Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

She is not on life support. Her care is not expensive. Why does her disability deserve a death sentence?

It doesn't.

1 posted on 03/30/2005 10:15:58 PM PST by freespirited
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies ]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021 next last
To: freespirited
"To break the tie, Greer engaged a fifth neurologist, Dr Ronald Cranford. He is well spoken and highly convincing. He is also a spokesman for the right-to-die movement. His testimony tilted the scales."

Bastards!

2 posted on 03/30/2005 10:19:43 PM PST by Jim Robinson
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited
"The American disability lawyer and activist Harriet McBryde Johnson put it clearly: "This belief that withdrawing a feeding tube is different than other killing - why is that a reasonable distinction? I haven't heard anybody say it would be OK to kill Terri Schiavo if she weren't on a feeding tube."

Well put.

This article is a must read.

4 posted on 03/30/2005 10:26:06 PM PST by Miss Behave (Beloved daughter of Miss Creant, super sister of danged Miss Ology, and proud mother of Miss Hap.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited

Oh, so this is how it happened. I'm very disturbed by the fact that known euthanasia advocates were able to sway the decision but I see what happened now.

Couple this with the terrible mistake their lawyer made when the case went federal (choosing to argue about Greer instead of taking the chance to start over anew with new judges), and the mistakes are heartbreaking.

But they didn't have the money Michael had. Nor does it seem they had any clue all of this was going to happen until after Michael got the money and changed his tune. I can't judge them, I don't know how well-educated and capable I would have been in a similar situation.

I do know that watching your daughter starve to death, a daughter who is still responsive with you and who can obviously still feel the pain of her forced death, must be torment.


10 posted on 03/30/2005 10:57:25 PM PST by DameAutour
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited
"This belief that withdrawing a feeding tube is different than other killing - why is that a reasonable distinction? I haven't heard anybody say it would be OK to kill Terri Schiavo if she weren't on a feeding tube."

Good point. It is not a "reasonable distinction". It's most certainly, NOT "ok". It may be legal (in Florida anyway) but that doesn't make it right.

...Continued prayers for Terri...

11 posted on 03/30/2005 10:58:42 PM PST by blinachka (Vechnaya Pamyat Daddy... xoxo)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited
...a 41-year-old brain-damaged Florida woman is slowly dying at her husband's request.

"Request?"

Technically, maybe.



In the real world, NO.

18 posted on 03/30/2005 11:18:39 PM PST by Petronski (The last lonely man in the deep woods.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited
Why the pro-life lobby lost a do-or-die battle

Because even the President and his brother read the Polls.

21 posted on 03/30/2005 11:21:18 PM PST by KDD (just the facts please)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited

"... all Experience hath shown that Mankind are more disposed to suffer, while Evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the Forms to which they are accustomed."


28 posted on 03/30/2005 11:28:50 PM PST by atomic_dog
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited
The fundamental problem with the case mounted by the Schindler family is that they depicted Schiavo's plight as a religious issue.

Perhaps they should have relied more on Thomas Jefferson and personal rights.

31 posted on 03/30/2005 11:30:38 PM PST by Pan_Yans Wife (" It is not true that life is one damn thing after another-it's one damn thing over and over." ESV)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited; MeekOneGOP; PhilDragoo; potlatch; Happy2BMe; ntnychik; Smartass; FairOpinion


Personal Injury - Disabled - Hospice Care - Accidents
Medical MacPractice - Wills - Trusts - Whack & Fall
Mediscare - Criminal Defense - Tax Shelters
Spontaneous Comas - Estate Scamming



FELON & FELON - LLC

DO YOU HUNGER FOR INNER PEACE?

35 posted on 03/30/2005 11:36:01 PM PST by devolve (WWII : http://pro.lookingat.us/RealHeros.html James Bond - 007 : http://pro.lookingat.us/007.5.html)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited
"Why the pro-life lobby lost a do-or-die battle"

It should read Why America lost a do-or-die battle.

