Posted on 11/24/2004 7:30:01 PM PST by Exton1
Judge rules Islamic education OK in California classrooms
Dismisses suit opposing requirement students recite Quran, pray to Allah
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted: December 13, 2003
1:00 a.m. Eastern
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© 2003 WorldNetDaily.com
Requiring seventh-grade students to pretend they're Muslims, wear Islamic garb, memorize verses from the Quran, pray to Allah and even to play "jihad games" in California public schools has been legally upheld by a federal judge, who has dismissed a highly publicized lawsuit brought by several Christian students and their parents.
As WND reported in July of last year, the suit was filed by the Thomas More Law Center against the Byron Union School District and various school officials to stop the use of the "Islam simulation" materials and methods used in the Excelsior Elementary School in Byron, Calif.
In her 22-page ruling announced Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Phyllis Hamilton said Excelsior is not indoctrinating students about Islam when it requires them to adopt Muslim names and pray to Allah as part of a history and geography class, but rather is just teaching them about the Muslim religion.
When WorldNetDaily first reported the story in January 2002 – shortly after the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks committed by 19 Islamist terrorists – major controversy ensued nationwide.
The World History and Geography class in question is part of a curriculum being taught to seventh-graders all over the state, and is included in the state's curriculum standards required by the state board of education. Although the standards outline what subjects should be taught and will be included in state assessment tests, they don't mandate how they're to be taught.
In the three-week course, Excelsior teacher Brooke Carlin had students assume Islamic names, recite prayers in class, memorize and recite verses from the Quran, and had them simulate Ramadan fasting by going without something for a day. The final test required students to critique Muslim culture.
The Islam simulations at Excelsior are outlined in the state-adopted textbook "Across the Centuries," published by Houghton Mifflin, which prompts students to imagine they are Islamic soldiers and Muslims on a Mecca pilgrimage. The lawsuit also alleges students were encouraged to use such phrases in their speech as "Allah Akbar," which is Arabic for "God is great," and were required to fast during lunch period to simulate fasting during the Islamic holy month of Ramadan.
Nevertheless, the judge ruled the program was devoid of "any devotional or religious intent," and as therefore educational, not religious in nature.
'Double standard' decried
However, Richard Thompson, chief counsel for Thomas More, points to what he calls an obvious double standard.
"While public schools prohibit Christian students from reading the Bible, praying, displaying the Ten Commandments, and even mentioning the word 'God,' students in California are being indoctrinated into the religion of Islam," he told WND on filing the lawsuit. "Public schools would never tolerate teaching Christianity in this way. Just imagine the ACLU’s outcry if students were told that they had to pray the Lord's Prayer, memorize the Ten Commandments, use such phrases as 'Jesus is the Messiah,' and fast during Lent," he added.
According to Thompson, "Although it is constitutional for public schools to have an instructional program about comparative religion or teach about religion and utilize religious books such as the Bible in courses about our history and culture, the Byron Union School District crossed way over the constitutional line when it coerced impressionable 12-year-olds to engage in particular religious rituals and worship, simulated or not."
However, Byron Superintendent Peggy Green defended the program: "Dressing up in costume, role-playing and simulation games are all used to stimulate class discussion and are common teaching practices used in other subjects as well."
And Excelsior Principal Nancie Castro maintained, "At no point do we teach or endorse religion; we teach about religions' impact from a historical context. ... This is the state-approved curriculum, using state-adopted textbooks and has been part of the instructional program in California for over a decade."
Appealing to the 9th Circuit?
Yesterday, Thompson told WND that his legal team believed from the start that, regardless of who won the first round, this case would go to appeal – and that is exactly where he wants it to go. With some irony, Thompson points out that the appeal would go to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.
"This is the court that said, in the 'Under God' Pledge case, that the mere expression 'One nation under God' [recited in a public school] violates the Constitution," said Thompson. "It will be very interesting to see how they deal with this Byron School District case where students are basically required to become Muslims for three weeks!"
While the Thomas More Law Center is intent on appealing the case, it is awaiting word from the plaintiffs as to their intent.
And if the student actually utters the words "there is no god but Allah and Mohammed is his prophet", it doesn't matter if he was role-playing, the Muslims will count him as officially converted to Islam and apostasy is punishable by death.
Hell in a handbasket. ....full speed.
Muslims ideas on how to spread Islam in public schools - http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1287886/posts
"We have staked the future of all of our political institutions
upon the capacity of mankind for self-government: upon the capacity
of each and all of us to govern ourselves, to control ourselves,
to sustain ourselves according to the Ten Commandments of God."
--- James Madison
This is crap. I'd pull my kid out of that school in a New York minute. Can't pray in school to a Christian God....but it's ok to pray to Allah....
A christian group should use this to immediatly make the same demand.
And if you don't know that you're a red state redneck.
More California bullsqueeze!
Are there any REAL Americans left in that socialist utopia?
What complete swine they are.
The administration of this school, and possibly the entire district, should be taken out like the terrorists they are.
Don't forget U.S. District Judge Phyllis Hamilton
Please CA FALL into the Pacific!
The inmates are obviously running the nuthouse.
Are local tax dollars to be spent on ammunition and explosives for schools or are Californian parents to supply kids their own IED's for show and tell?
We could also make the California teachers go on pilgrimages to Mecca with a brief stop in Fallujah on the way.
There are no words to express my contempt for the leftist radicals that run this place.
Enough is enough. Let's get a California class action suit going, against this school system, and in this judge's court, to teach actual American History, and Creationism. If he rules against the suit, take it to the Federal Supreme Court if necessary. It would be a good idea to engage Jay Secolo as attorney.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.