Posted on 09/27/2004 5:38:26 AM PDT by Behind Liberal Lines
Republican wannabe.
I think it's worth another look. Lots of symbolism and metaphors... Of course the problem with symbols and metaphors is they are not obviously concrete. They can be co-opted to mean just about anything anyone wants which of course is the problem with poetry... or sometimes even "Mission Accomplished" banners. To some the banner praised the hard work of air craft carrier personnel while to others the banner represented well, just about anything Kerry (or Michael Moore, or Dan Rather) happened to be thinking at the moment.
Dylan's answers were always "blowin' in the wind" and it took even him many years to try and understand what he really meant. That's fine, part of the territory with poetry. Likewise, it's part of the process of aging. He was "...much older then but he's younger than that now". As are we all.
Get me a cabin, in Utah.
Marry me a wife, catch rainbow trout.
Have a bunch of kids who call, me, 'pa'.
That must be what it's all about.
- Bob Dylan, "Time Passes Slowly," New Morning (1970)
She inherited a million bucks
and when she died, it came to me
I can't help it if I'm lucky..............
I love Dylan, but let's face it, he probably wants to avoid making comments about how other people look.
Dylan? Ain't he the moron helped to get Hurricane out of jail? Must be a huge dose of white liberal guilt there.
Gee, you'd almost think he was a closet Republican...
I bet a lot of aging hippies are getting deeply depressed even as we speak.Yeah, really. Who'd have ever thought the guy that wrote Mister Tambourine
Man would be like that??? .....
Yeah, I never got it either. It all sounded very pretentious to me.
It's funny that the press hailed Springsteen as the new Dylan, but it wasn't until Bruce shook off the Dylan influence that Bruce became listenable.
Maybe "Born in the U.S.A" is what Bob could have been if he threw off his own pretensions and wrote about what really mattered to him 8-)
The best Dylan song, "Idiot Wind". Check out the live version from the live album "Hard Rain", recorded in '76. My favorite Dylan album. Check out also, "Love and Theft" a recent release..
Dylan's "Positively 4th Street" is an all-time classic. That song reflects a lot fo the sentiment he shows here in this interview -- he wrote it as a "farewell" of sorts to the hippie culture in Manhattan's East Village after he lived near them for long enough to realize that they were the most useless people he had ever met.
You apparantly were correct. Mr. Dylan seems to have been in it for the money (good reason) and not for the philosophical BS that was so prevalent at the time. My friends were so into Dylan and Thoreau and every other type of anti-establishment type, Jerry Rubin, Mao's red book, etc.... I couldn't take it any more! and joined the MARINE CORPS!!!!!!!
White liberal guilt? Wasnt Hurricane innocent?
I used to have a room mate who thought "Blood on the Tracks" was Dylan's best album. I argued for "Desire," and it made for many good-natured debates.
He played "Idiot Wind" over and over. Great song. Great album.
Actually, that song is "Sign on the Window." .....on New Morning.
Bob is no closet Republican. He sang at Clinton's first inauguration, and he supported Al Gore's campaign, calling him his buddy.
But he is a gun owner. Like he said in his film Masked and Anonymous, "I gotta lot of respect for a gun."
Apparently, the pretensions were everyones Else's, not his....
Guilty as sin AND Dylan played pretty loose with the facts in his lyrics.
And don't forget "George Jacvkson"- 2 versions!
But, hey, it was the times and nobody's perfect.
A legend in his own time.
"Positively 4th Street" by Bob Dylan
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.