Posted on 11/16/2006 8:58:11 PM PST by NormsRevenge
SAN DIEGO
A federal judge on Thursday temporarily blocked the city of Escondido from enforcing a law that punishes landlords for renting to illegal immigrants.
U.S. District Judge John Houston said he had serious questions about whether the law would survive legal scrutiny and said it may inflict "irreparable harm" on tenants and landlords.
The law was scheduled to take effect Friday in the suburb 30 miles north of San Diego, where Hispanics make up 42 percent of the 142,000 residents.
Houston did not say how long his order would last, but said he would schedule a hearing in the case within four months.
The lawsuit was filed earlier this month on behalf of two Escondido landlords and two women who live in the country illegally but whose children are U.S. citizens and attend school in the city. The suit, filed by the American Civil Liberties Union, alleges that the law illegally punishes landlords for renting to illegal immigrants.
One of the landlords, Roy Garrett, welcomed the decision.
"(Illegal immigrants) are there, it's reality, it is immoral to force them to leave," Garrett said.
An attorney for the city declined to comment.
The City Council voted 3-2 last month to require landlords to submit documentation of their tenants' immigration status to the city, which would then verify that information with the federal government.
If tenants are found to be illegal immigrants, landlords would be given 10 days to evict them or face suspension of their business licenses. Repeat offenders could face misdemeanor charges and fines.
Last month, the ACLU persuaded a federal judge to temporarily block the city of Hazleton, Pa., from enforcing a crackdown on illegal immigrants.
The lawsuit alleges that the Escondido ordinance which is modeled on Hazleton's violates federal and state laws and puts landlords in an "impossible position" of enforcing immigration laws.
"The ordinance is riddled with constitutional flaws and ignores the subtleties, complexities and primacy of federal immigration law," according to the lawsuit.
The city argues that the law aims to alleviate the "significant and costly burdens on society" that are posed by illegal immigrants. Officials have said it would only be enforced on leases signed after it takes effect.
More than 50 municipalities nationwide have considered, passed or rejected laws to crack down on illegal immigration.
In Hazleton, a pair of measures approved by City Council would impose fines on landlords who rent to illegal immigrants, deny business permits to companies that give them jobs, and require tenants to register with City Hall and pay for a rental permit. A federal judge temporarily prohibited the laws from taking effect, saying they posed "irreparable harm" to landlords, tenants and businesses that cater to Hispanics.
This week, the Dallas suburb of Farmers Branch adopted a measure that would require tenants to submit documentation to the landlord when making or renewing leases. That measure takes effect Jan. 12.
Judge Info..
Houston, John A.
Born 1952 in Greensboro, NC
Federal Judicial Service:
Judge, U. S. District Court, Southern District of California
Nominated by George W. Bush on May 1, 2003, to a new seat created by 116 Stat. 1758; Confirmed by the Senate on October 2, 2003, and received commission on October 7, 2003.
U.S. Magistrate Judge, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California, 1998-2003
Education:
North Carolina A & T State University, B.S., 1974
University of Miami at Coral Gables School of Law, J.D., 1977
Professional Career:
U.S. Army Reserve, 1974-1978, 1981-present
U.S. Army, Judge Advocate General Corps, 1978-1981
Assistant U.S. attorney, U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of California, 1981-1987
Chief, Asset Forfeiture Unit, U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of California, 1987-1994
Senior counsel for asset forfeiture, U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of California, 1994-1996
Senior financial litigation counsel, U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of California, 1996-1998
Race or Ethnicity: African American
Gender: Male
Frito Bandito in Escondido?
:The suit, filed by the American Civil Liberties Union, alleges that the law illegally punishes landlords for renting to illegal immigrants."
The nativists are going to get restless again.
Irreparable harm? Unbelievable!
B.S.
Tyrant judges deserve tyrant consequences.
One of the landlords, Roy Garrett, welcomed the decision.
"(Illegal immigrants) are there, it's reality, it is immoral to force them to leave," Garrett said
_____________________________________________
I'm sure he is not going to think "it is immoral to force them to leave" (eviction) when one of these illegally "immigrants" don't pay their rent.
>> Irreparable harm? Unbelievable!
Wait until employers of illegal immigrants are similarly shielded from suffering 'Irreparable harm.'
Fixed
I love your screen name. :)
And thank you for the "fix."
I must be getting old. 2:00am used to be 'uptoolate', now more like 12:00.
My pleasure.
Maybe 'upnotaslateanymore'???
lol! I'm with ya on that one.
roflmao! YUP! My brain wants to stay up, but not my body (and I'm not so sure about my brain anymore either).
So the judge is supporting lawbreakers? Interesting!
We're close to hearing that every day. We can't get force illegals out of the country "or the economy will suffer".... etc. In the meantime, taxpayers get socked with more bonds for affordable housing, highways, and so on. It needs to stop. I'll be rooting for Escondido! If they lose, I may move to Mexico! lol.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.