Peanut butter works well for me, too. Daughter-san’s cafeteria @ college, when we visited and went to church with said daughter yesterday, and then ate on a couple of her “guest passes” @ the dorm’s cafeteria, had these little cups of “chocolate spread”. It was “ok”, but I discovered it has a strong chocolate smell, and I’ve read soft chocolate can work well for bait too. So, I saved half a cup and am trying a bit out as bait this evening. :-)
Let us know what you catch. I have used cheese chunks from a sandwich myself.
Chocolate or Nutella would get ME trapped like a rat, LOL!