Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Victor Davis Hanson: In the Eye of the Beholder. Imagine if we’d reported on WWII the way we do now
NRO ^ | May 12, 2006 | Victor Davis Hanson

Posted on 05/12/2006 4:41:46 AM PDT by Tolik

Imagine if we’d reported and opined on WWII the way we do now.

I think Franklin Delano Roosevelt, Henry Stimson, and George Marshall conducted the Second World War brilliantly, despite “thousands of mistakes.” But I can also envision how our present intelligentsia and punditocracy would have sized up their sometimes less than perfect efforts or applied their own reporting to the struggle against Japan and Germany. So imagine something like the following op-ed appearing, say, around May 1, 1945.

The Present Debacle

May 21, 1945 — After the debacles of February and March at Iwo Jima, and now the ongoing quagmire on Okinawa, we are asked to accept recent losses that are reaching 20,000 dead brave American soldiers and yet another 50,000 wounded in these near criminally incompetent campaigns euphemistically dubbed “island hopping.”

Meanwhile, we are no closer to victory over Japan. Instead, we are hearing of secret plans of invasion of the Japanese mainland slated for 1946 or even 1947 that may well make Okinawa seem like a cake walk and cost us a million casualties and perhaps involve a half-century of occupation. The extent of the current Kamikaze threat, once written off as the work of a “bunch of dead-enders,” was totally unforeseen, even though such suicidal zealots are in the process of inflicting the worst casualties on the U.S. Navy in its entire history.

Worse still, our sources in the intelligence community speak of a billion-dollar boondoggle now underway in the American southwest. This improbable “super-weapon” (with the patently absurd name “Manhattan Project”—in the midst of a desert no less!) promises in one fell swoop to erase our mistakes and give us instant deliverance from our blunders—no concern, of course, for the thousands of innocents who would be vaporized if such a monstrous fantasy bomb were ever actually to work.

We are only now coming off even more terrible losses in Europe, after being surprised by a supposedly defeated enemy in the Ardennes where another 20,000 Americans were killed and another 60,000 wounded or missing—again, due to our continued strategic incompetence and abject intelligence failures. Macabre reports of American bazooka shells bouncing off German Tiger tanks and our Shermans ablaze like Ronson lighters have only now come to light as we plow the Belgium countryside for yet another new American war cemetery. Tragically, this is not the first, but the fourth year of this war, when victory rather than endless bloodshed has been long promised.

A number of issues arise. Why is Henry Stimson (“Gentlemen do not read each other's mail”) still Secretary of War? After the debacles at Pearl Harbor, the Philippines tragedy, the Kasserine Pass disaster, the unforeseen bocage in Normandy, the Falaise Gap escape, the Anzio mess, the fatal detour to Rome, the surprise at the Bulge, the bloodbath at Tarawa, and now the Iwo Jima and Okinawa nightmares, is not five years of his incompetence and arrogance enough? A number of our retired generals seems to agree, who have recently bravely come forward to remind us that Sec. Stimson long ago tried to dismantle key elements of our intelligence services, attempted to curtail the operational command of our Army Air Corps generals in conducting bombings of Europe, and has on more than one occasion intervened to remove targets from Gen. LeMay’s campaign over Japan.

As we see thousands of Americans dying and our enemies still in power after four years of war, it is also legitimate to question the stewardship of Army Chief of Staff Gen. George Marshall. The Sherman tank tragedy, the daylight bombing fiasco, the absence of even minimally suitable anti-tank weapons and torpedoes—all these lapses came on his watch, and the man at the top must take full responsibility for mistakes that have now cost thousands of American lives. Indeed, it is not just that America has worse tanks and guns than our German enemies, but they are inferior even to the rockets and armor of our Soviet allies. The recent publication of “The Sherman Tank Scandal” follows other revelations published in “Asleep at the Philippines,” “The Flight of Gen. MacArthur,” “Gen. Patton and the Atrocities on Sicily,” “Do Americans Execute POWs?” “Torture on Guadalcanal,” “Incinerating Women and Children?” and “Civilian Massacres in Germany”—publications in their totality that suggest a military out of control as often as it is incompetent.

