Posted on 06/06/2024 7:10:44 PM PDT by nickcarraway
I was told that the character Andy Garcia played was aborted in the book.
Oh, sorry, I thought you were talking about Michael’s kids. Yeah, you’re right. Lucy Mancini did abort Sonny’s kid in the book.
On a related note, I recall that Mario Puzo named the novel’s abortionist character Dr Jules Segal after his former colleague, fellow author Jules Siegel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jules_Siegel
I do think that with the abortion storylines in both the novel and movie, Puzo was making the point that abortion was homicide analogous to the murders of convenience carried out by the gangsters.
I couldn't stand the character (Kay), either, but Keaton must've played the role just as Coppola wanted her to. This site claims Mia Farrow, Blythe Danner, and Michelle Phillips (of the Mamas and Pappas) also were considered for the role.
My father is a Godfather aficionado who’s read all the books, the spinoff novelizations and anything else he could find. He claims that Kay had a miscarriage but told Michael it was an abortion to hurt him.
I agree with that 100% She played the part exactly as they wanted her to. I still hate watching all the parts of those movies with the whiny, rather stupid Kay character in them. That I got that kind of repellent reaction is probably just what Coppola and Mario Puzo wanted us to think about Kay. I read the book before I watched the Godfather and I don’t remember the Kay character being so hard to stand though. I think Diane Keaton in some ways brought that out in the movie.
I always did, too.
Damn skippy… TWICE each day…
Ridiculous criticism. She was playing a WASP, not an Italian-American. Very reserved, repressed, “bland” culture, perfectly expressed in her “naïve” comment to Michael. She nailed it.
The abortion reveal came at the end of Godfather I. Sonny's out-of-wedlock son (played by Andy Garcia) and Michael's son's career as an opera singer don't show up until Godfather III.
The criticisms of Sophia Coppola were terribly unfair. She was the perfect Italian-American princess—a daughter, not a movie star—the second generation born in America and third generation living in America. Anyone expecting her to look like a Northern European princess or speak like a goombah's camare was off base -- her looks were on point, and her speaking voice and accent were typical of the third generation who were sheltered and privileged.
Diane Keaton's role in Godfather III was seriously undermined by whomever styled her hair and clothing. Both were ridiculous—the cheap brassy perm, the flashy satin fabrics, the gold colors—and entirely out of character. A woman of Kay Adams' background would have been wearing Ralph Lauren and have a sleek blow dry hairstyle. Not her fault; but most unfortunate.
Maybe Sonny went back for more.
You nailed it. The storyline was deep; the trilogy was a significant piece of American literature, not just cheap entertainment.
Yeah, WASP culture is like that on TV and in the movies. In reality WASPs--an ignorant term, really--have as much culture as anyone else, and it's no more "bland" or "repressed" than any other culture, just different.
But what is bland? Is it just something you're used to seeing? Something you grew up around? I think so. There's nothing inherently bland about any culture, and nothing inherently rich or exciting.
Of COURSE some cultures are more bland than others. Just as some cultures are BETTER than others. Bland is not bad. I spent seven years in a prep school that was half-WASP, and grew up in Connecticut, which has plenty of WASPs.
I think of Harry Lime’s speech in the Third Man:
“Don’t be so gloomy. After all, it’s not that awful. Like the fella says, in Italy for 30 years under the Borgias they had warfare, terror, murder, and bloodshed, but they produced Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci, and the Renaissance. In Switzerland they had brotherly love - they had 500 years of democracy and peace, and what did that produce? The cuckoo clock. So long, Holly.”
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.