Posted on 07/17/2004 8:30:40 AM PDT by SheLion
Senate plan ties FDA regulation to eliminating quotas
By NANCY ZUCKERBROD
Associated Press
WASHINGTON - The Senate approved a plan Thursday to put new restrictions on cigarette makers and pay tobacco farmers $12 billion to give up federal quotas propping up their prices.
An unlikely alliance of anti-smoking advocates and tobacco-state senators teamed up to secure the 78-15 vote to combine a 10-year buyout for tobacco growers with new Food and Drug Administration powers.
The measure was added as an amendment to a corporate tax bill and broke weeks of deadlock over how to proceed with negotiations on that bill.
Supporters had worked to get the buyout and new FDA authority to regulate cigarettes attached to the tax bill so talks could begin with the House on a compromise. The FDA would regulate tobacco not as a drug but as an entirely separate product category.
A bill the House passed last month included a smaller $9.6 billion tobacco buyout over five years and no new FDA regulations on manufacturing and marketing cigarettes and other tobacco products.
The Senate would make tobacco companies pay for the buyout through a user fee that could be passed on to smokers. The House would spread the cost of its version to all taxpayers.
"It's now time to end the tobacco program with a fair buyout, not on the backs of taxpayers," said Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn.
As part of an appropriations bill this week, House members also voted to forbid the Agriculture Department from carrying out a buyout financed by general tax revenues, putting the House on record as being on both sides of that issue.
House Majority Leader Tom DeLay, R-Sugar Land, has opposed giving the FDA authority to regulate cigarettes.
Sen. Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., said, "I'm not a great fan of FDA regulation today, but these two issues needed to be married here ... if we're to get either one of them out of the Senate and on the way down the legislative road."
The buyout would pay roughly 400,000 tobacco quota owners most of them in the Carolinas, Kentucky, Tennessee, Virginia and Georgia to give up federal allotments limiting how much they can sell each year. With no quotas to keep prices up, about half of the roughly 100,000 active tobacco growers may give up the crop altogether, said Keith Parrish, executive director of the National Tobacco Growers Association.
Farmers have been clamoring for a buyout in recent years after seeing the volume of leaf they can sell decline as more Americans gave up smoking and cigarette makers turned to cheaper leaf from abroad.
The Senate measure forbids the FDA from banning cigarettes. The agency could restrict but not eliminate addictive nicotine in tobacco products. It also could order the removal of certain ingredients and force cigarette makers to disclose more details about their product ingredients.
"Current law makes sure we know what's in products designed to help people quit smoking, like the patch or Nicorette gum, but not the very products that get people addicted in the first place to cigarettes themselves," said Sen. Mike DeWine, R-Ohio. "Isn't that crazy?"
Marketing terms such as "light" and "ultra-light" would be prohibited unless the FDA approved them. Studies have shown those cigarettes haven't reduced health risks faced by smokers.
The FDA asserted authority over cigarettes in 1996, but the Supreme Court later ruled that only Congress can give the FDA that power.
Philip Morris USA is the only major tobacco company to support FDA regulation of cigarettes. Company executives say it could better communicate with customers about new, safer products in a regulated environment with clear, uniform rules.
The other major companies say the new advertising restrictions would make it harder for them to gain new customers while ensuring that Philip Morris retains its market share.
Worse: cigarettes are to be available by prescription only.
Bump for later............on my way out the door right now.
Done.
Thank you! :)
Notice that my senators voted NO. Yea us.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.