[shuckmaster]

Evolution has NEVER been reproduced,

What a crock. Living individuals reproduce every day and living populations are in a constant state of evolution.

[PatrickHenry]

What a crock.

He's moving the goalposts quite a ways. He wants us to start out in a lab with an amoeba, and then reproduce an exact copy of the entire ecosystem of the planet. And if we do, he'll say it's evidence of ID. He'll also tell us to get our own dirt (big creationist punchline). If you let these people decide what science is and how it should be done we'll be back in the caves in no time.

[LiteKeeper]

:-) Nice try - but that is NOT what is generally referred to when talking about evolution. Even variation within a species is not what is referred to as evolution...even creationists believe in Natural Selection - it is integral to speciation (variation within a species, but not the evolution of new species).

The debate about evolution refers to the rise of new species due to mutations...it refers to the rise of species all from a common ancestor. And that has never been demonstrated in the Lab, nor in Nature.