Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: chickenlips

Baloney. Nothing “haunted” about it. It’s beautiful. And the massacre was a battle, 25 US Soldiers died. The new 7th Cav was well aware that Sioux had wiped out their unit a mere 14 years before. So were people on a hair trigger, yes.

But they refused to be disarmed, and a struggle started and everyone went cyclic when it popped. Nervous soldiers with institutional unit memory, freezing out in a plains blizzard for weeks.. they are not who you screw around with.

Tragic yes, but not some kind of genocidal massacre as it is made out to be.


4 posted on 02/07/2026 9:43:08 PM PST by DesertRhino (When men on the chessboard, get up and tell you where to go…)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]


To: DesertRhino
D. R. ; Everyone gets the "Bury my heart and the NPR version." Here is the other side.

"A blog dedicated to documenting through primary sources, the Army's actions at Wounded Knee."

Army at Wounded Knee

Includes pictures of the officers and most of the Muster lists and First Hand Written accounts. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

From the Omaha Bee, the death announcement of Indian Scout Little Bat, who was present at Wounded Knee.

(Written with 1890s newspaper rhetorical excess...)

“Little Bat” at Wounded knee....

“Little Bat’s” last prominent field service was in connection with the Sioux campaign of 1890-91. When Big Foot’s band was corralled at Wounded Knee creek by the Seventh cavalry he doubted the sincerity of the Indians, who had promised to surrender formally on the following day. He told Colonel Forsyth of his fears. The night passed without incident. With the break of day the camps of the troopers and soldiers were astir. Breakfast over, an order was issued that the redskins surrender their arms. This they refused or at least did not do. Thereupon they were commanded to stand in line and submit to a thorough search, as it was “Little Bat’s” belief that the weapons were concealed beneath the folds of the savages’ blankets.

The search had not begun when a medicine man, an aged rascal freshly painted for trouble, slipped before the lines of Indians and those of the soldiers. He began a chant which was full of meaning to “Little Bat.” It was the Sioux’s death song. That a tragedy was at hand there could be no doubt in the mind of this seasoned scout.

In vain did he try to catch the eye of his colonel, who was at the extreme end of one line. Suddenly the medicine man stooped, picked up a handful of snow and sand and flung it high in the air, at the same time ceasing his chant with a shrill cry.

“Look out!” yelled “Little Bat” to the soldiers, but before they could raise their carbines a murderous fire was turned upon them from the two columns of savages. For a moment or more the troopers were in a panic. They knew not which way to turn, so sudden was the attack. But the tide of battle was quick to turn and within thirty minutes over 200 dead and wounded Indians lay upon the field. Of the troopers thirty-five, including brave Captain Wallace, were killed outright and twice as many more were disabled—an awful penalty to pay for attaching so little importance to the suspicions of so experienced a scout as “Little Bat.” Garnier got out of the cross-fire of troops and savages by crawling on his hands and knees to an elevation where a four-inch gun was planted. Here he lay pumping his Winchester into the Indians as they fled for cover in the draws of the hills.

Since the campaign of 1890 the scout has been a familiar figure about Crawford, Chadron, Hay Springs and Oelrichs. He seldom got farther east than Valentine, which is near the Rosebud reservation. The meager press reports of his death show that he was slain by a saloon manager or bouncer. It may have been brought about by a quarrel over monte. “Little Bat” enjoyed the confidence of Generals Crook, Terry, Carr, Merritt and Miles and next to Frank Grouard was the foremost scout in the army. He was not a relative of Baptiste Pourier, who is known as “Big Bat” and who enjoys some distinction as a scout."

63 posted on 02/08/2026 1:24:40 PM PST by Pete from Shawnee Mission
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson