Posted on 11/16/2026 7:00:37 AM PST by Miami Rebel
Weeks after voters lashed out at data centers in the midterms, Congress is debating a sweeping overhaul of federal permitting rules that could help tech companies more quickly build the facilities.
The bill would speed up federal environmental reviews of a variety of energy projects, including transmission lines and gas pipelines, making it easier for developers to get the power they need to run data centers. Historically, utilities have spread the cost of electrical grid upgrades among all their customers. But as anger over data centers has swelled. Most A.I. companies have promised to do so, although these so-called ratepayer protection pledges can be difficult to enforce.
But that help comes with a huge catch: Data centers would also have to pay much more for their electricity under a provision in the bill that would charge the facilities extra for access to the electric grid. That measure would upend decades of federal power rules and potentially save billions of dollars over the next decade for households and other ratepayers.
The push to impose higher costs on data centers underscores how thorny the politics around A.I. have become in Washington. Massive, energy-hungry data centers are spreading rapidly across the country, straining electrical networks and triggering anger in many communities. Voters this month approved at least 40 local ballot initiatives to restrict the facilities.
“The day of data center freeloading ends when this bill passes,” said Senator Sheldon Whitehouse, Democrat of Rhode Island and a co-author of the bill. “Data centers now have to pay for the extra costs that they bring to the grid when they come online. They do not get to have all that extra cost dumped out onto the utility’s rate base and picked up by all of the other ratepayers.”
(Excerpt) Read more at nytimes.com ...
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
The “tax” would merely prevent local consumers from being compelled to subsidize data center operators by paying higher electric bills.
It would seem to me that this is a state and local issue.
The feds should have no role.
The Democrats are going to single-handedly destroy the global financial markets. It’s all part of the plan. You may not like this whole datacenter charade, but if we don’t invest in compute capacity, American tech organizations are going to be hamstrung providing services which will reduce capacity, and that will lead to lower consumption by American and global businesses which will lead to reductions in force across the entire tech sector. That will ripple across all white- and blue-collar industries that rely on tech services. Logistics will stall, the flow of goods will slow, prices will increase as demand increases.
I’m going to predict that the global financial markets will look VERY different by 2028 and unrecognizable by 2030.
China be happy.
Miami Rebel wrote: “The “tax” would merely prevent local consumers from being compelled to subsidize data center operators by paying higher electric bills.”
Those local consumers will benefit from those data centers.
leftists blaming data centers for “high energy costs” is just cover for the consequences their own woke sheeple are experiencing from their disastrous green energy schemes
The trend is that data centers will generate their own power, or cut separate deals with utilities outside the existing grid
I think the stock market is currently propped up by inflated values of AI “investments”. It has to pop eventually because the return isn’t there. This will just accelerate the collapse.
The sad part is we have not trained at least one generation in critical thinking and moral behavior.
Only a fool would believe this protects rate payers. This is simply a gift to the big players to keep smaller competition out of the game. Any extra money from the data centers will go right into the pockets of the same people that raised your current rate through mandated wind and solar, “green” subsidies, and environmental lawfare.
Local utilities already have everything they need to recoup infrastructure costs from data centers. If your bills are going up look at your corrupt state legislature and your utility.
“Those local consumers will benefit from those data centers.’
A retired couple living on a fixed income would benefit how?
The impact of the data centers on electricity capacity is a multifaceted problem. Over the past 30 years the left has stopped the building of nuclear power plants and has forced the closure of much of the coal generation capacity which provided the excess supply required to support population and industrial growth. The promised future of green solar and wind power generation has proven to be a dud in practice - high capital costs and low output. As a result the nation no longer has the excess production capacity for electricity to surge in response to adverse weather conditions (cold or hot) much less supply power to new residential and industrial customers. Add to that the aging of the grid and the offshoring of production of key components of the grid and the ability to add capacity, or repair the grid, is measured in years instead of weeks or months.
The left will not adopt the shot term bandaid of stopping the closure of coal generation plants, which is still ongoing. It will not encourage a government/industry partnership in a crash program to both harden the grid against cyberattacks and EMP as well as bring back to America the production of key components of our electrical infrastructure. It will not fast track approval of new nuclear facilities. it will not end its opposition to new natural gas generation plants. It certainly will not permit new technology clean coal generation plants.
Needless to say the GOP has wasted its time in office with respect to stewardship of our electrical infrastructure. I certainly don’t expect to hear an alternative energy policy put forward as the left doubles down on green energy and shuts down the growth of AI, thereby ceding the lead in advanced technologies to China forever.
The US will march on to third world status. Ten years from now expect brownouts and blackouts to become common across the US. Unreliable electricity supply will not only be annoying to residential customers, it will result in the offshoring of the rest of any US business requiring reliable electrical supply. Think investment banks and their information systems, the stock market as well as the rest of our country’s manufacturing sector. When your focus is on managing supply, instead of growing supply, you typically get less supply and higher costs.
Data Centers come in many sizes. Many have been quietly in operation for years with little fanfare or fuss. They are there not mainly for AI/SI, but for co-location, disaster recovery, and to provide computing, storage and connectivity that can be scaled up of down for clients with a smaller capital outlay. Some dedicated ones are on the premises of the user (e.g. state governments, large corporate centers). I have worked in both types.
The new breed, largely dedicated to AI/SI, are much, much larger. So large, in fact that they often have their own power plants on the premises, which are often (but not always) away from population centers. In some cases, they are located near remote solar and wind farms, providing a more efficient use of remotely generated energy.
The water in these new ones is mostly recycled, like the coolant in an automobile. Whatever these data centers make will be taxed, but the companies know that energy costs being regulated differently is a risk. The companies don’t volunteer for it, but they will pay it, along with the labor, landscaping, construction, fuel, IT equipment, and liability costs. The possible returns are large, but the risks are real. The end product is a tool that can be used as any tool, like electricity or an internal combustion engine, for good, neutral or evil purposes.
The company spends lots of money to get people like me to work at sites that are either remote, or whose local population cannot provide enough of the right kind of talent for the work that needs to be done.
In my group at SpaceX in Memphis, we have an interesting combination of young black men, old guys like me who don’t seem to get the office positions in our home cities so easily anymore, and some (but not a huge number) of foreign labor from Latin America and countries like India. The composition of the construction crew (much more of them!) has different proportions of the same types, but is otherwise similar.
The irony of my AI/SI employer being accused of costing jobs is not lost on me, but I do know that the hurry to get these things built is two-fold: one, to beat upcoming restrictions, and two, to sell our product as soon as possible to paying customers, of which there is no shortage.
If the customers weren’t using these data centers for the output, they would be using smaller data centers or in-house equipment to do the job more expensively, and not as well.
That’s nonsense.
If you live in El Paso, Texas, and you’re paying 14.1¢/kWh, it makes no difference what the source of the power is so long as the price stays at 14.1¢.
The extra charge to the data centers won’t go to the pockets of anyone except whatever company is ever supplying power,
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.