The reason is that America relegated it's faith to small buildings, one day a week. America expelled God from the public venue. America slept while the amoral Hippies grew-up and took over the country. America permitted abortion on demand. America is embracing and normalizing homosexuality. Now, America is allowing the life of an innocent woman to be reduced to arguments over legal procedures and the correctness of court filings.

I came from an America that that would have stood up and said: To hell with your procedures and your lousy paperwork! We're talking about an innocent woman's life here.

Now, America cringes in fear before the likes of George Felos, the Shiva-worshipping Hindu lawyer for the adulterer-husband of Terri, Micheal Schiavo, and that black-robed Mullah, George Greer.

That Cabal has effectively established that elected officials and representatives do not run the country. An elitist oligarchy has seized control; the "rule of law" has become whatever they decide "the law" is, on any given day; and now they determine who the "usless eaters" are, as well as how they should be disposed of.

While America neglected it's responsibilities and obligations to God, the Creator of the Universe has been preparing His judgment upon this nation of sleepers. It is only because of his mercy and grace, that swift and sure destruction has not already befallen America.

But it is coming, just as sure as it came upon Israel. "And it shall come to pass in that day, that every place shall be, where there were a thousand vines at a thousand silverlings, it shall even be for briers and thorns. With arrows and with bows shall men come thither; because all the land shall become briers and thorns. And on all hills that shall be digged with the mattock, there shall not come thither the fear of briers and thorns: but it shall be for the sending forth of oxen, and for the treading of lesser cattle." (Isa 7:23-25)

One of the Founders (whose name escapes me at the moment) remarked to the effect that he feared for our nation, when he considered that God is just. I echo those sentiments because His Grace & Mercy will not restrain His Justice forever.

Forgive us, Almighty God, for our sins of omission. Save Terri's life through your Mighty Power, to your glory. Save her, and have mercy upon us.

40 posted on 03/31/2005 12:06:21 AM PST by Washington_minuteman (Visiting Constitutionalist)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited

Unfortunately, I believe the options in the Courts have run their course, and due to incompetent counsel, they were waged on the wrong issues and were lost before they even got off the ground.

One of the disturbing things to me is that the Schindlers have had lousy lawyering from the start. They were manipulated and mislead by groups with political agendas of their own.

They should have retained a top flight Constitutional lawyer like Alan Dershowitz or Davis Boise who have expressed great sympathy and understanding of Terri's plight, instead of a using emotional, inexperienced, political idealogues

IMO the special interest groups with their own agenda
(even though I might agree with parts of that agenda) have hijacked Terri's interest and given her representation by an idealogue instead of a top Constitutional lawyer and that doomed Terri.

I also believe that these idealogues would have never ceded the spotlight to Dershowitz, Boise, or Ted Olson, even though they are the only kind of lawyers who would have had a ghost of a chance to save Terri.


41 posted on 03/31/2005 12:07:42 AM PST by PJBlogger (BEWARE :: HILLARY and her HINO want to take back YOUR COUNTRY !)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited

A well-written article overall. I agre with the author's basic premise. The Schindlers' lawyers really bungled the case badly, from most of what I've read. They also expressed their sympathetic understanding of Michael Schiavo's adulterous co-habitation with a girlfriend, which may have resulted in his getting away with flaunting a Florida statute against adultery.

Of course, Greer's conflict of interest (campaign contributions from Felos) should have come into play, as well as Felos' logtime activism with the Hemlock Society, et al. What a mess.


42 posted on 03/31/2005 12:35:16 AM PST by Bogolyubski
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited

I agree that the Schindlers were out-maneuvred! They should have gone to real well-known pro-life groups, instead of what appears to be a lame-duck one and gotten real help. There's plenty of groups out there to help and would've jumped at the chance. The lawyer they were given didn't see what hit them...and I still think hasn't figured it out.


43 posted on 03/31/2005 12:35:30 AM PST by Shery (S. H. in APOland)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited; Jim Robinson; Dolphy; All
Starving a living, breathing creature, to death, is cruel and inhumane. There are *no* BUTS or overriding factors about it.