Such problems start at the top. It is not out of “Roosevelt hating,” but out of the need for truth that requires this paper to remind the American people that Mr. Roosevelt, in whose hands our collective fate lies, has been untruthful to his wife about his liaisons, untruthful to the American people about the extent of his crippling illness, and thus, not surprisingly, untruthful to the United States Congress about the extent of our prewar involvement with the British Empire in its European war and the secret nature of our present commitments.

Recently we have learned that President Roosevelt, the former law school dropout, once again has violated basic freedoms enshrined in our Constitution. Supposed German suspects were subject to military tribunals, tried in secret, and then executed. Tens of thousands of Italians, Germans, and Japanese war captives are detained in hundreds of American prison compounds, without charges and often in secret. How many were truly captured in uniform, and under what conditions, is never disclosed.

Unfortunately this violation of American values comes not in isolation, but on the heels of the unlawful internment of thousands of American citizens in Western concentration camps, the cover-up of the Cobra disaster in Normandy and the criminally negligent killing of General McNair, and still more rumors that hundreds of American soldiers perished in secret in training exercises on the eve of the Normandy invasion. Yet, the American people to this day have no precise idea how many of their enlisted men and officers have been killed, much less where they perished or how.

Indeed, what little we know comes to light only due to the brave efforts of a few unnamed operatives in the Office of Strategic Services who have in secret provided such information concerning patently illegal activities to the responsible news organizations.

Yet even this government’s propaganda efforts ring hallow, as we noticed with the recently released film footage purportedly showing Adolph Hitler incompetently handling a Colt .45 revolver. In fact, such a weapon, little known in Germany, is hard to load and shoot, especially the early model that the Fuhrer was shown trying to fire. To be fair, his apparent unease is not necessarily proof that Mr. Hitler was unfamiliar with firearms, much less fraudulent in his demonstration of military experience.

Remember as well that these clandestine transgressions of this administration follow a long record of constitutional disrespect—whether trying to pack the Supreme Court with compliant justices, unilaterally turning over our destroyers to the United Kingdom, or, well before Pearl Harbor, ordering, by fiat, attacks on the high seas against German submarines. Such abuses of presidential authority, characterized by intrigue with British agents and unauthorized spying on foreign nationals, go a long way in explaining the German decision to declare war against us on December 8, 1941, presenting the United States with the present catastrophe of a two-front conflict.

We can envision that when this lamentable war is over, fought with such malfeasance, the real heroes will not be Gen. Marshall, Secretary Stimson, or yes-men like Gen Eisenhower, but courageous mavericks such as a Charles Lindbergh or Senator Robert Taft, who long ago warned us that we were provoking an unnecessary war, one that, as they feared, was subsequently to be waged barbarically and yet incompetently at the same time.

The final irony is that we may well end up friendlier with our current fascist enemies than with our Communist allies. It is not hard to envision a policy looming on the horizon that soon coddles Hitler’s current friend Gen. Franco, while opposing his dire enemy Joseph Stalin. We have it on good authority that already there are postwar contingency plans to train and reform the Japanese and German militaries to serve as a bulwark against a Communist Soviet Union and a soon to be Communist China, as America readies for yet another war, one that may last not five, but 50 years. How ironic that a struggle that started out in 1939 to ensure a free Eastern Europe and China may well end up, at best, guaranteeing their enslavement to totalitarians every bit as cruel as Hitler and Tojo.

Citizens should not have to look to our actors and intellectuals for answers, but, in the absence of political accountability, they often do. After the release of The True Story of the B-17 Slaughter, Gary Cooper thankfully came forward to remind us how President Roosevelt took us into a British war that we were utterly unprepared for. Next look for Coop’s recently completed and powerful American Gestapo this fall. Likewise, Jimmy Stewart remarked from the front lines above Germany (so unlike our president, who failed to serve in any of America’s past wars) that it is hard to know who the real enemy is after we have bombed the children of Hamburg. And Clark Gable is currently preparing a documentary on the Pacific theater, 12/7, that outlines the racist nature of that campaign that seeks the extermination of all the living Japanese we encounter.

