Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

What's Wrong With the Proposals for a New Guestworker Program?
F.A.I.R. Website ^ | 1/4/04 | F.A.I.R.

Posted on 01/08/2004 11:44:50 AM PST by libertylass

What's Wrong With the Proposals for a New Guestworker Program?

Proposals for a massive new "guestworker" program would:

threaten homeland security grant amnesty for law-breakers, a step overwhelmingly opposed by the American public establish a back door immigration program threaten the jobs and wages of American workers. The politicians pushing a guestworker amnesty know that Americans staunchly oppose amnesty, and so they shy away from calling it what it really is, instead cloaking it in terms like "earned legalization" or "normalization of status." They are deliberately misleading the American public.

THEY SAY that the overwhelming majority of people entering the country illegally pose no threat to our country and that if we allow them enter in a lawful manner, we will enhance our homeland security.

THE TRUTH is that there are an estimated 8-11 million illegal aliens in the United States, and it only took 19 to perpetrate the attacks of September 11. Our immigration system has become overburdened and unmanageable due to mass illegal immigration. As a result, there is little reason to feel confident that, absent a massive infusion of new resources, which is highly unlikely given current fiscal realities, anything approaching thorough background checks can be conducted on applicants for a guestworker program. Even without the added burden of an amnesty, people like Sheikh Omar Abdul Rahman, the blind Egyptian cleric who masterminded the first World Trade Center bombing, and Mohammed Atta, the leader of the September 11 attacks, managed to slip through the screening process. There is every reason to believe that adding new responsibilities to an overtaxed system will make us less safe.

No one has yet explained how the millions of applicants would be given security checks or whether that’s even remotely feasible, given an already overburdened immigration enforcement system. Immigration officials would have to deal with hundreds of thousands of more applicants a year, to say nothing of how we would verify eligibility for any of the eight million potential applicants already here illegally, particularly with many of them armed with false identity documents. When the immigration system can’t adequately perform its most essential mission, adding in the responsibility for security checks, tracking, and removal when necessary for millions of participants in a guestworker program will guarantee disaster.

THEY SAY that the legislation is not an amnesty, but that guestworkers who participate in the program will be eligible for permanent resident status.

THE TRUTH is that the proposal would be an amnesty with an “apprenticeship” provision. Illegal aliens who are already in the U.S. would be eligible to apply. Thus, they would be excused for having violated our immigration laws in the first place, and then be rewarded again with permanent residency--thus making the law, in effect, a double amnesty. Calling it something else does not change the reality that this proposal is a massive amnesty program.

THEY SAY the program will help regain control of the borders and stop illegal immigration.

THE TRUTH is that the proposal does nothing to discourage future illegal immigration or enforcement of our immigration laws, ensuring that any guestworker or illegal alien who wants to remain in the U.S. can and will. In fact, about one-third of illegal aliens in the country right now arrived on legal visas and simply never went home. In addition, it does nothing to strengthen border security to ensure that only guestworkers, and not terrorists, are being admitted.

THEY SAY that spouses and children of illegal aliens may also be eligible to participate in the visa program.

THE TRUTH is that this would be an amnesty not only for those who qualify for this “guestworker” program, but a simultaneous amnesty for their dependents, whether or not they are workers. Aside from expanding the amnesty to include non-workers, it also grants a benefit to the dependents of illegal aliens that is not afforded to the families of other guestworkers who never violated the law. Moreover, it undermines the stated – if flawed – purpose of a guestworker program: that foreign workers come temporarily and then return home. Employers would be able to utilize a virtually limitless supply of guestworkers at low wages, while the expense for services like education and health care for dependent family members would have to be picked up by taxpayers.

THEY SAY that an electronic job registry operated through the Department of Labor will allow employers to post jobs and American workers would have the first chance to apply. Moreover, the jobs would have to be offered again at the end of the three-year period, and that workers’ visas would be renewed only if no Americans are willing to take them.

THE TRUTH is that in the estimation of the General Accounting Office and former Labor Secretary Robert Reich, the provisions in existing guestworker programs that are intended to ensure that American workers get first crack at jobs have been a complete failure. Even if the political will existed to prevent employers from bypassing American workers in favor of foreign guestworkers – which there doesn’t – the Labor Department does not have the resources to monitor the hiring process. A federal government that managed to fine a grand total of 13 employers nationwide in 2002 for violating employer sanctions laws cannot be counted on to enforce the provisions of a guestworker program either.

THEY SAY that BSIIA would be a market-driven program that will negate the reasons why employers hire illegal aliens.

THE TRUTH is that under BSIIA, there would not even be a prevailing wage requirement, meaning that employers will be able to offer wages far below what most Americans would be willing to accept, thereby creating an artificial need for guestworkers. In effect, the law would grant legal sanction to employers who want to hire workers at low wages and limited leverage. One of the primary purposes of our immigration laws is to prevent employers from undermining wages and working conditions of American workers.

THEY SAY that the program would prevent abuse of foreign workers by affording them mobility and the ability to file grievances against abusive employers.

