Posted on 06/13/2006 6:31:01 PM PDT by Sabramerican
An unhyphenated people ashley perry, THE JERUSALEM POST Jun. 14, 2006
People often ask me where my family is from. I reply Britain, and they invariably ask me where my grandparents came from, and I reply again, Britain. Sometimes they will ask where my great-grandparents or great-great-grandparents came from and the reply is still Britain.
This answer is usually met with incredulity as most assume that Anglo-Jewry is in the main no more than two or three generations old and has its origins in Eastern Europe. When I tell these same people that I am in fact 17th-generation British, I am met with disbelieving and astonished looks.
The fact is my family has been in Britain for 350 years and, unlike most of Anglo-Jewry today, we are Sephardim (Jews of Spanish and Portuguese ancestry). My ancestors were admitted to England shortly after the English Civil War, when the Lord Protector Oliver Cromwell, having won a raging battle against the Monarchists, needed financiers to reinvigorate the war-torn English economy.
Rabbi Menassah Ben Israel of the Amsterdam community petitioned Cromwell to readmit Jews to a land which had not officially seen a Jew in over 360 years. Cromwell accepted the petition but only after a heated exchange with those who sought to prevent Jews from being readmitted.
The first Jewish community in Britain for centuries consisted of no more than a handful of families who arrived from the thriving Sephardi Jewish community in Amsterdam to try their luck in London. After a few more years and the addition of new families, the first synagogue was built, namely Bevis Marks, which still stands, although sadly under-used, in the City of London.
My rich Sephardi-Anglo background, with its honorary titles and coats-of-arms, leaves me somewhat divided. While on the one hand I am proud of what British Jewry has achieved, on the other I am saddened by what being British has made the Jews.
"Britishness" is a hotly debated subject in those Isles today; many are asking what British means and how one attains this appellation. As opposed to some other parts of the world, it is not done to apply an adjective to your nationality. You cannot be "African-British" or "Asian-British." It is far more simple than that, you are either British, or you are not.
UNLIKE MOST other minorities, Jews can hide all elements of their heritage and become "British." This has led to a quandary for many Jews, especially in this generation. Jews no longer want to be outsiders in any way, and with help from a certain amount of antipathy they have morphed into the British cultural and social landscape with few, if any, discernible characteristics.
British Jews, unlike their American counterparts, have anglicized their names and their customs. My father and grandfather both felt it necessary to change their name from the foreign-sounding Pereira-Perez to Perry as they went off to fight "Johnny-Foreigner" in the two world wars.
Anglo-Jewry has literally had to take its kippa off its head, as Chief Rabbi Jonathan Sacks suggested due to security concerns a few years ago.
I have my own personal opinions as to why British mistrust and suspicion of the Jews is so different and perhaps at a higher social level than most other forms of world-wide anti-Semitism.
The British consider themselves the height of civilization, the founders of democracy and the force that brought culture to much of the world. However, there is one people that has lived with the British for many years, reminding them that their civilization is relatively new.
A good example of this was a retort by prime minister Benjamin Disraeli to an anti-Semitic remark aimed at him in the House of Commons: "When the right honorable gentlemen's ancestors were savages on an unknown Island, mine were priests in the Temple of Solomon," Disraeli responded.
FOR THE BRITISH, who like to look down their noses at most nations in the world, there is one people among them who constantly remind them of their humble beginnings. I do believe that this rankles the British upper and literary social set, which finds its manifestations in the so-called chattering classes.
A few years ago Penelope Wyatt reported in the Spectator the remark of a peer in her upper-middle class social milieu: "Thank God, we can once again say what we want about the Jews."
While in most Western countries anti-Semitism is usually the bastion of the underprivileged and those from the lower-socioeconomic classes, in Britain its strongest protagonists are to be found at the opposite end of the social spectrum.
As Anglo-Jewry celebrates 350 years since its readmittance, I look back on my own familial Anglo-Jewish narrative with a mixture of pride, interest, and a heavy dose of consternation. Anglo-Jewry faces an uncertain future as it struggles for its own identity.
As for me, I have made my choice. From my side of the family, at least, there will not be an 18th British generation. I have returned to Israel, where my roots extend far deeper than those of my sojourn in the British Isles.
The writer is development coordinator for the Jewish People's Project at the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. He made aliya five years ago and lives in Efrat.
"British Jews, unlike their American counterparts, have anglicized their names and their customs."
The author evidentally has not met any assimilated, southern Jews in the United States, whose families go back to Colonial days on this continent.
Are there many left? As a kid, I read a book called Mr. Benjamin's Sword, about Judah P. Benjamin, and it inspired me to go looking up the history of Jews in the US. Turned out that a large percentage, from what I gathered even the majority (until maybe the late 19th or early 20th century) were in the South.
If you could tell me a bit more, I'd be grateful.
---------------------------
Yep.
Well, he made good on his declarations and moved to the Holy Land. What would you have preferred?
My family goes back 5 generations in the United States. Yes, we are all proud Americans, but my children have also chosen paths that led them to Canada, Israel, and Russia.
None can squelch a twit quite like an Englishman. With his telling of the Disraeli squelch, the author makes most clear his essentially English weltanschaung.
Okay, so I am not going crazy... :)
Some Americans make the false accusation that British Jews in general are not loyal to the UK. I suspect that the allegiance of those Americans is to Rome.
Why did the Chief Rabbi of London have to warn English Jews not to wear skull-caps in public?
All European nations are tribal. It's not necessarily bad, but for someone who considers immigrating, United States (or Canada or Australia) would be a better choice.
Where did he insult his homeland? What he did was point out that antisemitism pervades the British upper classes. That's a criticism, not an insult.
People often ask me where my family is from. I reply Britain, and they invariably ask me where my grandparents came from, and I reply again, Britain. Sometimes they will ask where my great-grandparents or great-great-grandparents came from and the reply is still Britain.
It reminds me a Russian joke:
Some guy comes to the civil records office and ask for change of his name.
The clerk says: "It will cost you a lot"
The guy answers: "I don't care. I have to change my name".
So the clerk ask: "What new name do you wish to have?"
"Pyotr Petrovich Petrov"
Clerk writes it down and asks: "Good, and what is you present name?"
"Ivan Ivanovitch Ivanov"
Clerks stares at the customer with curiosity, and says:
"Ivan Iwanovich Ivanov is a very good Russian name! Why do you want to change it?"
"Because people always ask me - what was your previous name?"
The linked story merits a second look after reading this author's opinion.
Why would the British Monarchy be jealous of the success of the Jews?
http://209.157.64.201/focus/f-news/1591071/posts
I LOVE Oliver Cromwell. A SMART man, as well as a (necessarily) brutal bastard when he needed to be.
If only a NEW Cromwell would emerge to send those welfare cases from the House of Windsor-Hanover-Saxe Coburg to the gallows.
Yeah, I spent the last year in Britain and didn't encounter any anti-Semitism. Only the contrary, if possible. Then again, I was in the countryside, in what could very well be considered flyover/redneck (or, in the case of Eastbourne, chav) country Britain.
Perhaps if I was in London, it might be otherwise, but then I suspect most anti-Semitism wouldn't come from the British right (except maybe a few inbred aristocrats), but from the British left, and particularly among immigrants. Likely belonging to a certain religion of peace and tolerance.
He should get points for honesty. And Ken Livingstone should be tarred, feathered and rode out of London on a rail.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.