Finally, we welcome the upcoming courageous anthology edited by John Steinbeck, Ernest Hemingway, and William Faulkner, Worse Than Our Enemies?, that charts the near criminal direction of American foreign policy under this administration’s plans of total and endless war, of preparing for a new imperial conflict against the Soviet Union before the current one with Germany and Japan is even over. It is in this context that the venerable John Ford recently resigned from the Navy, and instead will produce a series of films Why We Shouldn’t Fight that will reveal what was really behind this needless campaign of annihilation against the Japanese.

Victor Davis Hanson is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution. He is the author, most recently, of A War Like No Other. How the Athenians and Spartans Fought the Peloponnesian War.


TOPICS: Culture/Society; Editorial; Front Page News; Political Humor/Cartoons; Politics/Elections; War on Terror
KEYWORDS: left; media; mediabias; theleft; vdh; victordavishanson; waronterror; wot; wwii; wwiv
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100 ... 121-129 next last
To: Tolik

Great use of satire by VDH.


61 posted on 05/12/2006 9:47:44 AM PDT by unionblue83
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: 359Henrie
LOL! 8-)

No, but that was a funny reply. He was some young OS - PO2.

62 posted on 05/12/2006 9:50:11 AM PDT by 7thson (I've got a seat at the big conference table! I'm gonna paint my logo on it!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 60 | View Replies]

To: 7thson

OS's, my second guess. Plankowner AD-44


63 posted on 05/12/2006 9:58:07 AM PDT by 359Henrie (We cannot deport 12 million can we? Si, se puede!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 62 | View Replies]

To: Tolik

Another great V.D. Hanson touche!


64 posted on 05/12/2006 10:12:32 AM PDT by Paulus Invictus
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: 7thson
They now have a small sub you can tour as well as the Battleship Missouri on Ford Island. Way, way better than before. Still gives you a chills when they take you out to the Memorial.

Yep, the USS Bowfin...wifey and I were humbled at the hardships those submariners had to endure, given the extremely cramped and claustrophobic quarters.

The Missouri has been added since our last trip, so haven't seen that...for sure will do so, if we ever get back to Hono.

65 posted on 05/12/2006 10:21:14 AM PDT by ErnBatavia (Meep Meep)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | View Replies]

To: Valin

Michelle Malkin does a good job of showing the efforts of the Imperial Japanese to influence and subvert US policy.


66 posted on 05/12/2006 11:09:51 AM PDT by unionblue83
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 37 | View Replies]

To: Valin

Sorry, I meant in her book, "In Defense of Internment:..."


67 posted on 05/12/2006 11:11:04 AM PDT by unionblue83
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 37 | View Replies]

To: billbears
Imagine if Vic got back to his hack treatment of ancient history instead of incessant ramblings on something he has no clue about (of course he's not always that good on the ancient history either). Vic has made it evidently clear his treatment of historical fact outside of ancient history is questionable at best

Can you cite any specifics in the posted article to support this opinion?

68 posted on 05/12/2006 11:16:32 AM PDT by Logophile
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 47 | View Replies]

To: 359Henrie
Plankowner ACSC Wallops Island, Va

Plankowner CG 65

69 posted on 05/12/2006 11:19:31 AM PDT by 7thson (I've got a seat at the big conference table! I'm gonna paint my logo on it!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 63 | View Replies]

To: 7thson

Cool. The only time I get underway anymore is a 2 day tuna trip.


70 posted on 05/12/2006 12:21:51 PM PDT by 359Henrie (We cannot deport 12 million can we? Si, se puede!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 69 | View Replies]

To: Jim Noble
You would have to imagine that they did not intern enemy aliens who had managed to attain US nationality.

Which one are you advocating?

