Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: DiogenesLamp; x; Bull Snipe; HandyDandy
DiogenesLamp: "Right back at you.
You and others keep trying to make the Declaration of Independence about slavery because you want to completely distract people from the fact it is about *INDEPENDENCE*."

Naw... that's nonsense, because the logic of Independence is simple -- we're equal to you, with God-given rights, which you've abused in horrible ways, so we are declaring independence.

Equality is the foundation on which the entire logic of independence is built.
To put that another way, if we were lesser beings equivalent to, say, livestock, then we must suffer whatever demands our superiors place on us.
But we're not, we're equal, and therefore can only be governed through our consent, the consent of the governed.

That's why equality is the foundation on which independence is built, and it's why nearly every Founder opposed slavery, at least in principle and in the long-term.

DiogenesLamp: "Why do you do this?
Because it contradicts your claimed belief that the South had no right to leave.
The very founding document of this nation says they absolutely had a right to leave, so you want to try to say the Declaration of Independence was about slavery."

Nooooo... our Declaration of Independence clearly and unequivocally spells out our "right to leave" as being conditional, based on the "parade of horribles" it lists:

In the simplest possible terms, the Declaration says to the King -- "you're not better than us, so we don't have to put up with your cr*p, so go to hell!"

So independence begins in equals suffering abuses, and the efforts of our Lost Causers to deny the importance of equality is more than a little grating on anyone who understands even a little about the subject.

DiogenesLamp: "It wasn't.
If you were honest you would admit that and just accept the fact that your side is legally and morally wrong about trying to stop people from having independence."

Sorry, but there's nothing honest in your attempts to compare the conditions of 1860 with those of 1776 -- they weren't even remotely comparable.
And there's nothing honest in your claims that the Declaration creates and unlimited "right of secession", because it does nothing of the sort.

Instead, the Declaration lays out dozens of conditions which justify independence, and not even one of those conditions existed in 1860.
All this is clearly spelled out by the Father of the Constitution, James Madison, in his proscription against secession "at pleasure", and that fully explains why in 1861, the Virginia delegation refused to declare secession for "light and transient causes", but instead waited until after war began at Fort Sumter to declare secession and war against the United States.

DiogenesLamp: "The Declaration of Independence is a *KNOCKOUT PUNCH* to your side, and this is why you keep trying to divert any discussion of it into "slavery."
It's dishonest, and your side needs to quit doing it."

Of course, you are simply referring to your own weak arguments here, and such diversions are all coming from your own side, as a review of this thread clearly shows.

DiogenesLamp's post #133 is the first time on this thread the Declaration of Independence is mentioned in this context.

181 posted on 04/11/2024 4:47:54 AM PDT by BroJoeK (future DDG 134 -- we remember)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 180 | View Replies ]


To: BroJoeK
Naw... that's nonsense, because the logic of Independence is simple -- we're equal to you, with God-given rights, which you've abused in horrible ways, so we are declaring independence.

Somehow this logic escaped the founders because they continued having slaves for "four score and seven years" after they signed the Declaration of *INDEPENDENCE*.

Wasn't about slavery. Wasn't intended to be about slavery. History revisionists have made it about slavery.

Was about *INDEPENDENCE* and how states had a right to it. That is all it was about.

Looked up the Magna Carta. The word "equals" is used in there eight times. Is it about slavery? Are they speaking of the slaves?

Can you be honest?

183 posted on 04/11/2024 3:38:22 PM PDT by DiogenesLamp ("of parents owing allegiance to no other sovereignty.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 181 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson