Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Iraq course bound to end badly
Chicago Sun-Times ^ | Aug 21 05 | Andrew Greeley

Posted on 08/22/2005 11:27:24 AM PDT by churchillbuff

What does "stay the course" mean? At one time it meant "regime change." Then it came to mean "weapons of mass destruction," then it meant "war on terror." Now apparently it means an Iraq that is "democratic and free." ...that is nonsense. How many Arab countries are currently both free and democratic -- from Mauritania to Saudi Arabia? Not a one. Does that not suggest that it would be impossible for the United States to impose on Arab culture what we mean by freedom and democracy? In fact, how many Muslim countries can boast of Western-style civil society and democracy? Turkey, maybe, at least up to a point. Iran? Pakistan? Bangladesh? Indonesia? Does that suggest that in its present form Islamic culture is not conducive to what we mean by democracy? ...[snip]

In Iraq ...the Shiite majority is struggling to create an Islamic republic on the Iranian model, more moderate, perhaps, but still a theocratic state in which the mullahs have supreme power -- and women have almost no rights at all. Indeed "staying the course" seems to mean fighting Iran's war against Iraq with Chinese money (which pays for the part of the national debt the war is piling up through the purchase of American treasury notes).

I do not deny that there are elements in the Islamic heritage that are compatible with a civil and democratic society. I insist, however, that these elements do not dominate today in any Islamic country, again with the partial exception of Turkey. But President Bush is nonetheless going to create by sheer willpower and the blood of American troops such a society in Iraq?

....Most Americans believe that real democracy is something like our own. They believe that the president is promising that in Iraq. It is a foolish, ignorant, stupid promise.

Democracy does not mean merely that the majority of voters elect their rulers. It also means the rights of the minority are protected. It means freedom of the press, freedom of expression, freedom of religion, the right to seek redress of grievance, an impartial and independent judiciary, it means no street violence after an election, the right to presumed innocence and to appeal court decisions, respect for those who are different from you, protection of property and contracts, a stable and generally accepted civic culture, civilian control of the military and the police -- all the precious and priceless freedoms and rights which we Americans take for granted -- however imperfectly they may be protected or honored.

Majority rule, without these kinds of safeguards, turns into tyranny, total power invested in the monarch or the general or the cleric or the caudillo or maximum leader or whoever else claims at gunpoint to embody the will of the people. No matter how long Bush "stays the course" in Iraq, the history of that part of the world suggests that the end result of our "regime change" will be something like that. For this, American blood is being spilled?

Western democracy, far from perfect, is still the best there is. One may call what goes on in Cuba or Russia or China or Egypt or Algeria or Pakistan or Indonesia democracy not in the Western style, if one wishes. But the president should not deceive the American people. What will happen in Iraq will be very much like what existed before Saddam came to power and eventually lead, in the name of the will of the people, to another tyrant who will rule with an automatic weapon in his hand.


TOPICS: Editorial; Foreign Affairs
KEYWORDS: andrewgreeley; chamberlainbuff; failure; forthechildren; getlostneville; goawayneville; handwringers; idiot; iraq; itsover; justgiveup; letsbefrench; letsquit; moron; neville; ouisurrender; quit; skyisfalling; takeahikeneville; wardchurchillbuff; welost; woeisus
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-80 next last
To: Catphish

"Walk out of cave and make fire, bound to end badly" - Zog


41 posted on 08/22/2005 11:57:08 AM PDT by massgopguy (massgopguy)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 36 | View Replies]

To: oolatec
When they make Islam their source of laws, all will have been lost.

Depends on how they interpret the Quran. There seems to be some disagreement on that.

42 posted on 08/22/2005 11:58:20 AM PDT by MEGoody (Ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 10 | View Replies]

To: churchillbuff
Who in the h-- are they? Go to any legitimate news source on the planet --

ITM is the most influential blog in Iraq. Their information is often from direct sources. They report directly from TV and paper sources. Two of the founders of ITM even meet President Bush last December. They are a fantastic source of information from Iraq. They often spend time translating news from Arabic; news never seen here.

43 posted on 08/22/2005 11:59:07 AM PDT by liberty2004
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 26 | View Replies]

To: MEGoody
Perhaps, but Bush has said from the beginning that Democracy in Iraq wouldn't look like the U.S., """

Greeley's saying the same thing. He's saying it will look like an old-fashion Middle East dictatorship, with one-party or one-religion rule. Glad I counseled all the young people in my family against enlisting in this war. It wasn't worth the blood of young Americans. Any more than Bill Clinton's wars in Haiti and Somalia were. In 2000 Bush promised no more of that squandering of the lives of US troops for utopian nation-building. I applauded. He should have kept his word.

44 posted on 08/22/2005 11:59:20 AM PDT by churchillbuff
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 40 | View Replies]

To: liberty2004
ITM is the most influential blog in Iraq."""

If it's ignoring facts that all reputable news sources are reporting, it doesn't deserve to be very influential. From what you say about it, it sounds like it cherry picks news and shuts its eyes to the Islamic influence on the new constitution.

45 posted on 08/22/2005 12:00:48 PM PDT by churchillbuff
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 43 | View Replies]

To: G32
Even the most pro-war gung ho type (like me) realizes this was a total waste of effort if they write up a sharia based constitution

Sharia law will NOT be basis of their Constitution. Iraq is 60% women and they will not vote to put themselves under an Iranian style theocracy. Rueters is putting the worse possible spin on this. Remember, this all has to be voted upon by the people. I doubt they will submit to having theocrats ruling their lives.

46 posted on 08/22/2005 12:03:19 PM PDT by liberty2004
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 33 | View Replies]

To: frogjerk

Actually, that part, I think, is a pretty good question. What DOES Stay the course mean? And when do we get "there"? I think the erratic John McCain, in a moment of lucidity, had a pretty good definition. When he can fly into Baghdad International, get off the plane, and drive down the freeways and main streets to the green zone without escorts and without having to worry for his life.

And re that constitution, people forget that half the country is women and they get a vote on it so, while they alone aren't enough to torpedo it if it's too restrictive, they wield considerable political power. And we will be making sure they get to vote.

Unless their men won't let them out of the house, of course.


And in Iran, you can't make the assumption those black-robed mullahs are going to be running things forever. Right now I think you've got a government that's going to make their rule look like a tea party.


47 posted on 08/22/2005 12:04:21 PM PDT by johnb838 (Pray for the Peace of Jerusalem.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: Skooz
Frankly, I don't give a rat's patoot what kind of government they end up with as long as they no longer sponsor terrorism against the West, as Saddam did.

I agree with you, however, we should be very concerned about the possibility of Iraq becoming more or less an extended client state of Iran. Iran is one of the biggest state sponsors of terrorism in the world after all, which I think is why they were included as a member of the Axis of Evil, and rightly so.

If that ends up happening, the situation might well end up being as bad or worse than it was before. An eventual showdown of some kind or another with Iran seems inevitable.

48 posted on 08/22/2005 12:05:05 PM PDT by jpl
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 23 | View Replies]

To: churchillbuff
I tend to think that the only things that will ever work with Muslims go BANG. Democracy is not one of them.

Who knows, maybe the experiment will work.

If not, there's always Plan B

49 posted on 08/22/2005 12:05:06 PM PDT by Bon mots
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: churchillbuff
Democracy does not mean merely that the majority of voters elect their rulers. It also means the rights of the minority are protected. It means freedom of the press, freedom of expression, freedom of religion, the right to seek redress of grievance, an impartial and independent judiciary, it means no street violence after an election, the right to presumed innocence and to appeal court decisions, respect for those who are different from you, protection of property and contracts...

Actually, democracy doesn't mean ANY of that at all, which is why it's a bad system of government. Democracy is mob rule. A constitutional republic is required to protect minority interests.

50 posted on 08/22/2005 12:05:10 PM PDT by Sloth (History's greatest monsters: Hitler, Stalin, Mao & Durbin)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: churchillbuff
BAGHDAD, Aug 22 (Reuters) - A draft constitution for Iraq to be presented to parliament on Monday will make Islam "a main source" for legislation and ban laws that contradict religious teachings, members of the parliamentary drafting panel said.

How many conservatives argue that Christianity is "a source" (which is, as I said, a big improvement over "the source") for our own laws and Constitution. It is to be expected in Iraq that it is simply enshirined in the document.

And there are many other things in the constitution (according to Iraq the model there is a clause about issuing "no laws that are against the values of democracy and human rights" in there as well) we can be proud of and might make our efforts pay off.

The ink isn't even dry and some people are ready to throw up there hands and lock themselves away forever.

51 posted on 08/22/2005 12:07:50 PM PDT by Catphish
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 38 | View Replies]

To: churchillbuff
From what you say about it, it sounds like it cherry picks news and shuts its eyes to the Islamic influence on the new constitution.

I understand your concern. Believe me, I sometimes fear the worse will happen. ITM is quite balanced. They do present news that at first glance would be disheartening. The often mention the negative pressures of Islamic clerics. I have been reading ITM for over a year and I must say, they really have been provided a perspective that is positive and good. I am certain that a majority of Iraqis will NOT vote themselves into a theocracy. If you can spend time reading ITM, it will help provide another perspective.

52 posted on 08/22/2005 12:08:41 PM PDT by liberty2004
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 45 | View Replies]

To: churchillbuff

You focus on Islam as the bad influence over there, as I have often done, but it now seems to me that Islam is NOT the sole or even necessarily the primary determinent of Middle Eastern culture. It seems to me that Islam is to Iraq as Catholicism is to the Mafia, i.e., a thin veneer over a society that operates according to ancient, unredeemed tribal rules of honor, revenge, ehnic chauvinism, bribery, extortion, theft, murder, rape, and general thuggery. I'd like to tell one Iraqi - especially a militant - face to face: "You're no more a Muslim than I am; you're a self-worshipping, blasphemous, idolatrous sack of sh*t. You're nothing more than a common criminal."


53 posted on 08/22/2005 12:09:21 PM PDT by Steve_Seattle
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: churchillbuff
It means we don't cut and run.

What did it get us in Viet Nam?

What did it get us from Lebanon?

What did it get us from Somalia?

A reputation for being unable to muster the courage and determination to defeat the enemy.

NO THANK YOU, NOT IN MY NAME

54 posted on 08/22/2005 12:10:37 PM PDT by OldFriend (MERCY TO THE GUILTY IS CRUELTY TO THE INNOCENT ~ Adam Smith)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Steve_Seattle

you make some very good points Steve. I agree, the other factors you mentioned are very influential.


55 posted on 08/22/2005 12:11:41 PM PDT by liberty2004
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 53 | View Replies]

To: Catphish
"A draft constitution for Iraq to be presented to parliament on Monday will make Islam "a main source" for legislation."

The most important word in that sentence is not "Islam" but "main." I may be reading too much into it, but I think if hard-core fundamentalists were dominating the show, that word would not be in there.
56 posted on 08/22/2005 12:13:16 PM PDT by Steve_Seattle
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 51 | View Replies]

To: churchillbuff

Arabs!?

I am not surprised!


57 posted on 08/22/2005 12:14:12 PM PDT by F14 Pilot (Democracy is a process not a product)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: KevinDavis
Not this sh*t again...

My thoughts, exactly.

58 posted on 08/22/2005 12:14:32 PM PDT by marvlus
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: KevinDavis

Churchillbutt loves this stuff.


59 posted on 08/22/2005 12:20:07 PM PDT by verity (Big Dick Durbin is still a POS)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: verity; All

As all doom and gloomers...


60 posted on 08/22/2005 12:20:49 PM PDT by KevinDavis (the space/future belongs to the eagles --> http://www.cafepress.com/kevinspace1)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 59 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-80 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson