Posted on 09/23/2006 10:07:25 AM PDT by wagglebee
LONDON, September 22, 2006 (LifeSiteNews.com) – The Swiss suicide organization that has helped to kill at least 54 British clients and uncounted others from around Europe, is in a test case in the country’s Supreme Court arguing that people suffering from depression or who are “tired of life” should be able to legally use the facility to end their lives.
Ludwig Minelli, the founder of Dignitas, the Zurich-based organisation said his group was seeking to overturn the Swiss law that allows them to assist only people with a terminal illness.
Following in the wake of the international conference of the Right to Die movement in Toronto earlier this month, the move has come as no surprise to euthanasia opponents, who say it has always been part of the plan to make assisted suicide and euthanasia legal for anyone who wants it.
Alex Schadenberg, Executive Director of Canada’s Euthanasia Prevention Coalition, who attended the conference, says Minelli’s court battle is proof at last of the falsehood of the claim that the push to legalize euthanasia is about caring for people in distress.
Schadenberg said that Minelli's request for assisted suicide for the depressed is an admission that the euthanasia/assisted suicide movement is essentially a “death on demand culture.”
He warned that the demand for changes in the law for terminally ill people “rationally requesting a peaceful death,” are part of a larger “strategy of the death culture” and not the final goal.
“In fact euthanasia and assisted suicide have nothing to do with terminal illness or rational choices, but rather a demand for an unfettered ability to commit suicide,” Schadenberg said. “What Minelli is admitting is that people should have the right to suicide assistance, even if they can't rationally consent or they aren't terminal,” he concluded.
At the World Federation of Right to Die international conference in Toronto a debate was held on strategy between Canadian Derek Humphrey – considered a “radical” even among euthanasia campaigners – and Dr. Rob Jonquière of the Netherlands. Dr. Jonquière was opposed to the radical strategy of Derek Humphrey pushing for legalization on the grounds that it added to public suspicion as to the overall agenda.
Jonquière argued that a subtler method will be to have euthanasia legalized in the Netherlands for people who are "tired of living,” using the language of compassion and caring.
Following the movement’s strong anti-Catholic sentiments, Minelli blamed “religion” for stigmatising suicide, attacking this “stupid ecclesiastical superstition” against suicide and euthanasia.
Schadenberg told LifeSiteNews.com that a leading theme of the Toronto conference was the movement’s hatred for Christianity and Catholicism in particular which it sees as the only credible opposition to their goals.
Minelli, speaking to a group of Liberal Democrats in England, confirmed Schadenberg’s thesis, saying, “We should see in principle suicide as a marvellous possibility given to human beings because they have a conscience . . . If you accept the idea of personal autonomy, you can’t make conditions that only terminally ill people should have this right.”
“We should accept generally the right of a human being to say, ‘Right, I would like to end my life’, without any pre-condition, as long as this person has capacity of discernment.”
A spokesman for English disability groups concurred with Schadenberg’s analysis saying, “This confirms the suspicions of many disabled people that legalising assisted suicide would be the start of a slippery slope that would lead to anyone, whatever their condition, being helped or even coerced into opting for death.”
Read coverage in the UK’s Telegraph:
Depression is not a good reason to die
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/main.jhtml?xml=/health/200...
Read related LifeSiteNews.com coverage:
Swiss Assisted Suicide Entrepreneur Wants to Open Chain of Suicide “Clinics”
http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2006/apr/06041807.html
Freepmail wagglebee or little jeremiah to subscribe or unsubscribe from the moral absolutes ping list.
FreeRepublic moral absolutes keyword search
If the elections go like I think they are then the entire membership of D.U. might well qualify for this service, maybe they can come over on a boat and sit 12 miles out to offer their services to them cheaper?
Isn't this the same "group" that recommended drowning "the thirsty?"
Imagine that practice married with a political agenda that decides millions of are "depressed".?.
But you see, it's an unbecoming trait in an Ubermensch....
**Depression is treatable, it is NOT a terminal illness.**
Absolutely!
Please notify me via FReepmail if you would like to be added to or taken off the Catholic Discussion Ping List.
Next will be baldness or nearsightedness.
How such an atrocious scenario could ever be seriously considered by any Court is beyond me. "Assisted suicide" has crossed over the line into premeditated murder. This is a sign of the darkness and hopelessness that humanity feels as a result of the faithlessness that pervades the West in these times.
this article should interest the managed care companies in the U.S. and Medicare part D plans, which have to spend a lot of money for meds to treat depression. i think this approach could really cut expenses, raise profits, and help the national economy.
assisted suicide will soon become the "treatment of choice for depression".
however, the greedy pharmaceutical companies and the mental health lobby will probably fight this, because it will threaten their profits.
if this approach its approved, depression will have become a terminal illness.
Culture of Death Ping.
It's not always a temporary problem. Mine is chronic for about 40 years now and gotten much worse over the last 15 years. My life still has meaning to me, you learn how to live with it, you aren't fully functional like most people you know, but it is still worth living, and you can still accomplish a lot, contribute a little to society, and be there for your family.
This idea is ridiculous and dangerous especially because for a lot of people, depression is more or less temporary and can be treated in numerous ways. To end your life because of it, I understand why some people do that, but the worst eventually passes if you tough it out. Every day is not bad, and some people only have one major episode in their entire lifetime and bounce back and have great, normal lives for years and die a natural death in old age from something else.
What's Wrong With Involuntary Euthanasia?and this:
Involuntary Euthanasia is Out of Control in Hollandthen ask if we are not far from this: this.
I wasn't trying to be flippant, Aliska. I know whereof you speak - clinical depression has run in my family. Sux when you just can't get fired up about life.
How about liberal politicians and judges, add in a few doctors, after all I have determined they have no real quality of life.
I didn't take it that way, just picked your comment as being most relevant along with the article to respnd to. Not to worry.
Normal people who will never have to be treated for depression often have days when they can't get fired up about life. Then there are those who seem perpetually fired up, and you wonder if they are covering up for something. I guess it's all part of the human condition.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.