ABC NewsPosted on 04/03/2005 6:56:32 AM PDT by bd476
ABC News
Cardinals attend a Mass for the late Pope John Paul II celebrated by the Vatican secretary of State, Cardinal Angelo Sodano, not seen, on the steps of St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican, Sunday April 3, 2005. (AP Photo/Massimo Sambucetti)
The Associated Press
Apr 3, 2005 — When the cardinals enter their secretive conclave to pick the new pope, the 11 Americans voting will be the second-largest national group behind the Italians. But don't expect an American pope Vatican experts are absolutely convinced it won't happen.
"The economic, political and military power of the United States leads to resentments, and that's part of the human dynamic," George Weigel, John Paul II's biographer, said before the pope's death.
An American would be "virtually impossible," he said.
The Rev. Richard John Neuhaus of First Things magazine agreed. An American pontiff "would give not only the appearance but perhaps the substance of increasing what is perceived by many as the inordinate hegemony of American power."
The Rev. Thomas Reese of America magazine noted that in past centuries "the church always tried to keep (the papacy) out of the hands of the superpower" of the day, whether the Holy Roman Empire, Spain or France. The exception, the 14th century French popes who moved the Holy See to Avignon, proved disastrous.
There are other factors that make Americans unattractive papal candidates.
Popes need to be the masters of many languages but most Americans are fluent only in English, Reese said.
The country's clerical sex abuse scandal also hasn't helped America's reputation within the church and in Rome, and the U.S. church already had a reputation for being troublesome.
Observers also predict the American cardinals won't form any united bloc to work effectively for a particular policy, candidate or region such as neighboring Latin America.
The U.S. cardinals "are not as united as they were 10 or even five years ago," Neuhaus said, and lack the "common mind and approach that has characterized the American cardinals at some points in the past."
They range from staunch conservatives like Francis George of Chicago and James Stafford, head of a Vatican tribunal, to Los Angeles' Roger Mahony and Washington's Theodore McCarrick, regarded as rather more flexible and pragmatic.
The Rev. Thomas Reese of America magazine noted that in past centuries "the church always tried to keep (the papacy) out of the hands of the superpower" of the day .....Yep. They were talking about this on FOX News yesterday.
Looks like the next Pope may be Italian again maybe??
I think I heard that PJP II was the first non-Italian Pope in ~500 years?
Here is Rome's chance to unite Christianity, elect a Lutheran as Pope!
*Sputter*. . .you owe me a new keyboard. Coffee all over the thing.
;-)
Apparently, they don't teach logic in the Jesuit seminaries these days. Or in the journalism schools.
How does the fact that "most Americans are fluent only in English" have any bearing on any one particular individual who would be a candidate to the papacy?
There are many reasons why an American pope is extremely unlikely, but the above is not one of them.
Most of the American Cardinals and Many bishops should be in Prison, never mind being Pope.
"...regarded as rather more flexible and pragmatic."
"Progressive" is out of style right now.
It will be interesting to find out.They are on a strict schedule to pick a replacement, too, I believe.
I think I heard FOX News say something like 2 weeks, or 15 days or thereabouts? Not sure.
"There will be two popes before the end of the world - the first will be Polish the next and the last will be Negro [black]."
the other four thing it will be Osama Obama, after all in Illinois he is considered the second coming.
Duh.
I wonder if the Democrats, out of force of habit, will try to filibuster the nomination.
That just wouldn't be right.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.