Alouette stands corrected; the "wonders of the world" were already destroyed before the Moslems had the chance to destroy them.
No. Some of the seven wonders had been destroyed when the list was compiled.
I do have to agree that the pyramids should almost get an automatic bye.
I nominate:
Pyramids
Great Wall of China
Google server complex (Googolplex?)
The Vatican
The Empire State Building
The Trans-Atlantic cable
The Chunnel
Also-rans:
The Forbidden City
The Verazzano Bridge
Three Gorges Dam
The Panama Canal
Golden Gate Bridge
I would have nominated the World Trade Center, also, except for those damned Muslims. I deliberated in my mind about nominating the Pentagon.
Yuck.
>> Acropolis <<
Cindy Sheehan: What! I'm outraged! the US is represented its naval school!
I'm pretty sure jpl meant St. Peter's, right?
Some of the original "Seven Wonders" were destroyed before being listed ... so if you think the New York WTC was a 'wonder of the world", go ahead and nominate it. Heck with the mohammedans.
Neither the Colossus nor the Lighthouse were destroyed by Moslems but by earthquakes. Nor was the Hanging Gardens for that matter. Not that this makes Islam any more acceptable.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.