Posted on 01/03/2007 9:51:00 AM PST by Diddle E. Squat
AUSTIN — They work as maids and busboys. They build homes and highways. They bone chickens on the way to market.
They are worth billions of dollars to the Texas economy, but as members of the working poor they also are a drain of hundreds of millions of dollars from taxpayers.
They are the 1.4 million illegal immigrants that the federal government estimates live in Texas.
Half are divided evenly between the Dallas and Houston areas, according to the Center for Immigration Studies, with an additional 20 percent in the Lower Rio Grande Valley. Less than 5 percent live in the traditional Hispanic capital of Texas: San Antonio.
Their numbers in Texas grew by 270,000 in five years, and an estimated 70 percent of the 26,000 births at Houston and Dallas public hospitals in 2005 were to mothers who are undocumented immigrants. Unreimbursed care cost the Harris County Hospital District $97 million in 2005.
And with Congress failing to enact comprehensive immigration reform, illegal immigrants are poised to become one of the hottest issues before the Texas Legislature.
"If we do nothing, in 10 years, just based on the current birth rate, we're going to have 50 million (illegal immigrants and their children) in the United States. Our country will change totally. Our culture will be gone," said state Rep. Leo Berman, R-Tyler. "We've been invaded without firing a shot."
The fight by Berman and other conservative legislators to battle illegal immigration at the state level is likely to be emotional and possibly bitter.
Some Republicans and the influential Texas Association of Business want no action from state lawmakers, especially if it involves employer sanctions. And Democratic Hispanic legislators say conservatives such as Berman are using Latinos as a "political piñata."
"Politically, some people get caught up in trying to score cheap political points, but it doesn't contribute to the discussion about immigration and immigration reform," said state Rep. Rick Noriega, D-Houston.
A dozen bills already have been filed dealing with illegal immigration, many focused on restricting state and local services. A legislative caucus also has proposed harsh sanctions on businesses that employ illegal immigrants.
Then-Comptroller Carole Keeton Strayhorn recently issued a report saying illegal immigrants are worth at least $17.7 billion to the state's economy. She said the taxes they pay cover the cost of state services, but she also said they are a drain of about $929 million on local governments, mostly because of the costs associated with indigent health care.
Berman said he thinks Strayhorn's report seriously underestimates the cost of illegal immigrants to the state. Citing research by the conservative Lone Star Foundation, Berman said illegal immigrants cost the state $3.5 billion a year.
Some of the legislation and legislative proposals involving illegal immigrants include:
• Birthright citizenship: Berman's bill would deny automatic citizen access to state programs for children born in Texas to illegal immigrant parents after his bill becomes law. Berman wants the bill, if passed, to be used to test birthright citizenship in the federal courts.
Berman said "anchor babies" should not have automatic citizenship because the 14th Amendment requires the baby must be "subject to the jurisdiction" of the United States.
"We want to show the illegal aliens here have no desire at all to accept our culture or speak our language," Berman said.
Noriega said Berman's legislation "flies in the face" of U.S. national values. He said a sensible federal immigration policy would end many problems.
Gov. Rick Perry, who made border security a major issue of his re-election campaign, recently called legislation such as Berman's divisive.
• Remittance fees: Legislation would levy an 8 percent fee on the remittances that are sent from Texas to Mexico and Latin America, although U.S. citizens and legal resident aliens could ask for a refund. The fee would raise about $250 million, Berman said, which would go to hospitals that provide health care for illegal immigrants.
The average first U.S. job for a new illegal immigrant pays $900 a month compared with about $150 in their native country, according to the Inter-American Development Bank.
This year, Latin Americans in Texas will send about $5.2 billion back home in wire transfers, typically about $100 to $300 a month. Remittances from Mexicans living in the U.S. amount to almost 3 percent of that country's gross national product. The remittance fee bill may have a good chance of passing because it is being sponsored in the House by Berman and in the Senate by liberal Sen. Royce West, D-Dallas.
• In-state college tuition: Several bills, including one by Rep. Debbie Riddle, R-Tomball, would eliminate in-state tuition for undocumented immigrant children who attend public colleges. They would have to pay the higher tuition of foreign students who are legal residents.
"In-state tuition is meant for people who are here legally, not illegally," Riddle said. "Taxpayers have to subsidize tuition."
The tuition law was passed in 2001, carried by Noriega and Sen. Leticia Van de Putte, D-San Antonio. Current state law allows any student who has lived in the state for three years and graduated from a Texas high school to get in-state tuition.
