[discostu]

Marino only made it to the big dance once. Superbowl appearances are a rough meassure. When the press decides they're going to say a guy is great they're going to keep saying it over and over until he seriously screws up. Regardless of McNabb's mediocrity the Eagles are a much better team with him than they were without him, in this day after the golden age of QBs it's going to take a lot for the press to stop lionizing a guy that gives good interview (IMHO the real reason they love him so much).

[CyberCowboy777]

Marino is leaps and bounds ahead of McNabb - with one SB granted (I brought up the standard I know)

Stack McNabb against these truly great QBs (SBs, QB Rating, pure numbers)

John Elway
John Unitas
Dan Marino
Steve Young
Brett Favre
Fran Tarkenton
Otto Grahm
Joe Montana
Joe Theisman
Joe Namath