IMHO, harnesses are why dogs pull on a leash. My dog was started on a choker collar at <12 weeks. I am constantly complimented on how well she behaves. She never puts tension on the leash at all. Choker collars are extremely effective when used correctly. When used “angrily”, they are counter productive.
The overwhelming number of dogs I encounter that pull when leashed are wearing a harness.
AI....
Choke collars can be effective for training some dogs, but their use is controversial and depends on the dog, the trainer, and the situation. They work by tightening around the neck when the leash is pulled, applying pressure to correct behavior, often used for leash pulling or obedience training. Studies and expert opinions, like those from the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior, suggest they can reduce pulling in some dogs when used correctly, but improper use risks injury, fear, or aggression.
Pros: Can provide quick corrections, effective for strong or stubborn dogs in skilled hands.
Cons: Risk of tracheal damage, neck injuries, or behavioral issues if misused. Many trainers prefer positive reinforcement methods, like treats or harnesses, which studies show are often more effective long-term without risks.
Effectiveness varies: A 2019 study in Animals found positive reinforcement outperformed aversive tools like choke collars in reducing stress and improving learning in most dogs. Harsh breeds (e.g., German Shepherds) may respond better to firm control, while sensitive breeds (e.g., Collies) may become anxious.
Recommendation: If considering a choke collar, consult a certified trainer to ensure proper use or explore alternatives like front-clip harnesses or head halters, which are safer and often equally effective. Always prioritize the dog’s physical and emotional well-being.
_______________________________________
Hmm. I might reconsider a choke collar.