THE TRUTH is that the mobility of guestworkers would still be very limited and their ability to change jobs would depend on finding another employer who was willing to go through the procedure of posting a job and wading through the bureaucratic red tape. The primary interest of the workers would be to hold a job for six years in order to qualify for permanent residency. Moreover, at the end of the “apprenticeship” period, when the guestworker would be granted permanent residency and would gain bargaining power, there is no reason to expect that the employer would not seek another guestworker who is willing to work at below-market wages.

THEY SAY that the program would prevent deaths along the border.

THE TRUTH is that U.S. immigration laws are not responsible for the deaths along the border – it is the violation of our immigration laws that is responsible. If there is any culpability on the part of the American government, it is in its failure to deter illegal immigration by aggressively enforcing laws that prohibit illegal aliens from working here or accessing public benefits. Sending a clear signal that illegal entry to the U.S. will not be rewarded would have the desired effect of dissuading people from placing their lives and safety into the hands of unscrupulous smugglers. Besides, when the Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (BICE) adopted a measure that demonstrably cut down the likelihood of border deaths – by repatriating illegal alien crossers who were apprehended in Arizona to border towns in Texas – the open borders lobby protested, charging that the program was unfair to illegal aliens.

THEY SAY the program will provide workers when and while they’re needed.

THE TRUTH is that when the economy takes a downturn, there will be millions of guestworkers in the U.S. without a job, without a home, without health care, and with no intention of returning to their home countries. The guestworkers’ unemployment problems become the public’s burden.

1/04


TOPICS: Constitution/Conservatism; Crime/Corruption; Culture/Society; Mexico; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: aliens; amnesty; guestworker; illegalimmigration
I found this piece more direct in its assessment of how bad this policy would be.

Those who have been to the border trying to stem the tide have seen Bush turn his head over and over again when Americans have begged him to plug the 100's of miles of open gaps. He refused. Right this minute there are hundred trying to sneak over here along with men in black P.J.'s, the Mexican army, and drug runners with armed escorts. The American people do not matter to Bush when it comes to this issue. He is pandering and will lose my vote in 2004.

1 posted on 01/08/2004 11:44:51 AM PST by libertylass
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: All

How come EVERYBODY
is picking on ME?

Or mail checks to
FreeRepublic , LLC
PO BOX 9771
FRESNO, CA 93794

or you can use

PayPal at Jimrob@psnw.com

SUPPORT FREE REPUBLIC

Help Keep "the Duck" out of the White house!

2 posted on 01/08/2004 11:47:44 AM PST by Support Free Republic (Happy New Year)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: libertylass
THEY SAY any illegal immigrant found in the US who has not applied for the guest worker visa would be deported on the spot, chop chop.

THEY are the same folks who told us we need a guest worker program 'cause deporting border jumpers just isn't a realistic option.

3 posted on 01/08/2004 11:53:26 AM PST by skeeter (Fac ut vivas)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: libertylass; admin
this is re-post of article posting yesterday.
4 posted on 01/08/2004 12:18:57 PM PST by WOSG (Freedom, Baby! Yeah!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: libertylass
<< The American people do not matter to Bush when it comes to this issue. He is pandering and will lose my vote in 2004. >>

Amen.

And mine, too.

He and his administration are either with US or they are of the enemy -- his choice.
5 posted on 01/08/2004 12:19:58 PM PST by Brian Allen ( Rebellion to tyrants is obedience to God - Thomas Jefferson)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: libertylass
Those who have been to the border trying to stem the tide have seen Bush turn his head over and over again when Americans have begged him to plug the 100's of miles of open gaps.

Word is out that the border patrol is outraged at this proposal. It's almost like they're busting their tails for nothing. Sounds similar to the Vietnam War to me where the government is fighting a war it has no intention of winning and is even undercutting its own troops.

6 posted on 01/08/2004 12:24:27 PM PST by Reaganwuzthebest
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Brian Allen
"There is nothing as permanent as a temporary guest worker." ~~German saying.
7 posted on 01/08/2004 12:36:26 PM PST by Travis McGee (----- www.EnemiesForeignAndDomestic.com -----)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: libertylass
UNTIL WE SECURE OUR NATION'S BORDERS...WE'LL NEVER HAVE "NATIONAL SECURITY"!! PERIOD!!
8 posted on 01/08/2004 12:46:27 PM PST by theyibby
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Brian Allen
"War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The person who has nothing for which he is willing to fight, nothing which is more important than his own personal safety, is a miserable creature and has no chance of being free unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself."


-- John Stuart Mill
9 posted on 01/08/2004 12:48:44 PM PST by Diva Betsy Ross ("were it not for the brave , there would be no land of the free")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: libertylass
the provisions in existing guestworker programs that are intended to ensure that American workers get first crack at jobs" have been a complete failure. Even if the political will existed to prevent employers from bypassing American workers in favor of foreign guestworkers – which there doesn’t – the Labor Department does not have the resources to monitor the hiring process.

Well, according to the info posted Tuesday on the White House site, the hiring process "to ensure that American workers get first crack at jobs" will be bypassed for those millions of jobs now held by illegal workers (translation: a complete pass for employers who currently employ illegals):

From "Background Briefing by Conference Call on Immigration Policy" :

Q So an employer won't have to fear that they'll also have to step forward and show that their worker is undocumented. Will they have to register that undocumented worker? Is that the idea?

SENIOR ADMINISTRATION OFFICIAL: The employer will sponsor the undocumented worker, yes. But if you're asking the question as to whether the person needs to say, okay, well, here's Mary, and she's in this spot, do we need to hold on Mary and look for some American to fill that position, the answer is, no. We assume that by virtue of Mary's employment, that marketplace test, if you will, has already been met.

A "marketplace test" based on breaking the existing law.

10 posted on 01/08/2004 1:06:24 PM PST by browardchad
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: theyibby
UNTIL WE SECURE OUR NATION'S BORDERS...WE'LL NEVER HAVE "NATIONAL SECURITY"!! PERIOD!!

Just heard about this website on Sean Hannity's show: SecureBorders.com

The Defense of the Nation begins with the Defense of its Borders.

11 posted on 01/08/2004 1:21:17 PM PST by Lady Eileen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: libertylass
Yes I agree this in way make our nation safer.

And where will the resouces come from to "check" thess 8 million applicants?

They will not apply but are now aware that its OK to come in illagaly because a politicin pandering for votes will aooffer sanctuary/amnesty/OKIE DOKIE status at some point.

And everyone is only discusing this in terms of Latinos.

Is this program available to Arabs as well?
12 posted on 01/08/2004 3:41:21 PM PST by Kay Soze (W is embracing and adding to LBJ's Great Society Program.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Lady Eileen
Thanks for posting that site... never seen it before.
13 posted on 01/08/2004 3:50:25 PM PST by Reaganwuzthebest
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: Reaganwuzthebest
Your welcome.
14 posted on 01/08/2004 5:14:08 PM PST by Lady Eileen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: No More Gore Anymore
Brian Allen
Since Sep 24, 1999

SUPPORT FREE REPUBLIC!
A DOLLAR A DAY'LL KEEP LIBERALS AT BAY!


Brian Allen -- AKA: "brallen" -- [June 26 1998]

"I have sworn upon the altar of God eternal hostility against every form of tyranny over the mind of man."

-- Thomas Jefferson, 1800

Me too! Upon the Exact same altar!

-- Brian Allen, 1997

"Against the insidious wiles of foreign influence the jealousy of a free people ought to be constantly awake, since history and experience prove that foreign influence is one of the most baneful foes of republican government."

-- George Washington, 1793

"[Being American] is a question of principles, of idealism, of character: it is not a matter of birthplace or creed or line of descent."

-- Theodore Roosevelt

"Tis the business of little minds to shrink; but he whose heart is firm, and whose conscience approves his conduct, will pursue his principles unto death."

--Thomas Paine

"I believe that liberty is the only genuinely valuable thing that men have invented, at least in the field of government, in a thousand years.

"I believe that it is better to be free than to be not free, even when the former is dangerous and the latter safe.

"I believe that the finest qualities of man can flourish only in free air -- that progress made under the shadow of the policeman's club is false progress and of no permanent value.

"I believe that any man who takes the liberty of another into his keeping is bound to become a tyrant, and that any man who yields up his liberty, in however slight the measure, is bound to become a slave."

-- H.L. Mencken

War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The person who has nothing for which he is willing to fight, nothing which is more important than his own personal safety, is a miserable creature and has no chance of being free unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself."

-- John Stuart Mill

"O! Ye that love mankind! Ye that dare oppose, not only the tyranny, but the tyrant, stand forth!"

-- Thomas Paine

"The constitutions of most of our States assert that all power is inherent in the people; ...that it is their right and duty to be at all times armed."

-- Thomas Jefferson

"Single acts of tyranny may be ascribed to the accidental opinion of a day; but a series of oppressions, begun at a distinguished period, and pursued unalterably through every change of ministers, too plainly prove a deliberate systematical job of reducing us to slaves."

-- Thomas Jefferson

"A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largesse from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidates promising the most benefits from the public treasury with the result that a democracy always collapses over loose fiscal policy, followed always by a dictatorship. The average age of the world's greatest civilizations has been 200 years."

--Alexander Fraser Tytler

"All men would necessarily be equal if they were free from needs. It is want that subjects one man to another - not that inequality is in itself an evil, but dependency is. It does not matter if someone is called Your Highness and someone else His Holiness, but it is grievous to slave for the one or the other."

--Francois Marie Arouet Voltaire

"The strongest reason for the people to retain the right to bear arms is, as a last resort, to protect themselves against tyranny in government."

-- Thomas Jefferson

"... it is a common observation here that our cause is the cause of all mankind, and that we are fighting for their liberty in defending our own.."

--Benjamin Franklin

"The only thing new in this world is the history you do not know." "

-- Brother Harry S Truman

"As for what is not true, you will always find abundance in the newspapers."

-- Thomas Jefferson
15 posted on 01/08/2004 9:28:03 PM PST by Brian Allen ( Rebellion to tyrants is obedience to God - Thomas Jefferson)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson