If you used a base 12 math system, 5 would STILL go in to 10 twice.
The functions of math don't change with your method of keeping track.
I thought about what you said as well.
1*1=1
3*3=1
5*5=1
7*7=1
Furthermore, if you multiply any two of {1,3,5,7}, you get something in that set. But with this kind of arithmetic, 1 has four square roots.