Strayhorn estimated about 3,800 children of immigrants got in-state college tuition in 2004, less than 1 percent of all students in Texas institutions of higher education.
• Proof of citizenship for voting: Several bills would require proof of citizenship for a person to vote. Similar legislation has failed in the past.
• Marriage licenses: People applying for a marriage license would have to swear under penalty of felony perjury that they are not getting married to circumvent immigration laws.
• Driver's license: Legislation would allow immigrants to obtain a Texas driver's license by using a similar document from a foreign country.
Supporters say illegal immigrants are here and driving but without a license they cannot buy auto insurance. Opponents say issuing licenses on unsecure foreign documents could pose a security risk.
• Employer sanctions: No bills have been filed, but the research arm of a legislative caucus called the Texas Conservative Coalition proposes several sanctions against companies that employ illegal immigrants.
Bo Pilgrim, of Pittsburg, who runs the nation's largest poultry producing company, said the nation needs the labor of the illegal immigrants who are living in the shadows.
"I'm here to testify that it's real," Pilgrim recently told a group of border mayors. "If we lose those people, the economy of the United States will simply go down the drain."
I put the number closer to 3 million.
"• Birthright citizenship: Berman's bill would deny automatic citizen access to state programs for children born in Texas to illegal immigrant parents after his bill becomes law. Berman wants the bill, if passed, to be used to test birthright citizenship in the federal courts.
Berman said "anchor babies" should not have automatic citizenship because the 14th Amendment requires the baby must be "subject to the jurisdiction" of the United States."
I have stated the same here.
Evidently journalists don't have to take logic courses in college.
We have all these illegals who are bleeding state and local government dry, and "comprehensive immigration reform" (amnesty) is the way to fix the problem by legalizing the welfare state recipients so that they can collect even more benefits and bring in more family to suck up more resources.
And encourage another 20-30 million to sneak in and wait for the next amnesty.
Thank you, Mr. President and Karl Rove. Wish I got the same lush government pension and K Street consultant gigs after I lost my job.
Yup. Texas government has been a bastion of corruption for decades. Doesn't matter if the critters have a "D" or "R" by their name, they are pretty much universally corrupt in just about every way imaginable.
The proposals mentioned in the article aren't bad, but I seriously doubt we'll see any of them become law.
"Bo Pilgrim, of Pittsburg, who runs the nation's largest poultry producing company, said the nation needs the labor of the illegal immigrants who are living in the shadows."
Bo Pilgrim should be in jail.
Take a look around, Pilgrim.. They aren't "living in the shadows". They are out in the open, everywhere, and in our face.
sw
And illegals should be quickly deported whenever they are identified as such by law enforcement. As non-citizens, they are not protected by all of the rights of citizenship and should be air-dropped onto Greenland's north shore as soon as the C-130 is full. Kidz too.
This is extremely misleading. Comprehensive calculations have shown that illegal aliens (on the average) cost far more than they contribute to the US economy.
Illegal alien workers make contributions which benefit employers, but their associated costs are spread out to everyone else in the region. Their children, alone, cost almost $10,000 per year per child, to educate. Other costs include more traffic accidents (almost all uninsured), high use of "free" medical care, a huge percentage of street crime, etc.
The net cost to the citizens of Texas is probably at least $50B / year.
Pilgrim recently told a group of border mayors. "If we lose those people, the economy of the United States will simply go down the drain."
Of course he did. What else would he say? Greedy Bastard!
ping
"I'm here to testify that it's real," Pilgrim recently told a group of border mayors. "If we lose those people, the economy of the United States will simply go down the drain."
Bo Pilgrim is a drama queen. We don't need illegal aliens in the United States for any reason. Any job currently being done by an illegal alien can just as well be done by a legal immigrant. If we need additional foreign workers. Congress can increase the number of foreigners that we allow into our country each year.
"I'm here to testify that it's real," Pilgrim recently told a group of border mayors. "If we lose those people, the economy of the United States will simply go down the drain."
No, Bo, the economy will not go down the drain. What WILL go down the drain is the immense wealth of individualsl like you and your cronies who own multiple mansions all over the place, yachts and that huge piece of ranch just east of Mt. Pleasant off of I-30 up there where all of the big politicians and your cronies all go for private hunts that almost no one except those who live there know about. Perhaps if you would pay a reasonable wage to Americans, you could find all of the labor you want and you would STILL be very wealthy, just not as wealthy as you would like to be (owning EVERYTHING).
There. Fixed it. I suspect there has never been a reliable study on costs vs. benefits because the slave labour lobby doesn't want to know.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.