Take away guardianship.
Take away stated or otherwise wishes.
Take away brain condition.
Take away doctors' evaluations and labels.
Take away hospital/hospice care received.
Take away family dynamics.
Take away politics.
Take away law, lawyering, and judges' rulings.
Take away any and all debate.

An innocent, defenseless, living, breathing human being is purposefully being starved to death. They are not pulling any true life support *plug.*

Any member of a decent society rightly considers death by starvation to be cruel and inhumane. There is simply no way around that very base, simple, naked statement.

And further, Michael's words on Terri's true wishes (not stated until seven years after her collapse and the monies banked,) have been fogged and contradicted by himself on national TV. Terri's body was not shutting down already on its own. And that Judge Greer's ruling expressly included nothing by mouth including ice chips, beyond the removal of the feeding tube, is so very revealing.

In Terri's case, there is a veritable plethora of bright red flags. And because so, I stand with President George W. Bush that we must *err* on the side of life.

And fellow FReeper Dolphy wrote this food for thought, (which I think, is more for those who think that a feeding tube, in reality, constitutes true life support,) on another thread yesterday:

"More specifically, it is about who gets to substitute judgment for the incapacitated or incompetent in the absence of a written directive. In Florida the law says that evidence of ones desire to end life prolonging treatment must be clear and convincing. I agree with that but I remain unconvinced, by the publicly available documents, that Greer met that standard."

53 posted on 03/31/2005 1:26:29 AM PST by Miss Behave (Beloved daughter of Miss Creant, super sister of danged Miss Ology, and proud mother of Miss Hap.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited; Jim Robinson; backhoe; PhiKapMom
Many links have been removed since this superficial search for a connection in the 'players' was done in 2003.  Some were Open Society Institute/PDIA 'projects' that have been buried.  The items were left on the list to indicate how they related. The original link info used is still there just in case someone with more proficiency than I has an interest in pursuing.

The original Project on Death in America site was eliminated and PDIA was incorporated into OSI in December 2003, but today the original was accessible again and has a current date of March 31, 2005.

Dr. Peter Bambakidis - 'Independent' doctor appointed by Judge Greer to examine Ms. Schiavo.  

Peter Bambakidis, M.D.   Dr. Bambakidis earned his bachelor's and master's degree in music at the Cleveland Institute of Music.

Dr. Peter Bambakidis testimony that heart attack wasn’t cause for Terri’s collapse

Google-Case Western Reserve University + Peter Bambakidis

Google-Case Western Reserve University + Project on Death in America

Bambakidis Links to Ira R. Byock 

Google-Case Western University + Ira Byock

Google-Hospice of the Western Reserve + Ira Byock

Ira R. Byock - Involved in various Soros groups 

Ira Robert Byock - 1984-2003 University of Montana

Ira Byock, Director, Practical Ethics Center, University of Montana    Note: he is Director of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation National Program. 

Dr. Ira Byock Biographical Info

Byock Missoula Quality of Life Index (MVQOLI)

**For further information contact: 

Susan Bruno
Director of Institute Outreach
The Hospice of the Florida Suncoast

Byock Links to George J. Felos

George Felos / Partnership for Caring        Not Dead Yet info    Robert Wood Johnson Connection

The spirit and the law

George J. Felos - Attorney for Michael R. Schiavo.  Numerous connections to Soros related groups.  Student of Byock.  