A. Rounding up all Muslim U.S. citizens
B. Rounding up U.S. Muslims from certain countries (Saudi, Egypt, etc.)
C. None of the above, just spouting off.

If the answer is A or B, what benefit do you expect that to provide us, and why haven't these dangerous populations struck here on our soil anytime in the 4 and a half years since 9/11? Please also discuss why, if it's such a grand idea, FDR didn't do it to the Germans and Italians, and why we didn't have numerous sabotage incidents committed by Germans and Italians left running loose.

You would have to imagine that instead of celebrating the Carson Robinson Orchestra's version of "We're Gonna Have to Slap the Dirty Little Jap" that President Roosevelt had them arrested for hate speech.

Please cite any person who has been arrested or censored by the administration for criticizing Islam or advocating any particular war strategy.

71 posted on 05/12/2006 12:44:44 PM PDT by Mr. Silverback (TRY JESUS. If you don't like Him, the devil will always take you back.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 26 | View Replies]

To: OXENinFLA

bttt


72 posted on 05/12/2006 12:46:28 PM PDT by Mo1 (DEMOCRATS: A CULTURE OF TREASON)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 20 | View Replies]

To: billbears

Why don't you be more specific? Where does Hanson make a mistake here about WWII? Where does he unfairly criticize war critic's treatment of current ops?


73 posted on 05/12/2006 12:48:26 PM PDT by Mr. Silverback (TRY JESUS. If you don't like Him, the devil will always take you back.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 47 | View Replies]

To: Tolik

Brilliant writing. It rings of a contemporary CNN or MSNBC (or you fill in the letters) nightly news cast!


74 posted on 05/12/2006 12:53:25 PM PDT by Minutemen ("It's a Religion of Peace")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: melancton
But what he says gets the patriotic juices flowing, so it doesn't matter what the facts are.

Welcome to FR. Please see my post 73 and respond to it.

75 posted on 05/12/2006 12:54:54 PM PDT by Mr. Silverback (TRY JESUS. If you don't like Him, the devil will always take you back.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 52 | View Replies]

To: Valin
And so did the British. The book Desperate Deception outlines how British MI5 agents infiltrated both Harris and Gallup polling organizations and jimmied the polls to make it look like there was more support for war than really existed.

In Patriot's History of the U.S. we give FDR fairly high marks for going as far as he could to prepare the U.S. for an inevitable war, while at the same time resisting British incursions such as this one. I think 1940-1942 was FDR's "greatest hour," and that certainly the man had fallen off dramatically by late 1944.

76 posted on 05/12/2006 12:56:04 PM PDT by LS
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 37 | View Replies]

To: cgbg

The only good murtha is a defeated and shamed murtha


77 posted on 05/12/2006 12:56:16 PM PDT by bert (K.E. N.P. Slay Pinch)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: billbears

I'm a modern U.S. historian, and I find his treatment of modern history pretty damn accurate---much better than yahoo Freeper neoConfederates who think that only happy slaves existed in the South. If only all historians were as accurate in dealing with war issues as Hanson.


78 posted on 05/12/2006 12:57:26 PM PDT by LS
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 47 | View Replies]

To: billbears

IMHO, it is necessary to quell dissent in all wars. It is the nature of war, and survival. If you don't like surviving, move.


79 posted on 05/12/2006 12:58:16 PM PDT by LS
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 53 | View Replies]

To: ErnBatavia
Yep, the USS Bowfin...wifey and I were humbled at the hardships those submariners had to endure, given the extremely cramped and claustrophobic quarters.

A Pearl Harbor survivor who was in subs the whole war once told me he appreciated my service. It's not like I expected the guy to tell me to get bent or something, you understand, but for a moment I was stunned speechless in humility that this man would consider my four years of turning wrenches in SAC to be worth his commendation. One of the great moments of my life.

80 posted on 05/12/2006 12:58:27 PM PDT by Mr. Silverback (TRY JESUS. If you don't like Him, the devil will always take you back.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 65 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100 ... 121-129 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson