Posted on 05/04/2005 11:28:32 AM PDT by pookie18
ANCHORAGE, Alaska Lawyers selected a jury Monday that will decide whether Greenpeace and its contract ship were criminally negligent by failing to have the proper oil spill response paperwork during an anti-logging campaign.
The environmental activist group, the captain of the Arctic Sunrise and the ship's agent all are charged with misdemeanor criminal counts of operating a vessel without a spill contingency plan or proof of financial responsibility in case of a spill, as required by state law.
Opening statements were scheduled Tuesday in state District Court in the southeast Alaska town of Ketchikan. Because the case involves misdemeanor charges, it will be heard by only six jurors and two alternates.
"We feel good about the jury and feel confident they'll listen to all the evidence and render a fair verdict based on the evidence presented in court,'' said Greenpeace attorney Tom Wetterer.
State environmental regulators cited Greenpeace Inc., Arctic Sunrise Capt. Arne Sorensen and ship agent Willem Beekman last July for not filing a spill response plan or having a financial responsibility certificate. According to court documents, the ship was carrying more than 70,000 gallons of "petroleum products'' when it arrived in southeast Alaska for the protest campaign against logging in the Tongass National Forest.
In Alaska, non-tank vessels larger than 400 gross tons must file an oil spill response plan application five days before entering state waters.
The group contends the paperwork oversight was a mishap that was quickly corrected. Those on board didn't know such documents were required, Wetterer said.
"There was no criminal negligence here,'' he said.
Wetterer said the group is being unfairly targeted in retaliation for its anti-logging stance. The defendants contend that many other vessels have entered state waters without the same documents and never faced criminal prosecution.
"At the time of this incident, the ship was insured against oil spills and also had an international oil spill contingency plan in place,'' Wetterer said.
The state didn't pursue criminal charges against the group until the Arctic Sunrise departed from Ketchikan before the paperwork was finalized, despite an agreement to stay anchored, said Assistant Attorney General Jay Fayette.
The criminal negligence charges carry a maximum penalty of a $200,000 fine for an organization and a year in prison and a $10,000 fine for an individual.
The trial is expected to wind up at the end of the week, said Fayette, who on Tuesday plans to call his first witnesses, including a radio reporter who interviewed Sorensen after the Arctic Sunrise left Ketchikan.
Some details also will come from documents such as the ship's itinerary that District Judge Kevin Miller agreed to allow as evidence Tuesday after 90 minutes of "boring and polite legal bantering'' between the two sides, Fayette said.
"My intent is to compress this so we can keep it to this week,'' he said.
ROFL - Ya gotta love it!
I thought maybe they took Ted Kennedy out of his berth for a swim..
Ever meet a Greenpeace babe? They are hairy, smelly, unwashed, unkempt human toxic waste dumps. And crazy to boot.
Maybe they were just planning on using the Dave Matthews method.
Reminds me of the incident some years back where the Sierra Club was found to have been polluting their mountain retreat site for decades with raw sewage...
The story very quickly was buried; like cat doo doo.
Ha-Ha!
You think these guys would have a solar powered ship of something. 70,000 gallons of dastardly oil products! Just think of all the global warming they cause. < / smirk >
Slick
Greenpeace...SAVE THE WHALES! But murdering a baby in the womb is every womans' God given right neigh duty.
These people make me sick.
Ain't karma a bi@#ch? What goes around comes around. I love it when tree huggers step on it!!!!
Some pigs are more equal than others.
The poor Chinook!!!!!!
LOL!!!!
ROTFLMAO
That pic is going to make the rounds here in MA.
This regulation has been around since 1990. Its part of OPA-90, the Oil Pollution Act, enforced by the US Coast Guard. I'll wager the captain has a 500 ton USCG license and had a review of these regs the last time he renewed his ticket.
"Dano, sometimes the irony is overwhelming. Book 'em."
Muleteam1
"But the rules don't apply to us!"
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.