Posted on 12/20/2004 2:37:02 PM PST by Libloather
U.S. agrees to Nazi "gold train" settlement
By Michael Christie
Tuesday December 21, 2:30 AM
MIAMI (Reuters) - The U.S. government has agreed to settle a lawsuit with tens of thousands of Hungarian Holocaust survivors over a trainload of gold, jewelry and other property seized by the U.S. Army at the end of World War Two, lawyers said on Monday.
The agreement over 24 boxcars filled with $50 million to $200 million worth of art and household goods stolen by the Nazis and then confiscated by the United States still has to be worked out in detail, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, Sam Dubbin, told a court.
Government documents cited by the lawsuit said some of the property was requisitioned by U.S. military officers to furnish homes and offices, sold in army commissaries or kept by military personnel as trinkets.
"This money won't bring back my parents, my loved ones and my sister. I don't care if I get one dollar or $100,000, I just want closure," said Holocaust survivor Jack Rubin from Boynton Beach, Florida.
Rubin, 76, was 15 when the Nazis took him to Auschwitz concentration camp.
He was forced to help load what became known as the "Gold Train" with gold, jewelry, art, clothing, Oriental rugs and other household goods and religious articles.
The train was seized by the U.S. Army in Austria in 1945 and the suit said the army falsely classified it as unidentifiable and enemy property, thus avoiding having to return the goods to their rightful owners.
The suit was brought by Hungarian Jews in Miami, where many of them live.
HOLOCAUST SURVIVORS
But any agreement will also apply to Holocaust survivors in Australia, Israel and elsewhere, Dubbin said. While many owners of the goods died in Nazi concentration camps during the war, he estimated that between 30,000 and 50,000 people could benefit from the deal.
Financial details of what is believed to be the first suit against the United States over property stolen by the Nazis were not made public.
The original class-action suit sought $10,000 in compensation per plaintiff while estimates of the 1945 value of the goods range from $50 million to $200 million. In modern day terms, the treasures could be worth 10 times as much.
Gideon Taylor, executive vice president of the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany, said that for Holocaust survivors, the case was not about money. "It's about restituting history. This is a moral step by the U.S. to acknowledge the past," Taylor said.
The lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in Miami in 2001 on the 56th anniversary of Germany's surrender. It alleged the United States made no effort to return the goods and lied to Hungarian Jews who sought information after the war.
The Justice Department sought to have the case thrown out.
Daniel Meron, principal deputy assistant attorney-general, declined to clarify why the government decided to stop fighting the case except to say the two sides "managed to narrow our differences."
The Justice Department had faced calls from members of Congress from both parties, and newspaper opinion pieces, urging it to settle.
"While nothing can heal the wounds suffered by many of these survivors, I am grateful and relieved that our government is providing long overdue redress to these men and women," said New York Democratic senator Hillary Clinton, one of the lawmakers who pressured the government to settle.
U.S. District Judge Patricia Seitz set a deadline of Feb. 18 for a detailed agreement to be submitted and a follow-up hearing on Feb. 25.
bump
I have no problem in the payout to these people, but considering the investment we made to rebuild Germany after WW2, how about we get some billions back from the country itself as pay back?
I became acquainted with a man who was an inmate at Auschwitz/Birkenau (he said he had been an electrician before he was arrested so the Germans used him all over the camp) in 1944 when the Hungarian Jews were brought in for extermination. He said the transports came in day and night steady for about two weeks and almost everyone was sent directly to the gas chambers. He said the screaming went on incessantly day and night because those people knew what was going to happen to them and the Germans rushed them through with extreme brutality in order to keep them cowed and cooperative.
He said that he and other prisoners had been given the job of picking up the suitcases and bundles left by the people as they were herded off to be killed. He said there were literally mountains of goods piled at the arrival depot and that the Germans who were in charge of gathering these became immensely wealthy by pilfering from "piles" of jewelry and cash that were found in the luggage.
As I remember, the Nazis shipped up over 400,000 people out of Hungary in just three weeks - the one major pocket of undisturbed Jews left in Europe. Using valuable resources in a two-front war. The Nazis' dedication to the process was sickeningly astouding.
As I remember, the Nazis shipped up over 400,000 people out of Hungary in just three weeks - the one major pocket of undisturbed Jews left in Europe. Using valuable resources in a two-front war. The Nazis' dedication to the process was sickeningly astouding.
well, its hard to have an opinion on this without more facts. One thing I do disagree with is the fact that the settlement is a secret. How can what the government does with my money be a secret! (non-national security of course...)
And in the end only the lawyers will profit.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.