George J. Felos       Profile from book publisher - Note: Board Chair of Hospice of the Florida Suncoast 

Hospice is for Caring ... or is it for Killing?      Felos Student of Byock

THE RIGHT TO LIVE OR DIE         PBS    

 Both sides in Schiavo fight point to control of money  

Byock links to Mary J. Labyak

Dying Well

Public Policy Florida Hospice  7- 22 C  Byock/Labyak AARP interview on Hospice. Link to 6/98 AARP Bulletin not available    

National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization     NHPCO    Pre Conference Institutes September 5 and 6, 2003  Mary Labyak/Ira Byock Speakers

NHPCO / Project on Death in America      Schedule of conferences on Project on Death in America site

Project on Death in America 

New at Project on Death In America - Current as of March 31, 2005

Mary J. Labyak - CEO Hospice of the Florida Suncoast.  Numerous connections to Soros related groups.  Links to Mary Labyak:  

Mary J. Labyak   CEO Letter Hospice Florida Suncoast

Rallying Points - A Last Acts Initiative

BOARD OF DIRECTORS  PARTNERSHIP FOR CARING:AMERICA'S VOICES FOR THE DYING

PARTNERSHIP FOR CARING: AMERICA'S VOICES FOR THE DYING

Hospice donations diverted, suit says

     
George Soros - Through foundations, institutes and projects all the above link to Soros

Project on Death in America   Reflections On Death In America A speech given by George Soros on November 30, 1994 for the Alexander Ming Fisher Lecture Series at Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center 

The death related institutes and projects are infinite.

60 posted on 03/31/2005 5:39:37 AM PST by windchime (Hillary: "I've always been a preying person")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited

The Schindlers made the same mistakes as your average Conservatives always do. They did not realize they were up against far more than they knew. The Doctors, Hospitals, Insurance Companies, Social Security all have an interest in seeing Mrs. Schiavo die, not to mention a the inconvenience to her husband.

Not once can I recall a party directly related to the Schindler do any PR about the far broader issues of how this can effect everyone else. Not once. It was all centered on only Mrs. Schiavo herself. What was needed instead here was a PR campaign to be run concurrently with the case(I remember a small hysteria about euthanasia when I was a kid in Catholic school and being told it was sinful), spelling out the details of what kind of precedent this sets, how it will effect people of all stripes, how Mrs. Schiavo was neglected by her husband and not allowed every chance of recovery etc.

As a result of this case I am now for changing the filibuster rule, and whatever else it takes to reign in these Courts/Secularists. We are in trouble in this country, and I don't think we are going to get out of it peacefully.


71 posted on 03/31/2005 6:27:32 AM PST by dg62
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited
Goes to show you that the pro-euthanasia folks have been planning this a long time and had all their duckies in a row. They came down on the Schindlers like a ton of bricks and the poor family didn't know what hit them. They only wanted their daughter and sister with them, and weren't prepared for the manipulation of Felos.

They were out-lawyered from the start, and the judicial decisions based on that were what was upheld from then on.

78 posted on 03/31/2005 6:40:27 AM PST by SuziQ
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: All
I'm listening right now to the broadcast of Hannity's radio show (we get in on taped delay in Chicago, on the VERY popular WLS Radio, and Sean is talking with Ollie North, and Ollie is SO interesting and rational, and is stating the *big* picture, and humanitarian principles, in a way that only Ollie can.

Ollie is just GREAT right now with what he's saying.

105 posted on 03/31/2005 4:49:56 PM PST by Miss Behave (Beloved daughter of Miss Creant, super sister of danged Miss Ology, and proud mother of Miss Hap.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: ALOHA RONNIE
Wise words from Jim Robinson: "The fundamental problem with the case mounted by the Schindler family is that they depicted Schiavo's plight as a religious issue."

"In fact, it is a human rights issue. Schiavo is not in pain and is not dying. She is not on life support. Her care is not expensive. Why does her disability deserve a death sentence? "

- Jim Robinson

The parents may have seen this as a religious issue, but when you deal with the courts, you need to find another angle. This reality makes legal battles very difficult for truly devout people.

It's best to find an attorney who respects your position but will work hard to present another argument to the court.

Sad, but true. Religious arguments fall on deaf ears.

132 posted on 04/02/2005 1:44:36 PM PST by reformjoy (Hillary -- Botoxed all to Hell)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]

To: freespirited

The right to life side lost because the game was rigged.


134 posted on 04/02/2005 1:54:01 PM PST by TASMANIANRED (Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their country.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021 next last

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson