[Scott from the Left Coast]

Not very descriptive (my previous). But I've been partying all day with my neighbors (who saw it with us) -- so I'm not my most eloquent.

Things I liked: Damn near everything.

Little tiny things I didn't like:

Legolas snowboarding down the steps

The Arwen interludes (but my wife, not a reader of the books felt that those interludes did show that Aragorn was not tempted by Eowyn and was still totally faithful to Arwen -- so I can see, by that, the point).

The Galadriel narration

The change of the end of the battle of Helm's Deep

and not too much else (gotta run again, more later).

[Scott from the Left Coast]

Oh...and another thing...I thought PJ absolutely CAPTURED Smeagol. OK, a couple of the looks on the face were a bit over the top...but that was DAMN masterful. The arguing with himself was PERFECT!!!! (more later, I'm entertaining...)

[RMDupree]

Never mind my earlier post! :)

Thanks for your take on TTT.