One thing I do agree, there is someone up the ladder who should me be held responsible as well, otherwise it looks as it they are just scapegoats.
Her comander has been removed and her career ruined. Who else do you want to be ruined?
Something else, I have no problems, with torturing the sob's. In fact if it was up to me, I would 'outsource' their care, somewhere like Pakistan or Turkey [smile], where the really know to look after them,[sarcasm] quietly, effectively or else. In fact, I do hope than when I see Bin laden again, will dead... I would hate the idea of just putting him in prion (just like Saddam now), for what?.. they can't even touch them or get the intelligence we need. Ok, enought of this... we maybe have different points of vew. see ya.
BGen Janis Karpinski was a sad excuse for a commander. She should be the one being court martialed for incompetence and dereliction of duty.
The people one rung up the ladder need to be held accountable.
These are the people who should have known what she and her buddies were doing.